Manthan Swarm Learning Audit

Read the complete source appendix (124255 words)

20260612T090504Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T090504Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T090504Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T090504Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T090504Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T090504Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T090504Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T090504Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T090504Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T090504Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T090504Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T090504Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T090504Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T090504Z.tracker-trace.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Full-swarm host review has `swarm_health: OK` with one non-synthesized output flag (`reviewer_synthesis_detected=false`) and static/circular Lane-0 proof posture; local proof confirms tracker evidence is missing and action agents are unauthenticated, so P0 stays active and no phase advancement is authorized.

20260612T085206Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T085206Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T085206Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085206Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085206Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085206Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T085206Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T085206Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T085206Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T085206Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review remains advisory (`health: OK` but `reviewer_synthesis_detected=false`). Local proof re-validates core P0 blockers: no new writeable progress, compose validation-only proof, no loopback-boundary read-only posture, anchor naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, and blocked action-agent path. No phase advancement or Manthan product edits were authorized.

20260612T084351Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T084351Z`	`P0`	`OK`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T084351Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T084351Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T084351Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T084351Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T084351Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T084351Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T084351Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T084351Z.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host full-swarm contract passed (`health: OK`, `row_count: 23`, `error_rows: 0`, three substantive agents) with review-only execution mode. `Conduir loop P0` naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, and blocked action-agent auth remain unresolved blockers; no phase advancement or product edits were authorized.

20260612T083648Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T083648Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T083648Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083648Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083648Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083648Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083648Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T083648Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T083648Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T083648Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T083648Z.md`	`reviewer_synthesis_detected=false` blocked phase gating; boundary, naming, and action-agent blockers confirmed; no phase advancement in this cycle.

20260612T082706Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T082706Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T082706Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T082706Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T082706Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T082706Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T082706Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T082706Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T082706Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T082706Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T082706Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T082706Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review and local proof were read-only only. Degraded adjudication is due to expected `logs/.../swarm-db-audit.json` path mismatch plus unresolved Gate-0 blockers: `Conduir loop P0` naming drift, missing OS-O0 execution scripts, unresolved app-tier loopback posture evidence, and blocked action-agent auth (`gh`/`copilot`). No product files edited, no gate advancement.

20260612T081111Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T081111Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T081111Z-L0`, `L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T081111Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T081111Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T081111Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T081111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.host-binding.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.copilot-noop.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.docker-ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T081111Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T081111Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review remains advisory (`reviewer_synthesis_detected=false`) despite DB `health: OK`; local proof confirms `OS-O0` naming drift, stale script-presence artifact, missing OS-O0 scripts, unresolved outward boundary policy evidence, and auth/runtime blockers; no phase-advance was authorized.

20260612T041305Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T041305Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T041305Z-L0`, `L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T041305Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T041305Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T041305Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T041305Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.host-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T041305Z.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T041305Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T041305Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review remained advisory (`reviewer_synthesis_detected=false`) while `health: OK`; local proof confirms OS-O0 naming drift, missing smoke/selection scripts, unresolved app-tier loopback posture, and action-agent/runtime blockages, so P0 stayed active with no gate advancement.

20260612T040822Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T040822Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T040822Z-L0`, `L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040822Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040822Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040822Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040822Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T040822Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T040822Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-LEARNING-AUDIT.md`	Host-review output is degraded by `reviewer_synthesis_detected=false` despite `health: OK`; local proof remains review-only and confirms `Conduir loop P0` naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, unresolved app-tier loopback posture, and action-agent auth blockage, so P0 remains active.

20260612T040216Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T040216Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T040216Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040216Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040216Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040216Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T040216Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T040216Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T040216Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review health remained degraded because `reviewer_synthesis_detected=false` despite `health: OK`; local proof confirms `Conduir loop P0` naming conflict with `OS-O0`, missing OS-O0 scripts, unresolved app-tier loopback exposure, and review-only static proof posture, so `P0` remains active.

20260612T035627Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T035627Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T035627Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035627Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035627Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035627Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035627Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T035627Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T035627Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T035627Z.swarm.status`	DB-audit stayed `health: OK` but `reviewer_synthesis_detected=false`; local proof remains advisory-only and confirms naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, and app-tier loopback gaps, so no P0 phase-advance was authorized.

20260612T035150Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T035150Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T035150Z-L0`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035150Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035150Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035150Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035150Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T035150Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T035150Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T035150Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`	DB-audit shows `reviewer_synthesis_detected: false` in an otherwise valid output context; anchor naming/proof-posture, OS-O0 scripts, and action-agent auth blockers remain unresolved, so cycle is advisory only and P0 did not advance.

20260612T034544Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T034544Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T034544Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T034544Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T034544Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T034544Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T034544Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T034544Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T034544Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T034544Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-LEARNING-AUDIT.md`	Host review remained degraded for execution (reviewer synthesis missing), and local proof confirms OS-O0 naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, route/boundary uncertainty, and blocked action-agent auth; P0 remains active.

20260612T033315Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T033843Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T033843Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033843Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033843Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033843Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T033843Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033843Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033843Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T033843Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T033843Z.local-proof-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T033843Z.script-check.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Host wrapper is advisory-only (`reviewer_synthesis_detected: false`, one non-substantive row) and local proof confirms unresolved Lane 0 naming drift, missing OS-O0 scripts, and action-agent auth failure, so `P0` remains active and no phase-advancement is recorded.

20260612T033315Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T033315Z`	`P0`	`OK`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T033315Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T033315Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-LEARNING-AUDIT.md`	Full-swarm health is `OK` (12 findings, error_rows 1, no error-free synthesis flag), but selected proof still remains static and does not add P0 gate-exit evidence; `OS-O0` naming/phrase drift and missing tracker exit row remain active blockers for phase movement.

20260612T033315Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T033315Z`	`P0`	`OK`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T033315Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T033315Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T033315Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-LEARNING-AUDIT.md`	Full-swarm health is `OK` (12 findings, error_rows 1, no error-free synthesis flag), but selected proof still remains static and does not add P0 gate-exit evidence; `OS-O0` naming/phrase drift and missing tracker exit row remain active blockers for phase movement.

20260612T032552Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T032552Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T032552Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032552Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032552Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032552Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T032552Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T032552Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T032552Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T032552Z.local-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T032552Z.loopback-bindings.txt`	Host-review evidence remains non-actionable due degraded contract; local proof confirms OS-O0 naming mismatch, app-tier loopback gap, missing OS-O0 scripts, and tracker exit row absence at P0.

20260611T231206Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T231206Z`	`P0`	`OK`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260611T231206Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`	`manthan-phase-20260611T231206Z-L5`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T231206Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T231206Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T231206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T231206Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T231206Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T231206Z.md`	Host review remained review-only and healthy enough for tracker proof, but still did not create a new exit artifact: `Conduir loop P0` naming and app-tier outward boundary drift remain, one action-agent blocker persists, and no Manthan product edit was authorized.

20260611T222747Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T222747Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260611T222747Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; accepted controller: `L0`	rejected: none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222747Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T222747Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222747Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T222747Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222747Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222747Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host review was `DEGRADED` (no reviewer synthesis quorum); local proof confirms boundary posture unresolved, OS-O0 scripts absent, action-agent auth/compose health probes fail by environment, and no product edits or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T222041Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T222041Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260611T222041Z-L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`; rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T222041Z-L1`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T222041Z-L1`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222041Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T222041Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222041Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T222041Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222041Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222041Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host review produced usable local findings but is treated as degraded for execution safety due review-audit synthesis mismatch. Deterministic local proof confirmed that the cycle objective remained circular-anchor-based, OS-O0 scripts are absent, and app-tier compose boundaries remain unresolved. P0 stays active and no phase advancement occurred.

20260611T183225Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T183225Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T183225Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`; phase-candidate: `L9`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T183225Z-L10`, `L11`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T183225Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T183225Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T183225Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T183225Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T183225Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 17 analysis rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero except `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while the direction doc names `OS-O0`; the direction doc is tracked but self-labels uncommitted; root smoke/selection executables are absent; app-tier boundary remains incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; Docker live-health proof and GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes fail. A blocked `MAQ-024` anchor OS-O0 packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T180459Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T180459Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T180459Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T180459Z-L7`, `L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T180459Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T180459Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T180459Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T180459Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host review was degraded: status `0`, wrapper DB audit `DEGRADED`, 9 analysis rows, one audit-counted error row, only `claude` usable, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but live Docker proof fails with socket `operation not permitted`; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while the direction doc names `OS-O0`; root smoke and selection executables are absent; app-tier ports remain without `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; tracker loop grep has 7 generic/historical lines and no current exit-evidence row. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T175131Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T175131Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T175131Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T175131Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T175131Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T175131Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T175131Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T175131Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T175131Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 18 analysis rows, zero audit-counted error rows, at least two substantive agents, and reviewer output present. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while the direction doc names `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary remains incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; Docker live-health proof and GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes fail. A blocked `MAQ-002` root-smoke packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T161828Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`, `L8`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 22 analysis rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer output present. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary remains incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; Docker live-health proof and GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes fail. Reviewer ranked root smoke script creation as the separate better next lane, but no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T154317Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T154317Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T154317Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L8`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T154317Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T154317Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T154317Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T154317Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T154317Z.compose-proof.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T154317Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T154317Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 30 analysis rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer output present. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary and backend guardrail env remain incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines. GitHub/Copilot probes fail, so `MAQ-024` is blocked by action-agent authentication. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T151436Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T151436Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T151436Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T151436Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T151436Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T151436Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T151436Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T151436Z.compose-proof.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T151436Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T151436Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 28 analysis rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer output present. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary and backend guardrail env remain incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines. GitHub/Copilot probes fail, so `MAQ-024` is blocked by action-agent authentication. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T134000Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T134000Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T134000Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T134000Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T134000Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T134000Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T134000Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T134000Z.compose-proof.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T134000Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 13 analysis rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor is committed, still says `Conduir loop P0`, and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary and app-tier guardrail env remain incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual action-agent substitution, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T124705Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T124705Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T124705Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T124705Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T124705Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T124705Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T124705Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T124705Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host review was degraded: status `0`, wrapper DB audit `DEGRADED`, seven analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes; anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`; root smoke and selection executables are absent; app-tier ports remain without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; architecture scan has 417 lines but no live endpoint smoke. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T120214Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T120214Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T120214Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L6`, `L8`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T120214Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T120214Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T120214Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T120214Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T120214Z.maq-026-gate-path-scope-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T120214Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 21 analysis rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes but remains non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary and app-tier guardrail env remain incomplete; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; GitHub/Copilot probes fail. The gate-path finding was corrected: `CLAUDE.md` is stale, `README.md` is not. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T092021Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T092021Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T092021Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L10`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T092021Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T092021Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T092021Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T092021Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T092021Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 15 analysis rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root and `infra/compose` static config checks pass but remain non-smoke evidence; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary remains unresolved; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 52 lines; GitHub/Copilot probes fail. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T083745Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T083745Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T083745Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T083745Z-L7`, `L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T083745Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T083745Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T083745Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T083745Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host review was degraded: status `0`, wrapper DB audit `DEGRADED`, six analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; root compose static validation passes; the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`; root smoke and selection executables are absent; app-tier ports remain without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 42 lines; NATS/HERALD/MCP/bridge/signal/lineage claims were scanned but not live-smoked. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T082143Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T082143Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T082143Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`; phase-candidate: `L9`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T082143Z-L10`, `L11`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T082143Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T082143Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T082143Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T082143Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T082143Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 14 analysis rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: direct DB replay found product/progress tables zero; Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passes as static validation only; the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still says `Conduir loop P0`, and lacks run/DB/proof/tracker linkage; root smoke/selection executable checks fail; app-tier boundary remains unresolved; route proof has 53 lines; status proof has 52 lines; GitHub/Copilot probes fail. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual action-agent substitution, or phase advancement occurred; a blocked `MAQ-024` anchor-auditability packet was emitted.

20260611T041323Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T041323Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T041323Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T041323Z-L7`, `L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T041323Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T041323Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T041323Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T041323Z.maq-025-tracker-linkage-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T041323Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 13 analysis rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passes as static validation only, `docker compose -f ...` fails on this host, the anchor exists but is absent from `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md`, root smoke/selection executables are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, route proof has 53 lines, and `copilot -p` is unauthenticated. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred; a blocked `MAQ-025` tracker-linkage packet was emitted.

20260611T035954Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T035954Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260611T035954Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T035954Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T035954Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T035954Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T035954Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T035954Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T035954Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reports `OK`: 15 analysis rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output. Current proof keeps P0 active: `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passes as static validation only, the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, root smoke/selection executables are absent, direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, and route proof has 53 lines. The reviewer corrected the integration-doc `infra/compose` literal claim as overstated. `copilot -p` is unauthenticated, so no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred; a blocked `MAQ-024` one-file patch packet was emitted.

20260611T034458Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`; phase-candidate: `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L7`, `L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper and DB audit classify the review as `DEGRADED`: six analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), unparsed `deepseek`/session-limit `claude`, and missing reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory for action: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; static root/infra compose validation passes; P0 checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke, selection, literal `infra/compose`, and direction-doc self-status; app-tier boundary remains unresolved; route/status proof remains present; `.cbor` scan is empty; env/compose drift is advisory only; and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T030518Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T030518Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T030518Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`; phase-candidate: `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T030518Z-L7`, `L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T030518Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T030518Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T030518Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T030518Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper and DB audit classify the review as `DEGRADED`: six analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), unparsed `deepseek`/session-limit `claude`, and missing reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory for action: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean; static root/infra compose validation passes; P0 checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke, selection, literal `infra/compose`, and direction-doc self-status; app-tier boundary remains unresolved; route/status proof remains present; `.cbor` scan is empty; env/compose drift is advisory only; and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T025233Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T025233Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T025233Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`; phase-candidate: `L6`, `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T025233Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T025233Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T025233Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T025233Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T025233Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reported `OK` with 16 analysis rows and substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, but the operator downgraded the cycle to `DEGRADED` because the REVIEW body is a Claude session-limit message. Local proof is advisory for action: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root/infra compose validation passes, P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke, selection, literal `infra/compose`, and direction-doc self-status, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, route/status proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty, env/compose drift is advisory only, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T024215Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T024215Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T024215Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`; phase-candidate: `L6`, `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T024215Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T024215Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T024215Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T024215Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T024215Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper and DB audit classified the review as `DEGRADED`: six analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and reviewer synthesis missing/session-limit. Local proof is advisory for action: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root/infra compose validation passes, P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke, selection, and literal `infra/compose`, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, route/status proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty, env/compose drift is advisory only, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T014046Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T014046Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T014046Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T014046Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T014046Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T014046Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T014046Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T014046Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host status returned `0` and wrapper audit reported `OK`, but the operator classified the review as `DEGRADED` because `reviewer_synthesis_detected` is false and the reviewer body is a Claude session-limit message. Local proof is advisory for action: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root/infra compose validation passes, P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke, and selection, the integration doc lacks literal `infra/compose`, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, route/status proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T012934Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T012934Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T012934Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T012934Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T012934Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T012934Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T012934Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T012934Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper and DB audit classified the review as `DEGRADED`: six analysis rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and reviewer synthesis missing/session-limit. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root/infra compose validation passes, anchor `OS-O0`, smoke, selection, boundary, status-drift, CBOR, and integration-doc `infra/compose` literal checks remain open, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T011725Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T011725Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T011725Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`; phase-candidate: `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T011725Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T011725Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T011725Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T011725Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T011725Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper and DB audit classified the review as `DEGRADED`: only `gemini` produced substantive findings, `deepseek`/`claude` were unparsed or session-limit output, and reviewer synthesis was missing. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root/infra compose validation passes, anchor `OS-O0`, smoke, selection, boundary, CBOR, and integration-doc `infra/compose` literal checks remain open, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260611T010620Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260611T010620Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted local/controller: `manthan-phase-20260611T010620Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260611T010620Z-L8`, `L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T010620Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T010620Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T010620Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T010620Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, 16 analysis rows, two error rows, and substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, but `reviewer_synthesis_detected` is false and the reviewer body is a session-limit message, so the operator downgraded the cycle to degraded. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static root and infra compose validation pass, anchor `OS-O0`, smoke, selection, boundary, CBOR, and action-agent gates remain open, GitHub/Copilot auth failed, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T234416Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T234416Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T234416Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L8`, `L9`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260610T234416Z-L10`, `L11`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T234416Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T234416Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T234416Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T234416Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T234416Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 18 `analysis_findings` with substantive `deepseek`/`gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current proof keeps P0 active: selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress, app-tier root boundary is unresolved, infra compose exposure is separate, anchor `OS-O0` checks fail, root smoke/selection executables and CBOR vectors are absent, and GitHub/Copilot auth failed. A blocked `MAQ-001` action packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T214448Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T214448Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T214448Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L8`; phase-candidate: `L7`, `L9`	rejected: `manthan-phase-20260610T214448Z-L10`, `L11`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T214448Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T214448Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T214448Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T214448Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T214448Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 15 `analysis_findings` with substantive `deepseek`/`gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current proof keeps P0 active: anchor/static proof is config-validation only, the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, root app-tier boundary remains unresolved, infra compose has secondary exposure, root smoke/selection executables and CBOR vectors are absent, target linkage hits are incidental/non-gating, and GitHub/Copilot auth failed. A blocked `MAQ-024` action packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T205023Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T205023Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T205023Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L8`	superseded: `manthan-phase-20260610T205023Z-L9`; rejected: `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T205023Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T205023Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T205023Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T205023Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T205023Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 21 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current proof keeps P0 active: the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while committed direction requires `OS-O0`, static compose validation passes but is not smoke proof, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty, and GitHub/Copilot auth failed. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T200818Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T200818Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T200818Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L8`; phase-candidate: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T200818Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T200818Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T200818Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T200818Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T200818Z.maq-002-scope-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T200818Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 23 `analysis_findings` across `deepseek`, `claude`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Reviewer consensus rejects static anchor/compose proof as P0 progress and identifies absent root-smoke and selection scripts as the real OS-O0 deliverable gap; live smoke remains blocked by unresolved app-tier boundary posture and Copilot product action remains unavailable despite passing `gh auth status`. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T193228Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T193228Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T193228Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T193228Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T193228Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T193228Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T193228Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T193228Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 8 analysis rows and reviewer synthesis, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Reviewer synthesis says the committed Lane 0 anchor action is already done, the anchor grep proof is tautological, root `config -q` is static validation rather than smoke, and `infra/compose` support was not exercised. The controller added `test -d infra/compose` and `docker-compose -f infra/compose/docker-compose.yml config -q` to the P0 gate set and validated both at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T185318Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T185318Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T185318Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T185318Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T185318Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T185318Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T185318Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T185318Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 23 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current proof keeps `MAQ-024` blocked and P0 active: the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while committed direction requires `OS-O0`, static compose validation passes but is not smoke proof, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, target tracker linkage is absent, and `copilot -p` fails with `No authentication information found`; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T183717Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T183717Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T183717Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T183717Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T183717Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T183717Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T183717Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T183717Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 13 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `gemini`, and one unparsed `deepseek` row plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. The controller wrote the pre-action queue row and invoked Copilot for exactly `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; Copilot's edit/write attempts were denied, so no Manthan product file changed. Current proof keeps `MAQ-024` open: the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0`, static compose validation passes but is not smoke proof, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, persisted `gh auth status` reports invalid configured tokens, and no endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T182306Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T182306Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T182306Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T182306Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T182306Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T182306Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T182306Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T182306Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 26 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current proof rejects nested DB-empty/controller-inaccessible claims, keeps the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof as false progress, verifies the anchor `Conduir loop P0` vs committed `OS-O0` direction mismatch, confirms unresolved app-tier boundary and absent root smoke/selection scripts, and blocks all Manthan product edits because persisted GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes fail. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T181050Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T181050Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T181050Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T181050Z-L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T181050Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T181050Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T181050Z.maq-024-advisory-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T181050Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded despite status `0`: wrapper DB audit reports `DEGRADED`, seven analysis rows, one substantive agent, two error/unparsed rows, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static compose validation passes, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, route/surface proof includes signal/elites/lineage/MCP/bridge references but no root smoke exercises them, smoke/selection scripts are absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, GitHub/Copilot auth fails, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T170237Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T170237Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T170237Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`, `L9`; phase-candidate: `L8`	reviewer-refuted claims preserved in `L6` and `L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T170237Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T170237Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T170237Z.maq-002-scope-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T170237Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 12 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Reviewer consensus rejected the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof as false progress and pointed to OS-O0 smoke proof; current proof shows the anchor/static checks pass, root smoke and selection executable gates are absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T150148Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T150148Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T150148Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T150148Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T150148Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T150148Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T150148Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T150148Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 24 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-head proof kept P0 active: selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, direction/anchor status and naming drift remain current, smoke/selection scripts and CBOR vectors are absent, and the GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T131445Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T131445Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T131445Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`; phase-candidate: `L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T131445Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T131445Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T131445Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T131445Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T131445Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 20 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-head proof kept P0 active: selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress, target-facing anchor/direction naming drift remains current, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, smoke/selection scripts and CBOR vectors are absent, `gh auth status` now passes, but `copilot -p` is unauthenticated. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T105945Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T105945Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T105945Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`; phase-candidate: `L6`, `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T105945Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T105945Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T105945Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T105945Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T105945Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 28 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: anchor/static proof is tautological, app-tier boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, smoke/selection scripts are absent, target tracker linkage is absent, the committed direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted and conflicts with the anchor naming, GitHub/Copilot auth fails, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T104719Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L8`, `L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded despite status `0`: wrapper DB audit reports `DEGRADED`, 10 analysis rows, missing reviewer synthesis, and host output says only one usable voice. Local proof is advisory only: Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89` is clean, static compose validation passes, the anchor/static proof remains false progress, direction/anchor naming drift remains (`OS-O0` required vs `Conduir loop P0`), app-tier boundary is unresolved and route-significant, smoke/selection scripts are absent, GitHub/Copilot auth fails, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T100548Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T100548Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T100548Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T100548Z-L8`, `L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T100548Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T100548Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T100548Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T100548Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 23 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. HEAD freshness proof superseded stale untracked-direction findings: Manthan is now at `a3e1e89` with clean status, though the committed direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted. Current proof keeps P0 active: anchor/static proof is tautological, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, smoke/selection scripts are absent, target tracker linkage is absent, GitHub/Copilot auth fails, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T084555Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T084555Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T084555Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; phase-candidate: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T084555Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T084555Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T084555Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T084555Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T084555Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 43 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer synthesis in host output, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof as false progress, app-tier loopback boundary as unresolved, root smoke and selection scripts as absent, the direction draft as untracked non-authority, and GitHub/Copilot auth as invalid. A blocked `MAQ-002` root-smoke packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T082228Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T082228Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T082228Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T082228Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T082228Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T082228Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T082228Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded to one usable agent voice despite status `0`, so the cycle cannot claim consensus or authorize product edits. Local proof is advisory only: static compose validation passes, the committed anchor proof already passes before action, the Manthan tracker lacks loop P0/OS-O0 exit linkage, app-tier boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, GitHub/Copilot auth is invalid, and no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T074131Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T074131Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T074131Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; local-cycle-only: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T074131Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T074131Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T074131Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T074131Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded to one substantive agent (`gemini`) plus unparsed `claude` and `deepseek` rows, so the cycle cannot claim consensus or authorize product edits. Local proof is advisory only: static compose validation passes, app-tier boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked non-authority, and no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T064716Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L1`, `L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`; local-cycle-only: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T064716Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T064716Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded to one substantive agent (`gemini`) plus unparsed `claude` and `deepseek` rows, so the cycle cannot claim consensus or authorize product edits. Local proof is advisory only: static compose validation passes, `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked non-authority, app-tier boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, smoke/selection scripts are absent, latest persisted GitHub/Copilot probes fail authentication, and no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T063114Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`, `L9`; phase-candidate: `L4`, `L5`	`manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T063114Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T063114Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 13 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `gemini`, and one unparsed `deepseek` row plus reviewer evidence, but no cycle/execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof as false progress, the target-side anchor as missing P0 exit gates/tracker linkage, `infra/compose` terminology as drifted, the direction draft as untracked non-authority, app-tier boundary as unresolved, smoke/selection scripts as absent, and Copilot/GitHub authentication as unavailable. A blocked `MAQ-024` packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T061434Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T061434Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T061434Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L6`, `L7`, `L8`, `L9`; phase-candidate: `L5`	`manthan-phase-20260610T061434Z-L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T061434Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T061434Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T061434Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T061434Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 21 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no cycle/execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof as false progress, the direction draft as untracked non-authority, the draft's loopback-boundary claim as false if adopted, app-tier boundary as unresolved, smoke/selection scripts as absent, and Copilot/GitHub authentication as unavailable. A blocked `MAQ-023` packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T051700Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T051700Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T051700Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`, `L8`; phase-candidate: `L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T051700Z-L9`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T051700Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T051700Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T051700Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T051700Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 22 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed app-tier loopback boundary as the concrete top action, static anchor/compose proof as false progress, absent smoke/selection scripts, untracked nonblocking direction-draft drift, low-risk doc drift, and missing callable product-edit action lane. A refreshed `MAQ-001` packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T050154Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T050154Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T050154Z-L1`, `L2`, `L4`, `L5`, `L7`, `L8`, `L9`; phase-candidate: `L6`	`manthan-phase-20260610T050154Z-L3`, `L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T050154Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T050154Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T050154Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T050154Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 27 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Direct DB inspection rejected the DB-empty critical claim. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed app-tier loopback boundary as the concrete high-risk action, static anchor/compose proof as non-exit evidence, absent smoke/selection scripts, untracked nonblocking direction-draft drift, and missing callable product-edit action lane. A refreshed `MAQ-001` packet was emitted; no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T034001Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T034001Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T034001Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T034001Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T034001Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T034001Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T034001Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 13 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress because it revalidates the already committed anchor and static YAML only. The untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` draft remains drift evidence rather than adopted authority; app-tier loopback posture and smoke/selection gates remain unresolved; `gh auth status` passed but the available Copilot CLI exposes no product-edit command. No Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T032644Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T032644Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T032644Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T032644Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T032644Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T032644Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T032644Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T032644Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy host review produced 31 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. The reviewer selected the app-tier loopback boundary as the highest-value concrete action; current proof reconfirmed ports `47000`, `47001`, `47002`, `47003`, and `27000` lack `host_ip`, route-significant write/admin surfaces exist, smoke/selection scripts are absent, and the selected anchor/static proof remains false progress. GitHub auth passed and Copilot CLI exists, but no callable Copilot product-edit lane is exposed, so no Manthan product edit, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T024945Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T024945Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T024945Z-L1`..`L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T024945Z-L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T024945Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T024945Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T024945Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review coverage produced 10 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `gemini`, and one unparsed `deepseek` row plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: the selected anchor/static compose proof is false progress, `MAQ-022` env/dependency drift remains current, app-tier loopback boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, the untracked direction draft remains scope/adoption drift, smoke/selection scripts are absent, and Manthan product edits are blocked by the missing Copilot action lane.

20260610T023717Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T023717Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted mechanical/controller: `manthan-phase-20260610T023717Z-L1`..`L2`; phase-candidate advisory: `L3`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T023717Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T023717Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T023717Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T023717Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm degraded with one substantive agent (`gemini`), two error/unparsed rows, and no DB-detected reviewer synthesis. Local proof is advisory only: static compose validation passes, app-tier loopback boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, the untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed anchor if adopted and overclaims boundary posture, smoke/selection scripts are absent, and no Manthan product edit, Copilot action, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T022318Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T022318Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T022318Z-L1`..`L9`	`manthan-phase-20260610T022318Z-L10`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T022318Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T022318Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T022318Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review coverage produced 22 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: anchor/static compose proof remains non-advancing, app-tier loopback boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, the untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed anchor and overclaims boundary posture, smoke/selection scripts are absent, `MAQ-022` remains current, and Manthan product edits are blocked by the missing Copilot action lane.

20260610T020719Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T020719Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T020719Z-L1`..`L8`	`manthan-phase-20260610T020719Z-L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T020719Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T020719Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T020719Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review coverage produced 19 `analysis_findings` across `deepseek`, `gemini`, and one `claude` error row plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: anchor/static compose proof is non-advancing, app-tier loopback boundary remains unresolved, the untracked direction draft overclaims that boundary while using intentional OS-O0 naming, smoke/selection scripts are absent, `MAQ-022` remains current, `docker compose` v2 is unavailable, and Manthan product edits are blocked by the missing Copilot action lane.

20260610T011502Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T011502Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T011502Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T011502Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T011502Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T011502Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T011502Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review produced 10 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `gemini`, and one unparsed `deepseek` row plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: app-tier ports still lack loopback `host_ip`, smoke/selection scripts are absent, the untracked direction draft remains adoption drift, `config -q` is static-only, `MAQ-022` remains current, and product edits are blocked by the missing Copilot action lane. Reviewer refuted the broad root-vs-`infra/compose` conflict as stated.

20260610T010226Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T010226Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T010226Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T010226Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T010226Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T010226Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T010226Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review produced 26 `analysis_findings` across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini` plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof kept P0 active: the 8-line anchor remains non-exit evidence, the untracked direction draft is drift rather than authority, app-tier ports still lack loopback `host_ip`, smoke/selection scripts are absent, the `MAQ-022` env/dependency defect remains current, and product edits are blocked by the missing Copilot action lane. No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T003906Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T003906Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T003906Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T003906Z-L8`, `manthan-phase-20260610T003906Z-L9`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T003906Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T003906Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T003906Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy Lane 0 review reconfirmed that the committed anchor already exists at Manthan HEAD `2408120`, so anchor/static compose proof is satisfied but under-proves P0 and cannot advance the phase. The cycle recorded untracked direction-draft tree drift, static-only compose proof, absent smoke/selection scripts, unresolved app-tier loopback posture, and rejected operator cleanup of the untracked draft because it was outside the authorized write set. No Manthan product edit, Copilot action, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260610T002819Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T002819Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T002819Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260610T002819Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T002819Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T002819Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T002819Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy Lane 0 review confirmed the anchor is already landed at Manthan HEAD `2408120`, so re-running anchor/static compose proof would be false progress rather than P0 exit evidence. The anchor commit also bundled an unrelated lockfile. The untracked direction draft is low housekeeping, not current phase authority. Smoke and selection executable checks failed, app-tier loopback posture remains unresolved, no Manthan product edit ran, and P0 stayed active with `MAQ-001` still the next product-action packet.

20260610T001121Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260610T001121Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260610T001121Z-L1`..`L6`, `L9`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260610T001121Z-L7`	`manthan-phase-20260610T001121Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T001121Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T001121Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T001121Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T001121Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review produced 26 analysis findings across three agents plus reviewer evidence, but no execution/evaluation/promotion rows. Current-HEAD proof rejected the selected Lane 0 anchor/config proof as insufficient, ranked the app-tier loopback boundary as the next exact-write-set action, confirmed smoke/selection scripts are absent, re-scoped `MAQ-022` to a medium env-override footgun, and blocked product edits because no Copilot action lane is callable. P0 stayed active and a `MAQ-001` patch packet was emitted.

20260609T235711Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T235711Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T235711Z-L1`..`L4`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260609T235711Z-L5`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T235711Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T235711Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T235711Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T235711Z.maq-022-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T235711Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review and current-HEAD proof selected `MAQ-022` as the next scoped action: `api` and `maestro-bridge` miss six inherited budget/gateway env keys and `api` lacks `nats` in `depends_on`. No Manthan product edit ran because the configured Copilot action lane is unavailable; an actionable patch packet was emitted, P0 stayed active, and phase advancement was blocked by absent product edit, unresolved boundary, absent smoke/selection scripts, untracked direction draft, and no endpoint smoke.

20260609T223715Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T223715Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T223715Z-L1`..`L2`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260609T223715Z-L3`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260609T223715Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T223715Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T223715Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T223715Z-learning-artifact.json`	Host swarm review degraded to one substantive agent despite exit status `0`; local proof reconfirmed static compose pass, unresolved app-tier boundary, absent smoke/selection scripts, current `MAQ-022` env-default defect, anchor/draft naming drift, and unproved architecture/runtime claims. No Manthan product edit, Copilot action, or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T221254Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T221254Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T221254Z-L1`..`L5`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260609T221254Z-L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T221254Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T221254Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T221254Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T221254Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review-only cycle: DB audit was OK with reviewer synthesis and 21 analysis findings, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. Current-HEAD proof reconfirmed the `api`/`maestro-bridge` env-default merge defect, unresolved app-tier loopback boundary, absent smoke/selection scripts, and non-exit 8-line anchor. `MAQ-022` is the next bounded compose action candidate; no Manthan product edit, Copilot action, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T215100Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T215100Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T215100Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T215100Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T215100Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T215100Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T215100Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review-only cycle: DB audit was OK with reviewer synthesis from host output and 11 analysis findings, but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows. The Lane 0 anchor proof remains tautological against the existing 8-line anchor, static compose validation passed without live endpoint smoke, current HEAD still has untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`, and read-only compose replay verified the `MAQ-022` env-default candidate without authorizing a product edit or phase advancement.

20260609T212502Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T212502Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T212502Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260609T212502Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T212502Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T212502Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T212502Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed another review-only P0 cycle: the DB has 11 analysis findings but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows, the Lane 0 anchor proof is still tautological against an existing 8-line anchor, static compose validation passes but smoke and selection executable gates are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, the prior anchor commit included an unrelated package-lock file, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T210716Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T210716Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T210716Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260609T210716Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T210716Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T210716Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T210716Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed the cycle is still review-only: the DB has 21 analysis findings but no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows, the Lane 0 anchor proof is tautological, static compose validation passes, smoke and selection executable gates are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T204802Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T204802Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T204802Z-L1`..`L5`	`manthan-phase-20260609T204802Z-L6`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T204802Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T204802Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T204802Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review again confirmed the selected Lane 0 anchor proof is a self-referential no-op: Manthan HEAD `2408120` is clean, the anchor proof passes before product action, compose validation is static only, and no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, Copilot edit, or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T201108Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T201108Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T201108Z-L1`..`L5`	`manthan-phase-20260609T201108Z-L6`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T201108Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T201108Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T201108Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T201108Z.reaudit.json`	Healthy review confirmed the selected Lane 0 anchor proof is no-op false progress; controller-side MAQ-021 was executed by adding and validating a concrete `CYCLE_SWARM_DB_AUDIT_JSON` health proof to P0 gates; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T193029Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T193029Z`	`P0`	`OK`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T193029Z-L1`..`L5`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260609T193029Z-L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T193029Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T193029Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T193029Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T193029Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed this cycle is still review-only: wrapper audit is OK, DB inspection found 9 analysis rows and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows, the committed anchor proof is tautological, P0 has no concrete DB-audit proof command in the selected proof list, the target tracker has no anchor linkage, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T185501Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T185501Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T185501Z-L1`..`L7`	`manthan-phase-20260609T185501Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T185501Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T185501Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T185501Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed this cycle is still review-only: wrapper audit is OK, DB inspection found 33 analysis rows and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective rows, the committed anchor remains an 8-line non-exit-evidence stub with no tracker reference, static compose validation passes but smoke/selection executables are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T164322Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L1`..`L6`, `L9`	`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T164322Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T164322Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed another review-only P0 cycle: host status and DB audit are OK, DB inspection found 21 analysis rows and no execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution rows, the staged optional anchor remains absent from Manthan `HEAD`, integration-doc and static compose proof pass, smoke/selection scripts are absent, Copilot action auth is unavailable, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T154805Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T154805Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T154805Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T154805Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T154805Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T154805Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T154805Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed another review-only P0 cycle: host status and DB audit are OK, DB inspection found 15 analysis rows and no execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution rows, the staged optional anchor remains absent from Manthan `HEAD`, `docker-compose config -q` is static validation only, smoke/selection scripts are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, Copilot action auth is unavailable, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T151642Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T151642Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T151642Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T151642Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T151642Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T151642Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T151642Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed another review-only P0 cycle: the DB audit is OK and has 20 analysis rows but no execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution rows; the reviewed proof still targets a staged optional anchor absent from Manthan `HEAD`; integration-doc and static compose proof pass; smoke/selection scripts are absent; app-tier boundary remains unresolved; Copilot token variables are unset; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T141025Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T141025Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T141025Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T141025Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T141025Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T141025Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T141025Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed this remains review-only: host status and DB audit are OK, Python DB inspection found 20 analysis rows across three agents and no execute/evolution rows, the staged optional anchor is absent from `HEAD`, the packet still targets optional-anchor proof while current controls target the integration doc, integration-doc/static-compose proof passes, smoke/selection scripts are absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, Copilot product action auth is unavailable, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T132104Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T132104Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T132104Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T132104Z-L7`, `manthan-phase-20260609T132104Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T132104Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T132104Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T132104Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed this remains review-only: host status and DB audit are OK, Python DB inspection found 24 analysis rows across three agents and no execute/evolution rows, the packet still proves untracked optional-anchor evidence, integration-doc/static-compose proof passes, smoke/selection scripts are absent, Copilot action auth is unset, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T122541Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T122541Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T122541Z-L1`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T122541Z-L7`, `manthan-phase-20260609T122541Z-L8`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T122541Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T122541Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T122541Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed the cycle is still review-only: the packet targets an untracked optional anchor, live DB inspection has 32 analysis rows but no execute/evolution rows, integration-doc/static-compose proof passes, smoke/selection scripts remain absent, Copilot action auth is unset, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T104437Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	accepted: `manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z-L1`, `manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z-L2`; phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z-L3`..`L6`	`manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z-L7`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T104437Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T104437Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T104437Z-learning-artifact.json`	DB audit degraded the host review to one substantive agent and no reviewer synthesis; local proof reconfirmed packet/source drift, passing integration-doc/static-compose proof, failed optional-anchor proof, unresolved app-tier boundary, absent smoke/selection scripts, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.

20260609T100736Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z-L1`, `manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z-L2`, `manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z-L3`	`manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z-L5`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T100736Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T100736Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T100736Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed this is still review-only: the packet again used the optional anchor-file proof, the integration-doc/static-compose proof passes locally, smoke/selection scripts remain absent, and no Manthan product edit or phase advancement occurred.

20260609T074133Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z-L1`, `manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z-L2`, `manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z-L3`	`manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z-L4`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T074133Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T074133Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T074133Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review confirmed the repeated Lane 0 packet is review-only: the optional loop-anchor proof fails, the integration-doc proof path is the non-circular alternative, and no execute/evolution DB rows or Manthan product edits exist.

20260609T071745Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260609T071745Z`	`P0`	`OK`	`manthan-phase-20260609T071745Z-L1`, `manthan-phase-20260609T071745Z-L2`	`deepseek/unparsed`	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T071745Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T071745Z-learning-artifact.json`	Healthy review blocked phase advancement and Manthan product edits because the candidate proof targeted absent optional `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` and the write set was undeclared; next cycle should use the integration-doc Lane 0 proof or declare an anchor-doc write set first.

Date opened: 2026-06-08
Target repo: manthan
Control tracker: delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md

Purpose

This ledger records learning promoted by the Manthan 24-month swarm loop. A finding, hypothesis, patch rationale, transfer artifact, or negative result cannot influence later phases unless it is recorded here or in a referenced cycle audit file.

Promotion Rules

Promotion	Meaning	Can affect future phase?
`none`	Observation only.	No
`local-cycle-only`	Explains the current cycle only.	No
`phase-candidate`	May be reviewed by a later cycle.	Not until validated
`cross-swarm-quarantine`	May be shared to another swarm only as replayable evidence.	Not until replayed
`accepted`	Has proof and safety classification.	Yes

Minimum Audit Fields

Each accepted learning needs:

stable learning id;
source agent or proof command;
falsifiable claim;
evidence path or command summary;
validation result;
safety classification;
promotion decision;
status.

Ledger

UTC	Run	Phase	Learning	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
2026-06-08	baseline-commit-8b75d1b	P0	Manthan has a clean research/demo baseline, but not yet a product-stack baseline.	Manthan commit `8b75d1b`; tracker baseline section.	Viewer build/typecheck, Docker builds, and Python service pytest passed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	loop-baseline-81fbf3b7	P0	Full-swarm health is degraded in this environment and cannot be used for phase advancement yet.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-003A`; loop status checks.	Agent rows were error/unparsed/timeout/unauthenticated in prior review.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	loop-baseline-81fbf3b7	P0	Learning transfer must use auditable artifacts, not direct private-memory sharing.	Roadmap `Learning Transfer Notes`; prompt `Learning Audit Contract`.	Policy documented; implementation proof remains future work.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T080001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T080001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T080001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T081002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T081002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T081002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T082001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T082001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T082001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; DB row_count `0`; reviewer_synthesis_detected `false`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T083001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T083001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T083001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	Degraded swarm recording is a correct fail-closed safety signal, but repeated degraded cycles with zero findings mean the review/action loop is unavailable, not that Manthan has no gaps.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-015`; degraded audit JSON rows for `20260608T080001Z`..`20260608T083001Z`.	DB row counts and reviewer synthesis missing; no phase advancement.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	Copilot should be the action lane, not a blocking default review agent, until a finding is verified, scoped, queued, and has a proof command.	`delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; tracker `LOOP-FINDING-017`.	Controller now exposes `ACTION_AGENT=copilot` and review agents default to `deepseek,gemini,claude`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	Degraded cycles still need deterministic local proof to surface Manthan gaps, but those findings cannot authorize product edits or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan_swarm_phase_loop.prompt.md`; tracker `LOOP-FINDING-018` and `LOOP-FINDING-019`.	Prompt requires local proof on degraded cycles and action queue rows before action.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	Manthan has open P0/P1 proof gaps despite degraded swarm health.	Manthan `docker-compose.yml` host ports; substrate write routes; Manthan tracker status claims; action queue `MAQ-001` and `MAQ-002`.	Read-only local proof found boundary and product-smoke candidates; no Manthan product edits made.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	`loop-control-review-20260608-L5`: compose healthchecks use liveness while service readiness endpoints exist.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-020`; action queue `MAQ-005`; read-only grep over Manthan compose and service routes.	Verified `docker-compose.yml:11` uses `/healthz`; substrate/runtime/API expose `/readyz`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P1	`loop-control-review-20260608-L6`: selection feedback and dedup are implemented but disabled by default and not enabled in root compose.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-021`; action queue `MAQ-006`; runtime config grep.	Verified `read_api_url=""`, `selection_signal_bias=False`, and `dedup_enabled=False`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P1	`loop-control-review-20260608-L7`: NATS bus/presence remains architecture/future work for runtime.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-022`; action queue `MAQ-007`; Manthan integration doc.	Verified integration doc states runtime polls HTTP and `manthan.bus.*` subjects are unused.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P1	`loop-control-review-20260608-L8`: CI/root test parity omits `maestro-bridge`.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-023`; action queue `MAQ-008`; CI and Makefile grep.	Verified CI matrix and root `make test` omit bridge while baseline bridge pytest passed locally.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	`loop-control-review-20260608-L9`: live controller edits while cron is installed can create a transient failed tick that should not be interpreted as Manthan review output.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-024`; `cron.log`; preflight `preflight-20260608T084516Z`.	Current script `bash -n` passed; preflight reports idle; Manthan status clean.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T085337Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T085337Z-L1`: full-swarm review is degraded for this cycle and cannot authorize product edits or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T085337Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; cycle DB SHA `e22ef71ad6e4bac4916047e58fe216f2ac9db69a5d7995fd9a2951fe4b6b8c6a`.	Swarm command exited `124`; DB had DeepSeek unparsed, Gemini timeout, Claude socket error, and no reviewer synthesis.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T085337Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T085337Z-L2`: local proof reconfirms product-stack smoke and read-only boundary gaps as advisory candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T085337Z.local-proof.md`; compose/routes/status artifacts.	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passed; route/status artifacts showed host-published write/admin surfaces and no single root smoke script.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T084001Z	P0	Full-swarm review degraded again; no swarm learning was promoted.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T084001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T084001Z.swarm.db`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB rows were unparsed/error only and reviewer synthesis was absent.	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T084001Z	P0	`docker-compose config -q` is blocked in this execution environment because Compose is unavailable.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T084001Z-learning-audit.md`; command outputs from `docker-compose config -q` and `docker compose config -q`.	Exact proof command exited `127`; fallback check exited `125`; Manthan status stayed clean.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T084001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T084001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T084001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L1`: full-swarm review degraded again and cannot authorize edits or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T090001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB rows were DeepSeek unparsed, Gemini timeout, and Claude socket error; reviewer synthesis absent.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L2`: Compose proof remains unavailable in this runner.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.compose-config-q.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.docker-compose-v2-config-q.out`	`docker-compose` exited `127`; `docker compose` exited `125`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L3`: read-only outward boundary remains a phase candidate, not an accepted action, because write-capable services expose host ports.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.boundary-ports-health.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.routes.txt`	grep proof passed; full-swarm health degraded, so no product edit authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L4`: compose readiness remains a phase candidate because shared healthcheck uses `/healthz` while services expose `/readyz`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.boundary-ports-health.txt`	grep proof passed; full-swarm health degraded, so no action authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L5`: product-stack status claims remain ahead of this runner's root-smoke proof.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.status-claims.txt`; local proof note	status grep passed; Compose proof blocked; root smoke not executed.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P1	`manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z-L6`: selection, NATS/eventing, and CI parity remain P1-adjacent candidates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T090001Z.selection-nats-ci.txt`	grep proof passed; selection bias/dedup default off, NATS subjects unused, CI matrix omits `maestro-bridge`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T085001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T085001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T085001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T085337Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T085337Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T085337Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	loop-control-review-20260608	P0	`loop-control-review-20260608-L10`: recent lock directories must be treated as active even when their PID is not visible from the sandbox.	Tracker `LOOP-FINDING-030`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`.	`bash -n delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh` passed after the lock check was hardened.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T090001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T090001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T090001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T093001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T093001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T093001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T100001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T100001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T100001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T103001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T103001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T103001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T112002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning. Local proof recorded advisory phase candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T112002Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T112002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T112002Z.local-proof.md`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB had zero substantive agents and no reviewer synthesis; Compose proof blocked (`127`/`125`); static grep proofs passed; Manthan status stayed clean	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T111001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T111001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T111001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T112002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T112002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T112002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T120002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T120002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T120002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T124002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning. Local proof recorded advisory phase candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T124002Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T124002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T124002Z.local-proof.md`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB had zero substantive agents and no reviewer synthesis; Compose proof blocked (`127`/`125`); static grep proofs passed; Manthan status stayed clean	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T124002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T124002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T124002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T132001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning. Local proof recorded advisory phase candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T132001Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T132001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T132001Z.local-proof.md`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB had zero substantive agents and no reviewer synthesis; Compose proof blocked (`127`/`125`); static grep proofs passed; Manthan status stayed clean	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T132001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T132001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T132001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T135002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning. Local proof recorded advisory phase candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T135002Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T135002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T135002Z.local-proof.md`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB had zero substantive agents and no reviewer synthesis; Compose proof blocked (`127`/`125`); static grep proofs passed; Manthan status stayed clean	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T135002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T135002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T135002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z-L1`: full-swarm review degraded again and cannot authorize edits or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T143001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; DB SHA `ac2eaf074575bef7f07c4bd63a306542dd374b51dc916b393cf03b6b8fab2272`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB rows were DeepSeek unparsed, Gemini timeout, and Claude connection error; reviewer synthesis absent.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z-L2`: Compose proof remains unavailable in this runner.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T143001Z.compose-config-q.err`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T143001Z.docker-compose-v2-config-q.err`	`docker-compose` exited `127`; `docker compose` exited `125`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z-L3`: product-stack smoke, read-only boundary, readiness, selection, NATS/eventing, and CI parity remain advisory candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T143001Z.local-proof.md`; route/status/boundary/smoke/selection artifacts.	Static grep proofs passed; full-swarm health degraded, so no product edit or phase advancement was authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T143001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T143001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T143001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T151001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning. Local proof recorded advisory phase candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T151001Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T151001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T151001Z.local-proof.md`	`swarm_analyse` exited `124`; DB had zero substantive agents and no reviewer synthesis; Compose proof blocked (`127`/`125`); static grep proofs passed; Manthan status stayed clean.	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T151001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T151001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T151001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L1`: wrapper DB audit classified the cycle as degraded even though local DB inspection found 44 `analysis_findings` rows across three agent IDs, so P0 still cannot advance.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T153232Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.swarm-db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `db47111268fa9c5d5678cf0098a419b95038f31b6747942aeea042d764fe6e64`	Python sqlite inspection proved row/agent counts; authoritative wrapper audit remains `DEGRADED`.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L2`: compose config passes but under-proves root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.local-proof.md`; compose/smoke/scripts artifacts	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passed; no service startup or endpoint smoke command was run.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L3`: read-only outward boundary remains advisory because compose publishes write-capable services and routes include write/admin endpoints.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.routes.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.boundary-readiness.txt`	Static proof passed; degraded audit blocks product action.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L4`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate-path reference is stale.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.gate-path-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.gate-files.txt`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60`; live `G-*.md` files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L5`: this host supports `docker-compose` but not `docker compose`, so proof commands must be pinned or the environment normalized.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.docker-compose-v2-version.txt`; compose config proof	`docker-compose` config passed; `docker compose version` exited 1.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0/P1	`manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z-L6`: selection, NATS/eventing, HERALD binding, and CI parity concerns remain advisory only in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T153232Z.selection-nats-herald-ci.txt`	Static grep passed; no product action or phase advancement authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T153232Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T153232Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T153232Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T154918Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T154918Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; 25 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected in output.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z-L2`: the `20260608T153232Z` degraded DB verdict was a controller audit false negative.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T154918Z.reaudit-153232.json`; old audit `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T153232Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	`audit-db` replay returned `OK` with 44 rows, real agent IDs, reviewer synthesis, and zero missing identity rows.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z-L3`: loop controller audit now requires real agent identity and exposes an `audit-db` replay command.	`delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T154918Z.reaudit-current.json`	`bash -n` passed; both replay JSON files show `health: OK` and `missing_agent_identity_rows: 0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z-L4`: static compose config and git status commands still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	Reviewer consensus in `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T154918Z.swarm.out`; action queue `MAQ-002`	Healthy review evidence accepted; no product smoke command ran, so this remains a phase candidate.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T154918Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T154918Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T161215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T161215Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; 21 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected in output.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L2`: compose config validation under-proves root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T161215Z.compose-config-q.status`; `20260608T161215Z.scripts-list.txt`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exited `0`; no stack startup or endpoint smoke command ran; `scripts/` contains only `bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L3`: root compose app-tier host bindings leave the read-only outward boundary unproven.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260608T161215Z.compose-expanded-boundary.txt`	Expanded compose shows Postgres/NATS loopback host IPs, while substrate/runtime/API/bridge/viewer published ports lack `host_ip`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L4`: compose dependency health is liveness-gated while readiness endpoints exist.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.boundary-readiness.txt`; Manthan `docker-compose.yml:11-12`	Grep proof found shared python-base `/healthz` healthcheck and `/readyz` endpoints in substrate/runtime/API.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0/P1	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L5`: CI parity gap includes both missing `maestro-bridge` Python tests and missing Python service Docker builds.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.ci-compose-docs.txt`; Manthan `.github/workflows/ci.yml:42-43`, `:147-160`	CI matrix lists `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api`; docker-build matrix lists only `testnet-node` and `backup`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L6`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate-path reference remains stale.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.gate-path-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.gate-files.txt`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60`; live `G-*.md` files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L7`: this host supports `docker-compose` for the selected proof but not the `docker compose` plugin path.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.compose-config-q.status`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.docker-compose-v2-version.out`	Hyphenated compose config exited `0`; `docker compose version` exited `1` with "not a docker command".	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L8`: the scoped `CLAUDE.md` path fix is blocked by unavailable Copilot action lane in this environment.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.review-proof.md`; action queue `MAQ-010`; tracker `LOOP-ACTION-015`	Tool discovery exposed generic subagents, not a Copilot action lane; no Manthan product files were edited.	guarded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z-L9`: the Conduir loop P0 gate has no Manthan-side phase-gate anchor in the target repo.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.target-gate-anchor.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T161215Z.target-gate-files.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T161215Z.swarm.out`	Grep for Conduir loop gate/state terms exited `1` with zero matches; phase/swarm gate file find returned zero files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T161215Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T161215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T164001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T164001Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; 14 rows; substantive agents `claude` and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis present in output.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z-L2`: Conduir loop phase pointer conflicts with Manthan delivery-status authority.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.phase-identity-manthan.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.phase-identity-conduir.txt`	Grep proof shows Manthan tracker authority and historical done claims, while Conduir state still declares `active_phase: P0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z-L4`: ignored root `.env` is present during compose proof, so proof records host-local context unless a clean-check is added.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.env-presence.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.env-ignore.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.compose-env-vars.txt`	`.env` exists and is ignored; root compose has defaulted interpolation, so no clean-check failure was proven.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z-L5`: compose proof target is ambiguous because multiple compose files exist and `infra/compose/` is the documented internal default.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.compose-targets.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T164001Z.compose-default-doc.txt`; host packet `cycle-packet-20260608T164001Z.md`	`find` returned root, `infra/compose`, and `infra/docker` compose files; `CLAUDE.md` names `infra/compose/` as official internal default, while the packet selected root compose.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T164001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T164001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T170001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T170001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T170001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T170001Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; 23 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected in output.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T170001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T170001Z-L2`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate-path reference is stale and is now verified as a blocker candidate for the phase-anchor conflict.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T170001Z.gate-path-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T170001Z.gate-files.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T170001Z.swarm.out`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60`; live `G-*.md` files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`; no Manthan product edit was authorized without the configured action lane.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T170001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T170001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T172001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T172001Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `b0a84ce866f24203b3d76a932fa8b2112931bb6820b3aee8aeef8a277b2edfb8`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; DB inspection found 17 `analysis_findings` rows with substantive `deepseek` and `gemini` findings plus reviewer synthesis.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L2`: static compose config and clean git status under-prove root product-stack smoke.	Reviewer consensus in `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T172001Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T172001Z.compose-config-q.out`; `20260608T172001Z.scripts-list.txt`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no endpoint smoke command ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L3`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate-path reference is stale, but the stronger root-cause framing is not proven.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T172001Z.gate-path-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T172001Z.gate-files.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T172001Z.swarm.out`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60`; live gate files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`; reviewer classified this as a doc fix rather than proven phase-lock root cause.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains semantically risky against Manthan delivery-status authority.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T172001Z.phase-identity-manthan.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T172001Z.phase-identity-conduir.txt`	Grep proof reconfirmed Manthan tracker authority/done claims and Conduir `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L6`: current cycle DB zero-content claim is rejected for this engine schema.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T172001Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T172001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	Python `sqlite3` inspection found `analysis_findings=17`; authoritative audit reports `health: OK`.	guarded	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L7`: root compose is not rejected as the root product-stack proof target.	Reviewer consensus in `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T172001Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T172001Z.compose-targets.txt`; `20260608T172001Z.compose-default-doc.txt`	Reviewer accepted root compose for the literal root product-stack objective; the flaw is static validation only.	guarded	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z-L8`: healthcheck/readiness mismatch is rejected as a blocker for this cycle.	Reviewer consensus in `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T172001Z.swarm.out`	Reviewer verified `/healthz` and `/readyz` exist and downgraded the finding to non-blocking design concern.	guarded	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T172001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T172001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T174002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T174002Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `56c5c7c162a77cd0d890485c07f12ba3c2b0a77c37a4d5bee8fffc5c57c5dfe8`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; 26 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L2`: static compose validation cannot prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T174002Z.review-proof.md`; root and `infra/compose` expanded compose artifacts; `20260608T174002Z.scripts.txt`	Both compose config commands exited `0`, but no service startup or endpoint smoke command ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L3`: app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the boundary decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T174002Z.port-bindings.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T174002Z.swarm.out`	Grep shows infra ports use loopback while substrate/runtime/API/bridge/viewer use bare host-port mappings.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains a semantic overlay risk against Manthan delivery-status authority.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T174002Z.phase-authority.manthan.txt`; `20260608T174002Z.phase-authority.conduir.txt`	Grep proof reconfirmed Manthan tracker authority/done claims and Conduir `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L6`: the loopback-safe root compose claim is rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T174002Z.port-bindings.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T174002Z.swarm.out`	Reviewer corrected the contrary claim; app-tier ports do not include loopback host IPs.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z-L7`: the broken `/healthz` claim is rejected, while readiness remains the stronger smoke signal.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T174002Z.health-readiness.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T174002Z.swarm.out`	Grep shows substrate/runtime/API expose `/healthz` and `/readyz`, and compose healthchecks use `/healthz`; smoke should use readiness where available.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T174002Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T174002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for review findings, with an output-based reviewer-synthesis caveat.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T180001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T180001Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `4f9fddf904e153862dc0f174b627bed3fd842e67eaf6b045947d719c78ffdd53`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 25 findings across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer consensus was detected in output, not in the DB reviewer flag.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`; host output reviewer consensus	Root and `infra/compose` config checks exited `0`, but no service startup, `/readyz`, `/signal/feed`, `/elites`, lineage graph, MCP, or bridge probe ran; `scripts/` contains only `bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the binding decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`; Manthan `docker-compose.yml:86-169`	Grep/nl proof shows `substrate`, `runtime`, `api`, `maestro-bridge`, and `viewer` publish bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS use loopback.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L4`: the Conduir loop `P0` gate still lacks a committed Manthan-side phase-gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`; host output reviewer consensus	Target-repo phase/swarm gate file find returned no committed loop anchor; the active gate authority remains in Conduir control-plane files and host packets.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L5`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate-path reference remains stale.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60`; `find manthan-platform/gates -maxdepth 1 -name 'G-*.md'` found 13 live gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L6`: Conduir loop `P0` remains a semantic overlay risk against Manthan delivery-status authority.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker/CLAUDE grep confirms tracker authority and historical Phase 5/internal-research done claims while Conduir state declares `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L7`: root compose proof records host-local context because `.env` exists but is untracked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`	`.env` exists at 1290 bytes; `git ls-files .env` returned no tracked path; no secret values were read.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L9`: wrapper finalization left stale running state and required operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cron.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`	`current.json` reported PID `2054247`, `ps -p 2054247` found no process, and cron log shows wrapper parse/unbound-variable failures plus lock skips; lock files were not removed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z-L10`: the prior shorthand that `infra/compose` port mappings are loopback-safe is rejected for the current tree.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T180001Z.review-proof.md`; Manthan `infra/compose/docker-compose.yml:62-242`	Grep/nl proof shows bare mappings such as `9120:9120`, `9220:9220`, `19090:9090`, `9093:9093`, and `13000:3000`; do not reuse prior loopback-safe wording as boundary evidence.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T180001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T180001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for review findings, with substantive `claude` and `gemini` findings plus reviewer synthesis.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T182001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T182001Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `0b335880a93d443773281af3732f1a8470334de68aaf09ebf82b43061a7c8bd9`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 18 rows, with DeepSeek unparsed and substantive `claude`/`gemini` findings.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L2`: Conduir loop `P0` is an external control-plane overlay, not Manthan tracker `Phase 0`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.phase-authority-manthan.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.phase-authority-conduir.txt`	Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 done and Phase 5/internal-research status while Conduir phase state declares active `P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L3`: static compose config plus clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T182001Z.scripts-list.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, readiness probe, `/signal/feed`, `/elites`, lineage graph, MCP, or bridge probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L4`: root app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the binding decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.port-bindings.txt`	Grep proof shows substrate/runtime/API/maestro-bridge/viewer use bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS use loopback.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L5`: the Conduir loop P0 gate still lacks a committed Manthan-side phase-gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.phase-authority-manthan.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.phase-authority-conduir.txt`	Authority proof still anchors the active P0 gate in Conduir control-plane files, not a committed Manthan phase-gate file.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L6`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` still has gate-path drift and compose-default drift against the proof target.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.gate-compose-doc-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.gate-files.txt`	Grep found `CLAUDE.md:60` stale path and `CLAUDE.md:32`/`:58` defaulting to `infra/compose`; live gate files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L7`: root compose has a known dev `POSTGRES_PASSWORD` default that must be gated before any future `up` smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.port-bindings.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.env-context.txt`	Grep found `POSTGRES_PASSWORD:-manthan_dev_change_me`; ignored `.env` exists and no secret values were read.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L8`: the reviewer detail that `infra/compose/` lacks a compose file is rejected for the current tree.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.compose-targets.txt`	`find` found `./infra/compose/docker-compose.yml`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T182001Z.current-pid-check.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `2845260`; `ps -p 2845260` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T182001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T182001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T182001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T184002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T184002Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `dc5bc2922e09416d0a14cf1c16a9de2d78af00ef87284f91f4adeaa211c2f8a5`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 26 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.scripts.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, readiness probe, `/signal/feed`, `/elites`, lineage graph, MCP, or bridge probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the binding decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.port-bindings.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Proof shows substrate/runtime/API/maestro-bridge/viewer use bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external control-plane overlay, not Manthan tracker `Phase 0`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.status-claims.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker records historical Phase 5/internal-research status while Conduir state declares `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L5`: the Conduir loop P0 gate still lacks a committed Manthan-side phase-gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.phase-gate-files.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.compose-authority.txt`	Target-repo phase-gate file find returned no loop anchor; gate authority remains in Conduir control-plane artifacts.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L6`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` still has gate-path drift and compose-default drift against the current root proof target.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.gate-path.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.live-gates.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.compose-authority.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60`; live `G-*.md` files are under root `manthan-platform/gates/`; root proof target conflicts with `infra/compose` default wording.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L7`: the P0 gate includes `maestro-bridge` pytest, but CI omits `maestro-bridge` from the Python service matrix.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	CI/Makefile grep shows `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api` are covered while `maestro-bridge` is absent from the Python matrix.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L8`: future `up` smoke must record an intentional dev-default guard without reading secret values.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.dev-defaults.txt`	Grep found the root compose dev DB password default; no stack startup ran and no secret values were read from `.env`.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `3632645`; `ps -p 3632645` exited `1` with no process output; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z-L10`: raw claims that the DB had zero findings, standalone Compose is legacy v1, or `/healthz` healthchecks are high-risk are rejected for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.db-inspection.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.compose-version.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T184002Z.routes.txt`	DB inspection found 26 rows; standalone `docker-compose` reports v2.39.4; services expose `/healthz` and `/readyz`, so readiness is a stronger smoke signal but not a verified healthcheck blocker.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T184002Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T184002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, with reviewer synthesis detected in output rather than the DB reviewer flag.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T190001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T190001Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `2d96164f7ceed4757cb66786243230578177d01f827b51e709d4707bfe7624dd`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 28 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis was output-backed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T190001Z.compose-config-q.status`; `20260608T190001Z.scripts.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, readiness probe, `/signal/feed`, `/elites`, lineage graph, MCP, or bridge probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the binding decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.root-compose-ports.txt`	Proof shows substrate/runtime/API/maestro-bridge/viewer use bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external control-plane overlay, not Manthan tracker `Phase 0`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.phase-authority-manthan.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.phase-authority-conduir.txt`	Grep proof shows Manthan historical phase claims and Conduir `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L5`: the Conduir loop P0 gate still lacks a committed Manthan-side phase-gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Target-repo phase/swarm gate file find returned zero files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L6`: Manthan operator docs still have path drift for gate specs and API source references.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.doc-drift.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.live-gates.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.api-path-tests.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.api-stale-path-tests.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60` gate path and stale `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132` API path; live gate and API paths exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L7`: the P0 gate includes `maestro-bridge` pytest, but CI omits `maestro-bridge` from the Python service matrix.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	CI/Makefile grep shows `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api` are covered while `maestro-bridge` is absent from the Python matrix.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L8`: read-only route proof can support boundary review, but cannot replace live smoke or authorize product edits.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.routes.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.root-compose-ports.txt`	API route grep is GET-only, while substrate/runtime expose POST/admin routes and are host-published by root compose.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `305411`; `ps -p 305411` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z-L10`: raw claims that standalone Compose is v1, `observer_state` entropy is in scope, or `/healthz` is a verified high-risk blocker are rejected or scoped down.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T190001Z.health-readiness.txt`; `20260608T190001Z.swarm.out` reviewer reconciliation	Standalone Compose reports v2.39.4; observer-state claim is out of scope; services expose both `/healthz` and `/readyz`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T190001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T190001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L1`: full-swarm review was degraded for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T192001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.db-inspection.txt`	Host status `0`, but DB audit `DEGRADED`; only `gemini` was substantive and `claude`/`deepseek` rows were unparsed.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.local-proof.md`; `20260608T192001Z.scripts-list.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.routes.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup or endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure keeps the read-only outward boundary unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.write-boundary.txt`	App-tier services publish bare host ports while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned; substrate/runtime expose write/admin surfaces.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.phase-authority-manthan.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.phase-gate-files.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.target-gate-anchor.txt`	Manthan tracker records Phase 5/internal-research status and historical Phase 0 done; target loop-gate searches returned zero matches/files.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L5`: Manthan operator docs still have gate/API path drift.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.live-gates.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.api-paths.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132`; live gate and API paths exist.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L6`: P0 gate/CI parity still omits `maestro-bridge` from CI.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	CI/Makefile grep covers `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api`, while the P0 gate includes `maestro-bridge` pytest.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L7`: NATS/HERALD/selection claims were not proven by a running product stack this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.selection-nats-herald-ci.txt`; `20260608T192001Z.local-proof.md`	Static grep found wiring and default-off settings, but no stack startup or endpoint probe ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L8`: root compose has a known dev DB password default that must be gated before any future `up` smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T192001Z.dev-defaults.txt`	Grep found the root compose dev DB password default; no stack startup ran and no secret values were read from `.env`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z-L9`: raw degraded-review claims about the DB-audit gate and git-status proof are rejected or scoped down.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T192001Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `20260608T192001Z.local.manthan.status`	Phase gates require full-swarm DB audit OK and Manthan status was clean; no raw claim is promoted from the degraded review.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit blocked completion as healthy.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T192001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`; no phase advancement.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T192001Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T192001Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T192001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T193629Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T193629Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `a57241445922ee5c70d9d7a468730f65b957dbb178d5333dbb8a7e3ae0326d8c`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 34 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T193629Z.compose-config-q.out`; `20260608T193629Z.scripts.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, readiness probe, endpoint smoke, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure blocks an `up`-based smoke until the binding decision is resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260608T193629Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Proof shows substrate/runtime/API/maestro-bridge/viewer use bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L4`: P0 gate/CI parity still omits `maestro-bridge` from CI.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `20260608T193629Z.service-tests.txt`	CI matrix covers `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api`; P0 includes `maestro-bridge`; bridge has no `test_health.py`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L5`: read-only boundary proof must exercise runtime surfaces rather than rely on static compose and clean status.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.routes-write-boundary.txt`; `20260608T193629Z.root-compose-ports.txt`	API route grep is GET-only, but substrate exposes POST routes and runtime exposes `/admin/pause-all` while both are host-published.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L6`: Conduir loop `P0` is an external control-plane overlay, not Manthan tracker historical Phase 0.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.phase-authority.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T193629Z.swarm.out`	Manthan tracker records Phase 5/internal-research status and historical Phase 0 done while Conduir state declares `active_phase: P0`; reviewer demoted direct contradiction claims.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L7`: the Conduir loop P0 gate still lacks a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.target-gate-anchor.txt`; `20260608T193629Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Target-repo loop-anchor grep and phase-gate file find returned zero matches/files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L8`: Manthan operator docs still have gate/API path drift.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.doc-drift.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132`; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L9`: P1 root smoke and selection scripts are absent from the target repo.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.scripts.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, while P1 gates name `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` and `scripts/manthan-selection-ab.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L10`: raw claims about in-flight `current.json`, unavailable audit files, and clean-status boundary proof were rejected or scoped down.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T193629Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer verified the PID was live during review, audit/files existed, and clean git status is only cleanliness evidence.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z-L11`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T193629Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T193629Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T193629Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T193629Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T195012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T195012Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `1f579dd4460acf2a27ab9800ec6f622c862d612d6e7a7f0f958f5d9bd129fe07`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 12 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean git status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T195012Z.compose-config-q.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, readiness probe, endpoint smoke, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L3`: read-only boundary proof remains unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T195012Z.routes-write-boundary.txt`	App-tier services publish bare host ports while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned; substrate/runtime expose write/admin routes.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L4`: packet proof commands omitted the cycle-DB audit required by the P0 gate.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260608T195012Z.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T195012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	Packet listed compose config and Manthan status only; wrapper audit supplied the DB-health evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L5`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external control-plane overlay, not Manthan tracker historical Phase 0.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.phase-authority.txt`; reviewer consensus in `20260608T195012Z.swarm.out`	Manthan tracker records Phase 5/internal-research status and historical Phase 0 done while Conduir state declares `active_phase: P0`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L6`: nightly CI has a higher-fidelity smoke, but it is not yet selected as the root product-stack P0 proof.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.nightly-smoke.txt`; `20260608T195012Z.compose-targets.txt`	Nightly runs build/up/healthz/canary/prometheus/down against `infra/compose`; current packet selected root compose static proof.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L7`: Manthan operator docs still have gate/API path drift.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T195012Z.gate-paths.txt`; `20260608T195012Z.api-main-paths.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132`; live paths exist; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L8`: root compose has known dev database password defaults that must be guarded before any future `up` smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Grep found four `POSTGRES_PASSWORD` default references; no secret files were read and no stack startup ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L9`: DeepSeek's unparsed contribution is rejected for promotion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T195012Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T195012Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB inspection shows one `deepseek` row with severity `unparsed`; reviewer discarded it.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z-L10`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T195012Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T195012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T195012Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T195012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L1`: full-swarm review is treated as degraded because host status was `124` and swarm output was empty.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T200503Z.swarm.status`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T200503Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T200503Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	DB audit reported `OK` with 27 rows across three agents, but the prompt requires degraded classification on nonzero host status or empty output.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.local-proof.md`; `20260608T200503Z.scripts-list.txt`; `20260608T200503Z.routes.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, and no service startup or endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port exposure keeps the read-only outward boundary unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T200503Z.routes.txt`	App-tier services use bare host-port mappings while substrate/runtime expose write/admin routes.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external control-plane overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T200503Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T200503Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records Phase 5/internal-research status; target loop-anchor and source gate-file searches returned zero lines.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L5`: Manthan operator docs still have gate/API path drift.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.doc-drift.txt`	Grep found stale `CLAUDE.md:60` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132`; no product edit was authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L6`: P0 gate/CI parity still omits `maestro-bridge` from CI and root `make test`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	CI matrix and root `make test` cover `substrate`, `runtime`, and `api`, while P0 gate includes `maestro-bridge`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L7`: the authoritative smoke target and future smoke guard remain unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T200503Z.nightly-smoke.txt`; `20260608T200503Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Nightly uses `infra/compose` up/healthz/canary checks, while this cycle selected root static compose proof and root compose includes dev database password defaults.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z-L8`: DB audit `OK` alone is rejected as sufficient proof of healthy full-swarm review for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T200503Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T200503Z.swarm.status`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T200503Z.swarm.out`	Prompt-specific degraded rule overrides the DB audit because host status was `124` and output was empty.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T200503Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T200503Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T203419Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T203419Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `f40fb5052174aa3e002a178412aeb5fc746a3b76ecca5fb0ee5e2c911d64f8c8`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; Python sqlite inspection found 38 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T203419Z.compose-config-q.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint smoke, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=38` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L4`: root app-tier host-port exposure keeps the read-only outward boundary unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.routes.txt`	App-tier services have bare host-port mappings while Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned; substrate/runtime expose write/admin routes.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L5`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records Phase 5/internal-research status and historical Phase 0 done; target anchor grep and phase-gate file find returned zero lines/files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L6`: the authoritative smoke target and future smoke guard remain unresolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.compose-targets.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.nightly-smoke.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Three compose files exist; nightly uses `infra/compose`, while this cycle selected root static compose proof and root compose has dev defaults.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L7`: CI/doc drift remains proof-backed but blocked for product action.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T203419Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.doc-drift.txt`	CI/root `make test` omit `maestro-bridge`; `CLAUDE.md:60` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md:132` still cite stale paths; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L8`: raw DB and sqlite claims are rejected or scoped down.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T203419Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T203419Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260608T203419Z.sqlite3-command.txt`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`	DB has 38 `analysis_findings` rows, and the wrapper audit uses Python `sqlite3`; missing sqlite CLI is not a cycle blocker by itself.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T203419Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T203419Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T203419Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T204709Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T204709Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `3b43cded29b542de0bdea8c0ed609c3f7802d279d25a31504f113c70cecceaa4`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; DB inspection found 27 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`; reviewer synthesis detected.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T204709Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T204709Z.compose-config-q.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T204709Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=27` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L4`: read-only boundary remains unproven by the candidate command; bare host ports alone are exposure evidence, not mutation proof.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T204709Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T204709Z.routes.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Reviewer narrowed the claim; routes show substrate POST and runtime admin surfaces, but the selected proof asserted no read-only boundary.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L5`: root `docker-compose.yml` is the correct target for a root product-stack smoke; redirecting this objective to `infra/compose` is rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T204709Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T204709Z.compose-targets.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.nightly-smoke.txt`	Reviewer verified root compose is the Python product stack while `infra/compose` is the testnet stack.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L6`: Conduir loop `P0` is an external overlay and still lacks a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`20260608T204709Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 done and Phase 5 internal-research status; target anchor grep and phase-gate file find returned zero lines/files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L7`: forward gate blockers remain: P1 smoke/selection scripts are absent, `maestro-bridge` is not in CI/root test parity, doc paths drift, and healthcheck/readiness mismatch remains.	`20260608T204709Z.scripts-list.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.routes.txt`; `20260608T204709Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; CI matrix omits `maestro-bridge`; doc grep found stale paths; routes show `/readyz` while compose healthcheck uses `/healthz`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L8`: raw claims that the current host swarm output was empty or that `infra/compose` is the canonical product stack are rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T204709Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T204709Z.review-proof.md`	Host output is non-empty, audit is `OK`, and reviewer corrected the `infra/compose` target claim.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T204709Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T204709Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T204709Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T210552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T210552Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `6bc3159c10b5cd94e620542b8179a648848d184030c7464de5a54ec907479453`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; output was non-empty with reviewer synthesis; DB inspection found 16 rows across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T210552Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T210552Z.compose-config-q.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T210552Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=16` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L4`: the cycle packet's P0 anchor is stale unless treated as an external Conduir overlay over Manthan's historical tracker phases.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T210552Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T210552Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Reviewer verified Manthan tracker contradiction; local target-anchor grep returned zero lines and phase-gate file find returned zero files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L5`: the objective and safety gate conflict until boundary and smoke contract decisions are resolved.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T210552Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T210552Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.routes.txt`	Reviewer rejected immediate `docker-compose up -d`; local proof shows app-tier host ports, write/admin routes, and no read-only assertion command.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L6`: proof commands must keep using standalone `docker-compose` in this host.	`20260608T210552Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.docker-compose-plugin-version.txt`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; `docker compose version` failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L7`: forward gate blockers remain: missing P1 scripts, CI bridge omission, doc drift, and readiness mismatch.	`20260608T210552Z.scripts-list.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T210552Z.readiness-healthcheck.txt`	Scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; CI matrix omits `maestro-bridge`; doc grep found stale paths; compose uses `/healthz` while services expose `/readyz`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L8`: raw advice to start the stack immediately with `docker-compose up -d` is rejected for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T210552Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T210552Z.review-proof.md`	The reviewer flagged the proposed startup as unsafe under the read-only gate; no stack startup or endpoint probe ran.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z-L9`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T210552Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T210552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T212002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T212002Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `f97998a76d9d3597ea62daea255ebc6fb2a2ea1340577e690c86e6fcc9b23559`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis detected; DB inspection found 35 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T212002Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T212002Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T212002Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=35` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L4`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`20260608T212002Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 done and Phase 5 internal-research status; target loop-anchor grep and phase-gate file find returned zero lines/files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L5`: root app-tier host-port exposure and write/admin routes keep read-only boundary proof unresolved.	`20260608T212002Z.compose-ports-block.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.routes.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned, app-tier services use bare host-port mappings, and routes include substrate POST plus runtime admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L6`: root smoke and forward selection proof scripts are absent from the target repo.	`20260608T212002Z.scripts-list.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, while P1 gates name `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` and `scripts/manthan-selection-ab.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L7`: product doc, CI parity, and readiness drift remain proof-backed but blocked for product action.	`20260608T212002Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T212002Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`	Stale Manthan doc paths, `maestro-bridge` CI/root-test omission, and `/healthz` vs `/readyz` mismatch remain verified; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L8`: target HEAD freshness passed, but the planning repo HEAD in the packet was stale.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260608T212002Z.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T212002Z.review-proof.md`	Packet Manthan HEAD `8b75d1b` matched live target HEAD; packet Conduir HEAD `0c20958e` differed from live planning HEAD `63b46714`; accepted findings rely on live target proof.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L9`: raw advice to use `make test` or immediate stack startup as this cycle's proof is rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T212002Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T212002Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer rejected `make test` as written unless app services are already started and healthy; this cycle did not authorize `docker-compose up` under current guardrails.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z-L10`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T212002Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T210552Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T210552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T212002Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T212002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T213301Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T213301Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `18dd5e0a53ca0b5801deb82fcd069da4135fabc13167ead34fc595cee9707aa2`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis detected; DB inspection found 30 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T213301Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T213301Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T213301Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=30` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L4`: root app-tier host-port exposure and write/admin routes keep read-only boundary proof unresolved.	`20260608T213301Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.routes.txt`	Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned, app-tier services use bare host-port mappings, and routes include substrate POST plus runtime admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L5`: root smoke and forward selection proof scripts are absent from the target repo.	`20260608T213301Z.scripts-list.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, while P1 gates name `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` and `scripts/manthan-selection-ab.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L6`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`20260608T213301Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records historical phase claims; target phase-gate file find returned zero files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L7`: product doc, CI parity, and readiness drift remain proof-backed but blocked for product action.	`20260608T213301Z.gate-path.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.api-path.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.readiness.txt`	Stale Manthan doc paths, `maestro-bridge` CI/root-test omission, and `/healthz` vs `/readyz` mismatch remain verified; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L8`: proof commands must keep using standalone `docker-compose` in this host.	`20260608T213301Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.docker-compose-plugin-version.txt`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; `docker compose version` failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L9`: target HEAD freshness passed, but packet planning HEAD was stale.	`cycle-packet-20260608T213301Z.md`; `20260608T213301Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260608T213301Z.engine-head.txt`	Packet Manthan and engine HEADs matched live HEADs; packet Conduir `9ed8411d` differed from live planning HEAD `3861157`.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L10`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T213301Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z-L11`: raw empty-DB, empty-output, and inaccessible-repo claims are rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T213301Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T213301Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB has 30 findings, output is non-empty, and reviewer read planning artifacts.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T213301Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T213301Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T213301Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T215603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T215603Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `cf716dc93902dc6e7a14b6178f9069c587b147ae1c1faf36b101fcba68450b9f`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis detected; DB inspection found 28 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T215603Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T215603Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T215603Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=28` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L4`: root app-tier host-port exposure and write/admin routes keep read-only boundary proof unresolved.	`20260608T215603Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.routes.txt`	Postgres/NATS are loopback-pinned, app-tier services use bare host-port mappings, and routes include write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L5`: root smoke and forward selection proof scripts are absent from the target repo.	`20260608T215603Z.scripts-list.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, while P1 gates name `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` and `scripts/manthan-selection-ab.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L6`: Conduir loop `P0` remains an external overlay without a committed Manthan-side loop gate anchor.	`20260608T215603Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.phase-gate-files.txt`	Manthan tracker records historical product phases; target loop-anchor grep returned no matches and phase-gate file find returned zero files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L7`: product doc, CI parity, and readiness drift remain proof-backed but blocked for product action.	`20260608T215603Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.readiness-healthcheck.txt`	Stale Manthan doc paths, `maestro-bridge` CI/root-test omission, and `/healthz` versus `/readyz` mismatch remain verified; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L8`: proof commands must keep using standalone `docker-compose` in this host.	`20260608T215603Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.docker-compose-plugin-version.txt`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; `docker compose version` failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L9`: HEAD freshness passed for the packet target, planning repo, and engine repo.	`cycle-packet-20260608T215603Z.md`; `20260608T215603Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.engine-head.txt`	Packet Manthan `8b75d1b`, Conduir `6e27f80e`, and engine `11cb7851` matched live HEADs.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L10`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T215603Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z-L11`: raw zero-row, inaccessible-audit, and `.observer_state` entropy claims are rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T215603Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T215603Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260608T215603Z.review-proof.md`	DB has 28 findings, audit/output were readable, and `.observer_state` content is not a product risk.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T215603Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T215603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T221344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T221344Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `d75e41c9a0b352f2ab3344df71ce1f4b9d8b540b990501e8aa7add4a285778da`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus detected; DB inspection found 28 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L2`: Conduir loop `P0` is an external overlay and the target-side loop anchor remains absent.	`20260608T221344Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.target-loop-anchor.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.phase-gate-files.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.control-gate-proof.txt`	Live target proof found historical Manthan phase claims but no Conduir loop anchor; controller corrected `phase_overlay_anchor` to `missing_target_anchor_control_overlay_only`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L3`: static compose validation and clean Manthan status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T221344Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T221344Z.compose-config-q.status`; `20260608T221344Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L4`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260608T221344Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=28` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L5`: root smoke and forward selection proof scripts are absent from the target repo.	`20260608T221344Z.scripts-list.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`, while P0/P1 gates require root smoke and selection proof scripts before advancement.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L6`: root app-tier host-port exposure and write/admin routes keep the read-only outward boundary unresolved.	`20260608T221344Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.routes.txt`	Expanded compose and route grep prove app-tier ports and write-capable/admin surfaces remain visible; no boundary edit or startup was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L7`: product doc, CI parity, and readiness drift remain proof-backed but blocked for product action.	`20260608T221344Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.ci-bridge.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.readiness-healthcheck.txt`	Stale Manthan paths, `maestro-bridge` CI/root-test omission, and `/healthz` versus `/readyz` drift were verified; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L8`: proof commands must keep using standalone `docker-compose` in this host.	`20260608T221344Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.docker-compose-plugin-version.txt`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; `docker compose version` failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L9`: HEAD freshness passed for the packet target, planning repo, and engine repo.	`cycle-packet-20260608T221344Z.md`; `20260608T221344Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260608T221344Z.engine-head.txt`	Packet Manthan `8b75d1b`, Conduir `6e4e0282`, and engine `11cb7851` matched live HEADs.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L10`: raw advice to use immediate `docker-compose up -d --wait` as this cycle's proof is rejected.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T221344Z.swarm.out`; `20260608T221344Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer flagged immediate startup as unsafe under the read-only gate; this cycle did not authorize stack startup or endpoint probes.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z-L11`: wrapper finalization again found stale running state before operator finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260608T221344Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `1468785`; `ps -p 1468785` exited `1`; finalizer updated `current.json` to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T221344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T221344Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T221344Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T221344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T223357Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T223357Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T223357Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `143`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T223603Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T223603Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T223603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `143`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T223711Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T223711Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T223711Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `143`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T224502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T224502Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; output reports 39 findings from `deepseek`, `gemini`, and `claude`, with reviewer consensus.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	Host swarm output; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q`; `git status --short`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L3`: root app-tier host-port posture keeps the read-only outward boundary unresolved.	Host reviewer consensus; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T224502Z.port-bindings.txt`	Reviewer verified app-tier service mappings lack loopback prefixes while infra mappings are loopback-pinned; no compose binding edit or stack startup was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L4`: root smoke, selection, and target anchor artifacts remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	Host reviewer consensus; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Reviewer verified the named anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script are absent; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L5`: Conduir loop `P0` is an external overlay over Manthan historical phases and still lacks a target-side loop gate anchor.	Host reviewer consensus; `cycle-packet-20260608T224502Z.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Reviewer rejected treating Manthan historical Phase 0 as the same axis as Conduir loop P0; no target-side anchor edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L6`: low-risk doc drift remains proof-backed but blocked for product action.	Host reviewer consensus; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T224502Z.drift-proof.txt`	Reviewer verified the stale `CLAUDE.md` gate path; local drift proof captured doc/API path evidence; no Copilot product-edit lane or human authorization was available.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z-L8`: raw claims that the current cycle DB was empty are rejected.	Host raw finding versus `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T224502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	DB audit reports 39 rows and three substantive agents; the raw empty-DB claim is stale or false for this cycle.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T224502Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T224502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z-L1`: full-swarm review is degraded for this cycle despite host status `0`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T231045Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T231045Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `c25fa301ed6fa6d31252d491b31f5d4bfb5f793ee1a80dbbc8c719880a35aa81`	Audit reports one substantive agent (`gemini`) and no DB reviewer synthesis; DB inspection found `analysis_findings=10`, `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z-L8`: `current.json` held a stale running marker before finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `ps -p 4029586 -o pid=,stat=,cmd=`	`ps` exited `1`; finalizer updated the cycle marker to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z	P0	Degraded local proof recorded P0 product blockers as phase-candidates only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T231045Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T231045Z-learning-audit.md`	Compose config passed, Manthan status was clean, and proof artifacts reconfirmed static-smoke under-proofing, unresolved boundary posture, absent target anchor/scripts, doc/CI/readiness drift, and unproven architecture bindings; no product edit or phase advancement authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T231045Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T231045Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T231045Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T232533Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T232533Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `93d553a054d09df677e9f1e5f5a813d74c6584419045066dd083de8adf82583d`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 22 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L2`: static compose validation and clean status still under-prove root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260608T232533Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Compose config exited `0`, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L3`: Lane 1 read-only outward boundary remains unresolved but now has an exact patch packet.	`20260608T232533Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260608T232533Z.routes.txt`; `20260608T232533Z.action-patch-packet.md`	App-tier mappings lack loopback prefixes and route proof includes write/admin surfaces; exact future write set is `docker-compose.yml`; no product edit was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L4`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260608T232533Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=22` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L5`: proof commands must use standalone `docker-compose` in this host unless the plugin form is installed.	`20260608T232533Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; command result for `docker compose version`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; plugin-form `docker compose` exited `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L6`: raw current-cycle DB-empty claims are rejected.	`20260608T232533Z.db-inspection.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T232533Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	Current DB inspection and wrapper audit both found 22 analysis rows.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z-L7`: Copilot action is blocked in this controller session, so a patch packet was emitted instead of editing Manthan.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T232533Z.log`; `20260608T232533Z.post.manthan-status.txt`; `20260608T232533Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Host preflight showed Copilot token env unset; Manthan post status stayed clean.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T232533Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T232533Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T233913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T233913Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `ade2df6478e520ac8bcfb3d1626d3085e3764d09d2912301b2d76c6c488dd44f`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis detected; audit found 23 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260608T233913Z.review-proof.md`; `20260608T233913Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260608T233913Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=23` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L4`: Lane 1 boundary remains unresolved at target HEAD.	`20260608T233913Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260608T233913Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose shows app-tier published ports `47000`, `47001`, `47002`, `47003`, and `27000` without loopback host entries.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L5`: Conduir loop `P0` remains vulnerable to historical Manthan Phase 0 confusion and missing target-side gate evidence.	`20260608T233913Z.phase-authority.txt`; `20260608T233913Z.scripts-list.txt`; failed target-anchor and script checks	Tracker marks historical Phase 0 done; target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script checks failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L6`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target conflict remains open.	`20260608T233913Z.compose-targets.txt`; `diff -q docker-compose.yml infra/compose/docker-compose.yml`; gap remediation plan Lane 0	Both compose files parse and differ; Manthan docs call `infra/compose` the internal default, while Conduir remediation selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L7`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate path remains stale.	`20260608T233913Z.gate-path.txt`; `20260608T233913Z.gates-list.txt`	`CLAUDE.md` cites `herald-protocol/manthan-platform/gates/...`; live `G-*.md` files exist under `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L8`: proof commands must use standalone `docker-compose` in this host unless the plugin form is installed.	`20260608T233913Z.docker-compose-version.txt`; `20260608T233913Z.docker-compose-plugin-version.txt`	Standalone `docker-compose` reported `v2.39.4`; plugin-form `docker compose version` exited `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L9`: raw current-cycle empty-DB/runtime-artifact claims are rejected.	Raw DeepSeek findings versus `20260608T233913Z.db-inspection.txt` and `20260608T233913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	Current DB has 23 analysis findings and runtime audit files exist in the controller workspace.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-08	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z-L10`: Copilot product action is blocked in this controller session.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; Manthan post-cycle status	No callable Copilot product-action lane was available; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260608T233913Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260608T233913Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260608T233913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T000325Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T000325Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `b1cb793dfc4120fbcfa5b72c808425982303250e0b53f113d1564a3a6797209a`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 26 rows across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T000325Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T000325Z.compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T000325Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T000325Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=26` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L4`: Lane 1 boundary remains unresolved at target HEAD.	`20260609T000325Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260609T000325Z.routes-write-boundary.txt`; `20260609T000325Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose shows app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes substrate write routes plus runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L5`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T000325Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `20260609T000325Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search returned no anchor/smoke/selection files and `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L6`: Copilot product action is blocked in this controller session.	`logs/20260609T000325Z.log`; `20260609T000325Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T000325Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Wrapper log records GitHub/Copilot token presence checks as unset; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L7`: Docker daemon/image proof is unavailable from this controller shell.	`20260609T000325Z.docker-images.txt`	`docker images --format ...` exited `1` with Docker socket permission denied, so local image readiness was not replayed here.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L8`: `current.json` held a stale running marker before finalization.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/current.json`; `20260609T000325Z.current-pid.txt`	`current.json` recorded PID `4029586`; `ps -p 4029586` exited `1`; finalizer updated the cycle marker to completed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z-L9`: raw doc/runtime claims were corrected or rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T000325Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T000325Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T000325Z.db-inspection.txt`	The tracker does not repeat the stale gate path, but it has a separate stale API source path; the DB is not empty and audit files exist.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T000325Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T000325Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T001705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T001705Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `6c88de26fb56fbd8aff0cee30350265c8604f720f0114ac725ab3066a7a29097`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 12 rows with substantive `claude` and `gemini` findings.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T001705Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T001705Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T001705Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T001705Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=12` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L4`: Manthan tracker Phase 5 status frames conflict while Conduir loop `P0` remains external.	`20260609T001705Z.phase-authority-manthan.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.phase-authority-conduir.txt`	Tracker says Phase 5 is done by internal-research definition and also labels AWS Deployment in progress; Conduir state still declares `active_phase: P0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved.	`20260609T001705Z.compose-targets.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.root-vs-infra-compose.diff.txt`; root and infra compose config proofs	Three compose files exist, root and `infra/compose` differ, and both selected targets parse.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T001705Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search returned no anchor/smoke/selection files and `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L7`: Manthan operator docs still have gate/API path drift.	`20260609T001705Z.gate-path.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.gates-list.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.doc-drift.txt`	`CLAUDE.md` cites the stale nested gate path; live gates exist at root; tracker still cites stale `services/api/main.py`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller session.	`20260609T001705Z.action-agent-proof.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T001705Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Copilot/GitHub tokens are unset in the wrapper log, Docker socket access is denied, no callable action lane was used, and Manthan stayed clean.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L9`: HEAD freshness is valid for target Manthan, while planning findings were replayed because the packet Conduir HEAD was stale.	`cycle-packet-20260609T001705Z.md`; `20260609T001705Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.engine-head.txt`	Packet Manthan HEAD matched live target HEAD; live Conduir HEAD was `69f710813b931c66d2d48aceddde5de4bef3aac3`, so controller findings were replayed against current files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z-L10`: raw unsupported claims were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T001705Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T001705Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T001705Z.review-proof.md`	DeepSeek was unparsed/non-substantive; candidate commands were read-only and not unsafe; DB was not empty.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T001705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T001705Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T001705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T003053Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T003053Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `14a989d82a8710c1a469073d42932124a946802d3d064aae43930b04e0b0e8ab`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 27 rows split `claude:7`, `deepseek:12`, `gemini:8`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T003053Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T003053Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T003053Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, Manthan status was clean, and no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T003053Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=27` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles=objectives=mutations=evaluations=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target anchor and conflicting Phase 5 status frames.	`20260609T003053Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Tracker status proof shows internal-research done and AWS Deployment in-progress frames; Conduir state remains `active_phase: P0`; target anchor search returned zero lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved.	`20260609T003053Z.compose-targets.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; gap remediation Lane 0	Three compose files exist; root compose parses; docs still frame `infra/compose/` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T003053Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	`find docs scripts ...` returned zero lines for the anchor and required scripts.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L7`: Lane 1 boundary remains deferred but proof-backed.	`20260609T003053Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes substrate POST routes plus runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller session.	`20260609T003053Z.action-agent-proof-summary.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T003053Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Copilot/GitHub tokens are unset in the wrapper log, Docker socket access is denied, no callable product-action lane was used, and Manthan stayed clean.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L9`: HEAD freshness is valid for this cycle.	`cycle-packet-20260609T003053Z.md`; `git rev-parse HEAD` outputs for Manthan, Conduir, and engine	Packet HEADs matched live Manthan, Conduir, and engine HEADs before finalization.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z-L10`: raw unsupported claims were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T003053Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T003053Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T003053Z.review-proof.md`	Gemini workspace-access claims are false here, DeepSeek empty-DB claims are false against the current DB, and candidate commands are read-only but insufficient rather than unsafe.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T003053Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T003053Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T005132Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T005132Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `d453bad81e9916b768122fd5acc6f4d5f75aa74a37ebba863a5eb1dd0e416ea5`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 17 rows split `claude:7`, `deepseek:1`, `gemini:9`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T005132Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T005132Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T005132Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T005132Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=17` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, and `evaluations` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T005132Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker records historical/product phase status while Conduir state declares external loop `P0`; target anchor search returned zero lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved.	`20260609T005132Z.compose-targets.txt`; root and infra compose config proofs; gap remediation Lane 0	Three compose files exist; root and `infra/compose` both parse; Manthan docs still frame `infra/compose/` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T005132Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search returned zero lines for the anchor and required scripts.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L7`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate path is stale.	`20260609T005132Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.gate-files.txt`	`CLAUDE.md` cites `herald-protocol/manthan-platform/gates/...`; live discovery lists all 13 gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L8`: Lane 1 boundary remains deferred but proof-backed.	`20260609T005132Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L9`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller session.	`20260609T005132Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T005132Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	No callable Copilot product-action lane was available; Docker socket access was denied; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L10`: HEAD freshness was replayed against live files.	`cycle-packet-20260609T005132Z.md`; `20260609T005132Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.engine-head.txt`	Packet Manthan/engine HEADs matched live; packet Conduir HEAD differed, so controller findings were replayed against current planning files.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z-L11`: raw critical planning-workspace and gate-count claims were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T005132Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T005132Z.gate-files.txt`; `20260609T005132Z.db-inspection.txt`	Planning repo access is controller context, all 13 gates exist under root `manthan-platform/gates/`, and DB is not empty.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T005132Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `conduir_changed`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T005132Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T005132Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T010609Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T010609Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `b5f70b1d66823b37da559cb57c089ac2ecce0f6ec2a75e66b200716815e5ff96`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 10 rows split `claude:8`, `deepseek:1`, `gemini:1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T010609Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T010609Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T010609Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T010609Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=10` and `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, and `evaluations` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T010609Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker records historical/product phase status while Conduir state declares external loop `P0`; target anchor search shows the anchor absent.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved without the missing anchor.	`20260609T010609Z.compose-targets.txt`; root and infra compose config proofs; gap remediation Lane 0	Three compose files exist; root and `infra/compose` both parse; Manthan docs still frame `infra/compose/` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T010609Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search shows the anchor and required scripts absent; `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L7`: Manthan `CLAUDE.md` gate path is stale.	`20260609T010609Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.gate-files.txt`	`CLAUDE.md` cites the stale nested gate path; live discovery lists all 13 gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L8`: Lane 1 boundary remains deferred but proof-backed.	`20260609T010609Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L9`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller session.	`20260609T010609Z.action-agent-availability.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T010609Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	No callable Copilot product-action lane was available; GitHub tokens are absent; Docker socket access was denied; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z-L10`: the untracked conformance `package-lock.json` finding was rejected as high severity for this proof.	`logs/20260609T010609Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T010609Z.post.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T010609Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer downgraded the risk; the file remains untracked and no static compose proof depends on it.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T010609Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `conduir_changed`; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T010609Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T010609Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T011844Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T011844Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `b9247b4983db2f7bb31086eeb683cf2715dedaa05798b1e49b4b2b8aff09be29`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 11 rows split `claude:6`, `deepseek:1`, `gemini:4`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T011844Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T011844Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T011844Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T011844Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=11`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, and `evaluations` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T011844Z.phase-target-proof.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker records historical/product phase status while Conduir state declares external loop `P0`; target anchor search returned no required anchor file.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved without the missing anchor.	`20260609T011844Z.compose-targets.txt`; root and infra compose config proofs; gap remediation Lane 0	Three compose files exist; root and `infra/compose` both parse; Manthan docs still frame `infra/compose` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent.	`20260609T011844Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search returned zero lines for the anchor and required scripts.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L7`: Lane 1 boundary remains deferred but proof-backed.	`20260609T011844Z.root-compose-ports-defaults.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes application write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L8`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated in this shell.	`20260609T011844Z.action-agent-proof.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `20260609T011844Z.manthan-status.txt`	No-edit Copilot probe exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L9`: live smoke and Docker image proof are blocked by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T011844Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.review-proof.md`	`docker images` exited `1` with Docker socket permission denied.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T011844Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T011844Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer dropped the unparsed DeepSeek row and downranked the guarded-vs-degraded wording ambiguity as not actionable as written.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z-L11`: Manthan operator docs still have proof-backed gate-path drift.	`20260609T011844Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T011844Z.gate-files.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording while live discovery lists all 13 gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T011844Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T011844Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T011844Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L1`: full-swarm review degraded and cannot authorize product edits or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T013354Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T013354Z.swarm.status`; DB SHA `b189ff57a72d6d49e6e4eff04aa5cbb44f8e4eb72890ecf71e22a9ff983a961b`	Host status `124`; audit `DEGRADED`; reviewer synthesis absent; DB inspection found 17 analysis rows but no execute/evolution rows.	review-only	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke.	`20260609T013354Z.local-proof.md`; `20260609T013354Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T013354Z.scripts.txt`	Compose parse passed; no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L3`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and root-vs-infra target drift.	`20260609T013354Z.anchor-files.txt`; `20260609T013354Z.anchor-and-script-claims.txt`; phase state	Anchor discovery returned zero lines; Manthan docs still frame `infra/compose/` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L4`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T013354Z.scripts.txt`; `20260609T013354Z.anchor-files.txt`; phase gates	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; anchor discovery found no target loop-anchor file.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L5`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved.	`20260609T013354Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T013354Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports lack loopback `host_ip`; substrate POST routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all` exist.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L6`: status, NATS/HERALD, and selection claims are not proven by a running product stack this cycle.	`20260609T013354Z.status-claims.txt`; `20260609T013354Z.arch-claims.txt`	Static grep captured claims and default-off settings; no live stack probe ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z-L7`: raw degraded-swarm findings were rejected for promotion.	`logs/20260609T013354Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T013354Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T013354Z.local-proof.md`	Swarm output was empty, host status was `124`, and reviewer synthesis was absent; local proof replays only advisory findings.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T013354Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T013354Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T013354Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T015405Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T015405Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `df4cacd56ad841d32b89a82375a4e3b4346a604b1b0a2eddfa823ff70d564690`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 16 rows split `claude:1`, `deepseek:10`, `gemini:5`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L2`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T015405Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T015405Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T015405Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L3`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T015405Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=16`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T015405Z.status-claims.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Manthan tracker records historical/product phase status while Conduir state declares external loop `P0`; target anchor test failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L5`: root-vs-`infra/compose` target selection remains unresolved without the missing anchor.	`20260609T015405Z.status-claims.txt`; root and infra compose config proofs; gap remediation Lane 0	Root and `infra/compose` both parse; Manthan docs still frame `infra/compose/` as internal default while Conduir selects root compose for product-stack smoke.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T015405Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	Target file search listed only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; direct anchor/smoke/selection tests failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved.	`20260609T015405Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier ports lack loopback `host_ip`; substrate POST routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all` exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L8`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated in this shell.	`20260609T015405Z.copilot-path.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot CLI exists, but no-edit `copilot -p` exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L9`: live smoke and Docker image proof are blocked by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T015405Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.review-proof.md`	`docker images` exited `1` with Docker daemon socket permission denied.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T015405Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T015405Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T015405Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Raw empty-DB claim is false against inspected DB; the untracked conformance package-lock is a hygiene item, not a static compose blocker.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T015405Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T015405Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T015405Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T020759Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T020759Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `268579819686bca976af9d30f150e9485d931b56f740635c6012080fffe57f9f`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 24 rows split `claude:7`, `deepseek:12`, `gemini:5`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T020759Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=24`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L3`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T020759Z.status-claims.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.anchor-proof.exit`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Anchor file test failed; Manthan tracker records historical/product phase status while Conduir state declares external loop `P0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L4`: root compose remains the selected Conduir product-stack smoke target, with `infra/compose/` as supporting evidence.	`20260609T020759Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T020759Z.root-compose-config-q.exit`; `20260609T020759Z.infra-compose-config-q.exit`; remediation plan Lane 0	Root and `infra/compose` static config proofs exited `0`; target-side anchor remains absent.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L5`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T020759Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T020759Z.scripts-list.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.root-smoke-file.exit`; `20260609T020759Z.selection-ab-file.exit`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L6`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved and deferred behind Lane 0.	`20260609T020759Z.root-compose-ports.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes application write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L7`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T020759Z.copilot-path.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot CLI exists, but no-edit `copilot -p` exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L8`: live smoke and Docker image proof are blocked by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T020759Z.docker-images.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.docker-images.exit`; `20260609T020759Z.review-proof.md`	`docker images` exited `1`; no `docker-compose up` or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L9`: Manthan operator docs still contain proof-backed path drift.	`20260609T020759Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.gate-files.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live discovery lists gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T020759Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T020759Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T020759Z.routes.txt`	Reviewer rejected the healthcheck mismatch; raw empty-DB claim is false against inspected DB; untracked package-lock remains hygiene only.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T020759Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T020759Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T022139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T022139Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `f87913575a92d0f68153798f8fa9eb749844473104af13c03adee564bb2b3d9a`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 27 rows split `claude:9`, `deepseek:11`, `gemini:7`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T022139Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=27`, but `cycles`, `objectives`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L3`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T022139Z.phase-target-evidence.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.anchor-file.exit`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Anchor file test failed; Manthan product phase text remains separate from Conduir loop `P0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L4`: root compose remains the selected Conduir product-stack smoke target, with `infra/compose/` as supporting evidence.	`20260609T022139Z.root-compose-config-q.exit`; `20260609T022139Z.infra-compose-config-q.exit`; remediation plan Lane 0	Root and `infra/compose` static config proofs exited `0`; target-side anchor remains absent.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L5`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T022139Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T022139Z.root-smoke-file.exit`; `20260609T022139Z.selection-ab-file.exit`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L6`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved and deferred behind Lane 0.	`20260609T022139Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host entries, and route proof includes application write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L7`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T022139Z.copilot-path.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot CLI exists, but no-edit `copilot -p` exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L8`: live smoke is blocked in this controller context by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T022139Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.docker-ps.exit`; `20260609T022139Z.review-proof.md`	`docker ps` exited `1`; reviewer host-context Docker success is recorded as context divergence, not product proof.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L9`: Manthan operator docs still contain proof-backed path drift.	`20260609T022139Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.gate-files.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live discovery lists gate files under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T022139Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T022139Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T022139Z.review-proof.md`	Product `Phase 0 CLOSED` is a different namespace; raw empty-DB claim is false against inspected DB; untracked package-lock remains hygiene only.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T022139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T022139Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T022139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T023732Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T023732Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `447dcf66dadf5e03b291b481676852244df0254b44ae07c93d8dde6655277d8b`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 22 rows split `claude:9`, `deepseek:10`, `gemini:3`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute/evolution cycle.	`20260609T023732Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=22`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L3`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T023732Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T023732Z.root-compose-config-q.exit`; `20260609T023732Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Compose parse passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L4`: Lane 0 remains blocked by missing target-side loop anchor and phase namespace drift.	`20260609T023732Z.status-claims.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.anchor-file.exit`; phase state	Anchor file test failed; Manthan product phase text remains separate from Conduir loop `P0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L5`: root compose remains the selected Conduir product-stack smoke target, with `infra/compose/` as supporting evidence.	`20260609T023732Z.root-compose-config-q.exit`; `20260609T023732Z.infra-compose-config-q.exit`; remediation plan Lane 0	Root and `infra/compose` static config proofs exited `0`; target-side anchor remains absent.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L6`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T023732Z.anchor-smoke-selection-files.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.scripts-list.txt`; file test exits	Direct anchor/smoke/selection tests exited `1`; `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved and deferred behind Lane 0.	`20260609T023732Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Expanded root compose lists app-tier published ports without loopback host binding evidence, and route proof includes application write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L8`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T023732Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.action-patch-packet.md`	No-edit Copilot probe exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L9`: live smoke is blocked in this controller context by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T023732Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.docker-ps.exit`; `20260609T023732Z.review-proof.md`	`docker ps` exited `1`; no `docker-compose up` or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T023732Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T023732Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T023732Z.manthan-status.txt`	Raw DB-empty claim is false against inspected DB; host Docker success is context-specific; untracked package-lock remains hygiene only.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T023732Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T023732Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T025024Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T025024Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `933339d55e2e854082ec37ed3c9f7deb70f4eba34a8d0391ed7c2e2ab3516daa`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; DB inspection found 32 rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=23`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T025024Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=32`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L3`: the packet wording created a phase-namespace false-positive risk.	`logs/20260609T025024Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `20260609T025024Z.runner-bash-n.exit`	Controller packet generator now says Conduir loop P0 is an external control phase; `bash -n` exited `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L4`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T025024Z.root-compose-config-q.exit`; `20260609T025024Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T025024Z.scripts-list.txt`	Compose config exited `0`, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L5`: target-side loop anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script are absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T025024Z.anchor-file.exit`; `20260609T025024Z.root-smoke-file.exit`; `20260609T025024Z.selection-ab-file.exit`; `20260609T025024Z.scripts-list.txt`	Direct file tests exited `1`; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L6`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T025024Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L7`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T025024Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.docker-ps.txt`	Copilot auth probe exited `1`; Docker socket proof exited `1`; no Manthan product edit or live smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L8`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T025024Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.gate-files.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live gate files exist under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L9`: the raw claim that Manthan product Phase 0 DONE invalidates Conduir loop P0 is rejected.	`20260609T025024Z.control-phase-proof.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Conduir loop P0 is an external control-loop overlay; packet wording was patched to prevent repeated confusion.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z-L10`: target HEAD freshness passed, but packet planning HEAD was stale.	`cycle-packet-20260609T025024Z.md`; `20260609T025024Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260609T025024Z.engine-head.txt`	Target and engine packet HEADs matched live proof; packet Conduir HEAD differed, so accepted Manthan findings rely on replayed target proof.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T025024Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T025024Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T030654Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T030654Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `ddbc7d174e5899a127630a7c2c00686bba1b8b55e62afd36e78ee8ec69a1a059`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 13 rows split `claude:8`, `deepseek:1`, `gemini:4`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T030654Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=13`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L3`: the host packet used stale Lane 0 wording relative to the live runner source, and the runner now names the anchor proof explicitly.	`cycle-packet-20260609T030654Z.md`; `20260609T030654Z.packet-wording-proof.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.runner-packet-proof.txt`	Packet still used old `P0 remains active` wording; live runner now includes the external-control wording and `test -f docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `bash -n` passed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L4`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T030654Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T030654Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; direct script file tests	Compose config passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, selection script, or full P0 proof set ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L5`: Lane 0 target-side artifacts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T030654Z.scripts-list.txt`; direct anchor, smoke, and selection tests	Direct file tests exited `1`; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L6`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T030654Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L7`: product action is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T030654Z.copilot-path.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot CLI exists, but no-edit `copilot -p` exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L8`: live smoke is blocked in this controller context by Docker socket permissions.	`20260609T030654Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.review-proof.md`	`docker ps` exited `1`; no `docker-compose up` or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L9`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T030654Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.gate-files.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live gate files exist under root `manthan-platform/gates/`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T030654Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T030654Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.runner-packet-proof.txt`	External audit-file access failures are not repo findings; raw product Phase 5 relabeling is rejected because Conduir loop P0 is external; untracked package-lock remains hygiene only.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z-L11`: target HEAD freshness passed, but packet planning HEAD was stale.	`cycle-packet-20260609T030654Z.md`; `20260609T030654Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260609T030654Z.engine-head.txt`	Target and engine packet HEADs matched live proof; packet Conduir HEAD differed, so accepted Manthan findings rely on replayed target proof.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T030654Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T030654Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T032103Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T032103Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `f7132dbc655c0ca91216cd230024e7fe67512ca28d682e6244fc5501db57d97d`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 33 rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=14`, `gemini=10`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T032103Z.review-proof.md`; DB inspection of `logs/20260609T032103Z.swarm.db`	DB contains `analysis_findings=33`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L3`: current packet proof wording was stale relative to the live controller script.	`cycle-packet-20260609T032103Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `20260609T032103Z.head-freshness.txt`	Packet Manthan HEAD matched live target HEAD; packet Conduir HEAD was stale, so controller claims were replayed against current files.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T032103Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof cannot run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L5`: root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T032103Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.scripts.txt`	Direct file checks show both required scripts missing; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L6`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T032103Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T032103Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T032103Z.review-proof.md`	Root and infra config proofs passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T032103Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T032103Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T032103Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot auth probe exited `1`; Docker socket proof exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T032103Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T032103Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T032103Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T032103Z.compose-version.txt`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB; standalone `docker-compose` is v2.39.4, not v1; product Phase 5/AWS text is not itself a Conduir loop P0 blocker.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T032103Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T032103Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T034013Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T034013Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `2327d8853d5e4344d65a8acc912db3641fd1248b0e754ed179f55ed74db77114`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 43 rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=14`, `gemini=21`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T034013Z.review-proof.md`; DB inspection of `logs/20260609T034013Z.swarm.db`	DB contains `analysis_findings=43`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L3`: target HEAD freshness passed, but the planning repo HEAD advanced after the host packet was written.	`cycle-packet-20260609T034013Z.md`; `20260609T034013Z.head-freshness.txt`; live proof artifacts	Packet Manthan and engine HEADs matched live proof; packet Conduir HEAD differed, so accepted controller findings rely on replayed current-file proof.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T034013Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof cannot run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L5`: root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T034013Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.scripts.txt`	Direct file checks show both required scripts missing; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L6`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T034013Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T034013Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T034013Z.review-proof.md`	Root and infra config proofs passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T034013Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T034013Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T034013Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot auth probe exited `1`; Docker socket proof exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T034013Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z-L10`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T034013Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T034013Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T034013Z.compose-version.txt`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB; standalone `docker-compose` is v2.39.4, not v1; product Phase 5/AWS text is not itself a Conduir loop P0 blocker.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T034013Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T034013Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T034013Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T035439Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T035439Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `6333fe710acb8bfe69f3644f3e5c0c6704436f104e4deb362dd40de58cd28f95`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 23 rows split `claude=7`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=5`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T035439Z.review-proof.md`; DB inspection of `logs/20260609T035439Z.swarm.db`	DB contains `analysis_findings=23`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L3`: target HEAD freshness passed, but host packet wording was stale relative to the live dirty runner proof block.	`cycle-packet-20260609T035439Z.md`; `20260609T035439Z.head-freshness.txt`; `git diff -- delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`	Target Manthan HEAD matched live proof; packet phase-conflation criticism is local to this packet and should be cleared by regenerating from the live runner.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T035439Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof cannot run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L5`: root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T035439Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.scripts.txt`	Direct file checks show both required scripts missing; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L6`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T035439Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T035439Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T035439Z.review-proof.md`	Root and infra config proofs passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T035439Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T035439Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot auth probe exited `1`; Docker socket proof exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T035439Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L10`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T035439Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.gate-files.txt`; `20260609T035439Z.file-gates.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live gate/API files exist at canonical paths.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z-L11`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T035439Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T035439Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T035439Z.compose-version.txt`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB; standalone `docker-compose` is v2.39.4, not v1; product phase labels are not themselves Conduir loop P0 blockers.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T035439Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T035439Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T035439Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T041055Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T041055Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `cc9b39d20628e5eb94f716961e89b709541dd5aa55e3b512edd3278cbeed7814`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 24 rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=10`, `gemini=5`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T041055Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T041055Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=24`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L3`: packet HEAD freshness passed, but the packet objective remained broader than the one-lane execution target.	`cycle-packet-20260609T041055Z.md`; `20260609T041055Z.packet-heads.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.review-proof.md`	Packet heads matched live committed HEADs; operator scoped execution to Lane 0 only under the remediation order.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T041055Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof cannot run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L5`: root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T041055Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.scripts.txt`	Direct file checks show both required scripts missing; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L6`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T041055Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T041055Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T041055Z.review-proof.md`	Root and infra config proofs passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T041055Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T041055Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot auth probe exited `1`; Docker socket proof exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T041055Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L10`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T041055Z.doc-drift.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.gate-files.txt`; `20260609T041055Z.api-paths.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live gate/API files exist at canonical paths.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z-L11`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T041055Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T041055Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T041055Z.compose-version.txt`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB; the opened L0 row was normal preflight state; standalone `docker-compose` is v2.39.4, not v1; product phase labels are not themselves Conduir loop P0 blockers.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T041055Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T041055Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T041055Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T042847Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T042847Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `d443fb5277b9b8256f36dfae41a5c94ae38fd14d0c53672ae58964f69e204ad6`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer consensus present; DB inspection found 51 rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=32`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T042847Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T042847Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=51`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L3`: packet HEAD freshness passed, but the packet objective remained broader than the one-lane execution target.	`cycle-packet-20260609T042847Z.md`; `20260609T042847Z.packet-heads.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.review-proof.md`	Packet heads matched live committed HEADs; operator scoped execution to Lane 0 only under the remediation order.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T042847Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof cannot run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L5`: root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T042847Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.scripts.txt`	Direct file checks show both required scripts missing; scripts list contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L6`: static compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T042847Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T042847Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T042847Z.review-proof.md`	Root and infra config proofs passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L7`: read-only outward posture remains unresolved for the root product stack.	`20260609T042847Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L8`: product action and live smoke are blocked in this controller context.	`20260609T042847Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.docker-ps.txt`; `20260609T042847Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Docker socket proof exited `1`; Copilot CLI exists, but no callable authenticated Codex product-edit lane was available; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T042847Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L10`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T042847Z.doc-drift.txt`	Doc grep found stale nested gate wording and stale API path text while live gate/API files exist at canonical paths.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z-L11`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T042847Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T042847Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T042847Z.compose-version.txt`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB; standalone `docker-compose` is v2.39.4, not v1; product phase labels are not themselves Conduir loop P0 blockers.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T042847Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T042847Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T042847Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T044306Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T044306Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `471523103c42bd25c1693792fb2409d22c90d44ec8991ecc6ebbd01b4a77881a`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; DB inspection found 13 rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=4`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T044306Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.review-proof.md`	DB contains `analysis_findings=13`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L3`: the phase mismatch is a namespace-anchor gap.	`20260609T044306Z.phase-namespace-proof.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Conduir loop `P0` is an external control-loop phase while Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 as done.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L4`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T044306Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof exited `2`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L5`: static root compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T044306Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T044306Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T044306Z.review-proof.md`	Root compose config passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, root-smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L6`: product action is blocked because Copilot is not authenticated.	`20260609T044306Z.copilot-command.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot exists on PATH, but no-edit probe exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L7`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T044306Z.doc-drift-proof.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.gate-files.txt`	`CLAUDE.md` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` contain stale paths while live canonical files exist; Lane 4 remains deferred.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L8`: raw `.env` committed-secret finding was rejected.	`20260609T044306Z.env-ls-files.txt`; `20260609T044306Z.env-check-ignore.txt`; `logs/20260609T044306Z.swarm.out`	`git ls-files .env` returned empty and `git check-ignore -v .env` reports `.gitignore:2:.env`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z-L9`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T044306Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T044306Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T044306Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T044306Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T045707Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T045707Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `f0bf76c7c77e8f9019d6f176bbce0580aebfb180d31a9f10d582f19917a1ad82`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; DB inspection found 29 rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=10`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T045707Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T045707Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=29`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L3`: raw incomplete-cycle claims are stale or scoped down against current artifacts.	`logs/20260609T045707Z.swarm.status`; `logs/20260609T045707Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T045707Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.review-proof.md`	Status and output exist, DB rows belong to this run id, and post-status files are expected only after nested finalization.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L4`: the phase mismatch is a namespace-anchor gap.	`20260609T045707Z.phase-namespace-proof.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Conduir loop `P0` is an external control-loop phase while Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 as done.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L5`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T045707Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof exited `2`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L6`: static root compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T045707Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T045707Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T045707Z.review-proof.md`	Root compose config passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, root-smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L7`: product action is blocked because Copilot is not authenticated.	`20260609T045707Z.copilot-command.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot exists on PATH, but no-edit probe exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L8`: Lane 1 read-only outward posture remains unresolved and deferred behind Lane 0.	`20260609T045707Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes substrate write routes and runtime `/admin/pause-all`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L9`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T045707Z.doc-drift-proof.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.gate-files.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.api-path-test.exit`	`CLAUDE.md` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` contain stale paths while live canonical files exist; Lane 4 remains deferred.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L10`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T045707Z.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	guarded	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z-L11`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T045707Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T045707Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T045707Z.review-proof.md`	Raw empty-DB claims are false against inspected DB, and raw incomplete-artifact claims are stale against current status/output files.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T045707Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T045707Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T045707Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T051236Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T051236Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T051236Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `143`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it is review coverage only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T052417Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T052417Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `1f8ec8948815d41ab6e903f231e6b93a0a2bdc533bb4ee8b44c6688455c8ce87`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; DB inspection found 12 rows split `claude=7`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=4`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L2`: this cycle is review-only, not an execute or evolution cycle.	`20260609T052417Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T052417Z.db-inspection.txt`	DB contains `analysis_findings=12`, but execute/evolution tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L3`: target HEAD freshness passed, but packet planning HEAD was stale.	`cycle-packet-20260609T052417Z.md`; `20260609T052417Z.manthan-head.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.conduir-head.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.engine-head.txt`	Manthan and engine packet HEADs matched live proof; packet Conduir HEAD differed, so controller findings were replayed against current files.	controller	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L4`: the phase mismatch is a namespace-anchor gap.	`20260609T052417Z.phase-namespace-proof.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	Conduir loop `P0` is an external control-loop phase while Manthan tracker records historical Phase 0 as done and Phase 5 product-history frames.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L5`: Lane 0 target-side anchor remains absent at Manthan HEAD.	`20260609T052417Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.action-patch-packet.md`	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is missing, so the Lane 0 grep proof exited `2`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L6`: static root compose validation still under-proves root product-stack smoke and P0 exit.	`20260609T052417Z.root-compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T052417Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T052417Z.review-proof.md`	Root compose config passed, but no service startup, endpoint probe, root-smoke script, or selection script ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L7`: product action is blocked because Copilot is not authenticated.	`20260609T052417Z.copilot-command.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Copilot exists on PATH, but no-edit probe exited `1`; no Manthan product file was edited.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L8`: Lane 1 read-only outward posture remains unresolved and deferred behind Lane 0.	`20260609T052417Z.port-evidence.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.root-compose.expanded.yml`	App-tier ports lack loopback `host_ip` entries while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L9`: low-risk Manthan doc drift remains proof-backed.	`20260609T052417Z.doc-drift-proof.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.gate-files.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.api-path-test.exit`	`CLAUDE.md` and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` contain stale paths while live canonical files exist; Lane 4 remains deferred.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L10`: clean-tree proof is non-deterministic because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`20260609T052417Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json` before and after the cycle.	guarded	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z-L11`: raw weak findings were rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T052417Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T052417Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T052417Z.review-proof.md`	Raw no-audit claims are false against the current audit file, and direct relabeling to Manthan Phase 5 is rejected because Conduir loop P0 is external.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T052417Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; no Manthan product edit or phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T052417Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T052417Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T055925Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T055925Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T055925Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T062818Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T062818Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T062818Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T065352Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T065352Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T065352Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T071745Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T071745Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T071745Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T074133Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T074133Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T074133Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T075748Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T075748Z-L1`	local proof	The cycle cannot verify Lane 0's phase-anchor proof because the host swarm artifacts and deterministic file-content proof commands were uninspectable during this run.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T075748Z.local-proof.md` and `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T075748Z-learning-audit.md`.	BLOCKER; proof commands did not return usable output.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T075748Z-L2`	local proof	The Manthan target tree is not clean because an untracked `herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json` exists at current target HEAD.	`git -C manthan status --short` output recorded in the local proof note.	PASS for status capture; no write action authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T075748Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T075748Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T075748Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T082959Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T082959Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T082959Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T085631Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T085631Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T085631Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T092738Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T092738Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T092738Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z-L1`: full-swarm review was healthy, but the reviewed host packet proof target still referenced absent optional `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T095424Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T095424Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T095424Z.review-proof.md`	Host status `0`; DB audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; optional anchor proof returned `MISSING`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z-L2`: non-circular Lane 0 proof against live `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` passes and the live runner source emits that proof block.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T095424Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`	Integration-doc `test -f` and grep passed; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passed; runner syntax passed.	controller	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z-L3`: Manthan clean-tree proof remains allowlist-sensitive because of a pre-existing untracked conformance package lock.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T095424Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T095424Z.review-proof.md`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z	P0	`manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z-L4`: raw DB-zero and untracked-lockfile severity claims were rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T095424Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T095424Z.swarm.out`	Wrapper DB audit reports `row_count: 27` and `health: OK`; untracked package-lock finding is status hygiene only.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T095424Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T095424Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T100736Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T100736Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T101720Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T101720Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T101720Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T101720Z.review-proof.md`	Host status `0`; DB audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=12`; no execute/evolution rows.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z-L2`	action agent proof	The exact Lane 0 product action was blocked because Copilot was not authenticated for the edit request.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T101720Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	`copilot -p <anchor-doc prompt>` exited `1` with no authentication information found; Manthan tracked diff remained empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z-L3`	deterministic proof	The target-side loop anchor remains absent, while safe root compose syntax and integration-doc proof pass.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T101720Z.review-proof.md`	Anchor `test -f` failed; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` and integration-doc grep passed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z-L4`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains allowlist-sensitive because the pre-existing untracked conformance package lock remains.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T101720Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T101720Z.review-proof.md`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z-L5`	reviewer filtering	The unparsed `deepseek` row was not promoted as a source claim.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T101720Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T101720Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected; substantive parsed findings came from `gemini` and `claude`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T101720Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T101720Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T102917Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T102917Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T102917Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T102917Z.review-proof.md`	Host status `0`; DB audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=11`; no execute/evolution rows.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z-L2`	controller proof	The reviewed host packet is stale relative to the current runner source.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T102917Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T102917Z.review-proof.md`	Packet still targets optional `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current runner source targets existing `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; runner syntax passed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z-L3`	deterministic proof	The integration-doc Lane 0 proof and static root compose validation pass, but the optional anchor and P0 smoke/selection scripts remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T102917Z.review-proof.md`; Manthan `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; Manthan `scripts/` listing	Integration-doc and root compose config proof passed; optional anchor, root-smoke script, and selection A/B script checks failed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z-L4`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains allowlist-sensitive because the pre-existing untracked conformance package lock remains.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T102917Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T102917Z.review-proof.md`	`git status --short` shows `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z-L5`	reviewer filtering	The missing optional anchor is not promoted as a requirement to create that file from this stale packet.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T102917Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T102917Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected as false-progress action because current runner source already retired this proof target.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T102917Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T102917Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T104437Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T104437Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T104437Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T105621Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T105621Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T105621Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `412c1dfd9fb29c900a8a4369460e1ed15a5abc5bc9fadc6b3a7b175d1cb78841`	Host status `0`; DB audit `OK`; 22 rows; reviewer synthesis present.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L2`	controller proof	The host packet still reviewed the retired optional-anchor proof while current runner source says to use `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T105621Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T105621Z.review-proof.md`	Packet proof targets `SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; runner proof targets `SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; runner syntax passed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L3`	reviewer/local proof	The untracked optional anchor is a false-progress artifact, not Lane 0 evidence.	`20260609T105621Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T105621Z.optional-anchor-stat.txt`; `20260609T105621Z.optional-anchor-git-log.txt`; host reviewer synthesis	File is untracked, has empty git history, and has an mtime inside this cycle while matching the stale proof vocabulary.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L4`	operator/action contract	Anchor cleanup is a Manthan product-file action and was not executed by the operator because the configured product action lane is `copilot`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T105621Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	No Manthan product edit was performed and P0 did not advance.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc/static-compose proof passes, but root-smoke and selection scripts are absent.	`20260609T105621Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T105621Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T105621Z.scripts-list.txt`	Static proof passed; both script executable checks failed; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T105621Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T105621Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T105621Z.status-claims.txt`	App-tier published ports lack loopback prefix evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof is dirty because the new untracked anchor and the pre-existing conformance package lock are both present.	`20260609T105621Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup action authorized this cycle.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw findings that treat the newly created optional anchor as successful remediation are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T105621Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T105621Z.review-proof.md`	Reviewer synthesis classified the creation as the violation.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T105621Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T105621Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T110804Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T110804Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T110804Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.db-inspection.txt`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=25`; no execute/evolution rows.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and controller proof	The candidate proof set is false-progress because the optional-anchor `test -f` and self-grep can pass on an untracked stub and do not exercise P0 exit gates.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T110804Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.file-gates.txt`	Reviewer consensus ranked the proof set as a blocker; `optional_anchor_test_f=0` but `optional_anchor_tracked=1`; smoke and selection gates fail.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L3`	deterministic proof	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is present but untracked and cannot count as Lane 0 evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.optional-anchor-stat.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.optional-anchor-tracked.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.optional-anchor-git-log.txt`	Status shows `??`; `git ls-files --error-unmatch` fails; git log is empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L4`	controller proof	The live runner and remediation plan target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`, while this host packet still targets the optional anchor.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.packet-source-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T110804Z.md`	Source/remediation plan say not to create the optional anchor solely for file-existence proof; packet proof commands use `SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc and root compose syntax proof pass, but root-smoke and selection A/B scripts remain absent and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.integration-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.compose-config-q.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.file-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.scripts-list.txt`	Integration and compose syntax pass; `root_smoke_test_x=1`, `selection_ab_test_x=1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.port-binding-context.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without `host_ip`; Postgres/NATS use `host_ip: local-service`; route proof contains write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package lock are both present.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup action authorized this cycle.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw recommendations to count or commit the existing optional anchor as current progress are rejected for this cycle because they conflict with the remediation plan and lack an authorized product-action lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T110804Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T110804Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Rejected; no Manthan product edit was executed; optional anchor remains untracked and blocked under `MAQ-018`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T110804Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta remains `manthan_changed` from untracked target artifacts; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T110804Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T110804Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T112111Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T112111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T112111Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T112111Z.db-inspection.txt`	Host status `0`; audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=29`; no execute/evolution rows.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked self-referential stub.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T112111Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T112111Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T112111Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep pass; `git ls-files --error-unmatch` exits `1`; reviewer consensus rejects the proof.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains: the packet targets the optional anchor while runner/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T112111Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T112111Z.packet-source-proof.txt`; remediation plan	Packet uses optional-anchor proof; runner/remediation say not to create it solely for file-existence proof.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T112111Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T112111Z.compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T112111Z.file-gates.txt`	Compose syntax exited `0`; both script executable checks exited `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T112111Z.port-binding-context.txt`; `20260609T112111Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without `host_ip`; write/admin surfaces are present.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T112111Z.copilot-probe.txt`; action queue	No-edit probe exited `1` with no authentication information found; no Manthan product edit occurred.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package lock are present.	`20260609T112111Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB findings are rejected.	`logs/20260609T112111Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T112111Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB audit JSON	Direct DB inspection found `analysis_findings=29` and audit health `OK`.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T112111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta remains `manthan_changed` from untracked target artifacts; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T112111Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T112111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T113253Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit	Full-swarm review is degraded for this cycle because only one substantive agent contributed and reviewer synthesis was missing from the DB audit.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T113253Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T113253Z.swarm.out`	Host status `0`; audit `DEGRADED`; substantive agents `gemini`; DB SHA `ddcc1f87d579dad70e4629deca210240faeeac735fbb08cc1e6e054a5b5e237e`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L2`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift persists because the packet targets optional-anchor proof while live control docs target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T113253Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/run_manthan_swarm_phase_loop.sh`; phase gates; remediation plan	Grep proof passed; packet uses `SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`, runner/gates/remediation use `SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L3`	local proof	The optional anchor is untracked and cannot count as Lane 0 evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T113253Z.local-proof.md`; Manthan `git status --short`; `git ls-files --error-unmatch docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`	Status shows `??`; `git ls-files` exits `1`; no cleanup authorized.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L4`	local proof	Integration-doc and root compose syntax proof pass, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T113253Z.local-proof.md`; `20260609T113253Z.compose.expanded.yml`; Manthan `scripts/` listing	Compose syntax and integration proof pass; both script executable checks exit `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L5`	local proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T113253Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T113253Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T113253Z.status-claims.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip`; write/admin routes are present.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L6`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package-lock are present.	`20260609T113253Z.local-proof.md`; Manthan `git status --short`	Status capture passed; no cleanup authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	Raw single-voice recommendations to commit the optional anchor or treat the conformance lockfile as a medium build risk are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T113253Z.swarm.out`; conformance lockfile; DB audit JSON	Rejected; swarm health degraded, and the lockfile pins no dependency tree.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z	P0	Host cycle degraded; no accepted learning and no phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T113253Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T113253Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; local proof advisory only; status delta `unchanged`; no Manthan product edit.	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T113253Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T113253Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T113253Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T114329Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T114329Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T114329Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `92139224ec1246f75b053838c0f74826bfdffe2bdb25647be9c57dded5967299`	Host status `0`; DB audit `OK`; `row_count: 23`; reviewer synthesis present in host output.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked self-referential artifact.	`logs/20260609T114329Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T114329Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T114329Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`	Reviewer synthesis ranked the proof set as a blocker; `git ls-files --error-unmatch docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L3`	deterministic proof	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is present on disk but untracked, absent from `HEAD`, older than the review run, and unreferenced by Manthan README/tracker.	`20260609T114329Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T114329Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.optional-anchor-stat.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.optional-anchor-git-log.txt`	Status shows `??`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; README/tracker grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L4`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains: live runner, gates, and remediation plan target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`, while the reviewed packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	`20260609T114329Z.packet-source-proof.txt`; `cycle-packet-20260609T114329Z.md`; remediation plan	Grep proof shows integration-doc proof in live controller artifacts and optional-anchor proof in the host packet.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T114329Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T114329Z.scripts.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.review-proof.md`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T114329Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T114329Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T114329Z.status-claims.txt`	App-tier published ports appear without loopback `host_ip` evidence, while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package lock are both present.	`20260609T114329Z.manthan-status.txt`; `logs/20260609T114329Z.pre.manthan.status`; `20260609T114329Z.review-proof.md`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized or executed.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw recommendations to count, commit, or otherwise treat the current optional anchor as Lane 0 progress are rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T114329Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `20260609T114329Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected because the artifact is untracked, self-referential, conflicts with current remediation order, and no authorized Manthan product action was executed.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T114329Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T114329Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T115542Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T115542Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T115542Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T115542Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=22`; execute/evolution ledger tables remain `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked self-referential artifact.	`logs/20260609T115542Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T115542Z.review-proof.md`; optional-anchor tracked/HEAD/absent proof files	`git ls-files --error-unmatch` exits `1`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`; `test ! -e` fails because cleanup did not run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T115542Z.md`; `20260609T115542Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Live runner/gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L4`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T115542Z.copilot-probe.txt`	`copilot` exists, but token env vars are unset and no-edit probe exits `1` with `No authentication information found`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T115542Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T115542Z.compose-config-q.out`; `20260609T115542Z.file-gates.txt`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks fail; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T115542Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T115542Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T115542Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package lock are present.	`20260609T115542Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB, root-vs-infra contradiction, and commit/enrich-anchor recommendations are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T115542Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T115542Z.db-inspection.txt`; remediation plan	Rejected or demoted; no Manthan product edit occurred.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T115542Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T115542Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T115542Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T115542Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T115542Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T121504Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L1`	host swarm review	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T121504Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T121504Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T121504Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=14`; execute/evolution ledger tables remain `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked self-referential artifact.	`logs/20260609T121504Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T121504Z.review-proof.md`; optional-anchor tracked/HEAD/absent proof files	`git ls-files --error-unmatch` exits `1`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`; `test ! -e` fails because cleanup did not run.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T121504Z.md`; `20260609T121504Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Live runner/gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L4`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T121504Z.copilot-probe.txt`	`copilot` exists, but token env vars are unset and no-edit probe exits `1` with `No authentication information found`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T121504Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T121504Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T121504Z.scripts.txt`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks fail; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T121504Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T121504Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T121504Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and pre-existing conformance package lock are present.	`20260609T121504Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB, read-only-boundary-violation, missing-root-env, and commit/enrich-anchor recommendations are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T121504Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T121504Z.db-inspection.txt`; remediation plan	Rejected or demoted; no Manthan product edit occurred.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T121504Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T121504Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T121504Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T121504Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T121504Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T122541Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T122541Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T124200Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T124200Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T124200Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `b9c5eadd05266e0c3ac6c4c7acaa86771864cb30d2f73efaade8f216beac071e`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; 33 findings from three agents.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L2`	Python DB inspection	This cycle produced review findings only, not execute/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T124200Z.db-inspection.txt`	`analysis_findings=33`; `findings`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked artifact with no current run-id binding.	`logs/20260609T124200Z.swarm.out`; optional-anchor proof files	`git ls-files` exits `1`, `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`, and run-id grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L4`	packet/source proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T124200Z.md`; `20260609T124200Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Live runner/gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T124200Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T124200Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T124200Z.scripts.txt`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks fail; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T124200Z.action-agent-auth.txt`; `20260609T124200Z.copilot-probe.txt`	Token env vars are unset and the no-edit probe exits `1` with no authentication information found.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L7`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T124200Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T124200Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T124200Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L8`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and conformance package-lock are present.	`20260609T124200Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T124200Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	Raw commit-all and count-anchor-as-progress recommendations are rejected.	`logs/20260609T124200Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; optional-anchor tracking proof	Rejected or demoted; no Manthan product edit occurred.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T124200Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T124200Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T124200Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T124200Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T125508Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T125508Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T125508Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `32aa2ecee1058f21a3df5f980262f085c550f486880aa309719f49bd02124160`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; 12 findings from three agents.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L2`	Python DB inspection	This cycle produced review findings only, not execute/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T125508Z.db-inspection.txt`	`analysis_findings=12`; `findings`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked artifact with no current run-id binding.	`logs/20260609T125508Z.swarm.out`; optional-anchor proof files	`git ls-files` exits `1`, `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`, and run-id grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L4`	packet/source proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T125508Z.md`; `20260609T125508Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Live runner/gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T125508Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T125508Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T125508Z.scripts.txt`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks fail; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T125508Z.action-agent-auth.txt`; `20260609T125508Z.copilot-noedit-probe.txt`	Token env vars are unset and the no-edit probe exits `1` with no authentication information found.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L7`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T125508Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T125508Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T125508Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L8`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and conformance package-lock are present.	`20260609T125508Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	The immediate recommendation to commit the optional anchor and tracker line is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T125508Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; optional-anchor tracking proof; Copilot auth proof	Rejected for this cycle because the write set is wider than the current remediation-plan action, the packet is still anchored on stale optional-anchor proof, and the action agent is unauthenticated.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T125508Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T125508Z.copilot-noedit-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T125508Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T125508Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T130622Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T130622Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T130622Z.swarm.out`; DB SHA `583b69425b5fd8b57e30f85de532a6ba4b58a6d5804161354abf62da19b84349`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; 21 findings from three agents.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L2`	Python DB inspection	This cycle produced review findings only, not execute/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T130622Z.db-inspection.txt`	`analysis_findings=21`; execute/evolution ledger tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof is false progress because it passes against an untracked artifact with no current run-id binding.	`logs/20260609T130622Z.swarm.out`; optional-anchor proof files	`git ls-files` exits `1`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`; run-id grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L4`	packet/source proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T130622Z.md`; `20260609T130622Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Live runner/gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T130622Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T130622Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T130622Z.file-gates.txt`	Compose syntax exits `0`; both script executable checks fail; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because Copilot is unauthenticated.	`20260609T130622Z.action-agent-auth.txt`; `20260609T130622Z.copilot-noedit-probe.txt`	Token env vars are unset and the no-edit probe exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L7`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T130622Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T130622Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T130622Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L8`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the untracked optional anchor and conformance package-lock are present.	`20260609T130622Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T130622Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture passed; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	The immediate recommendation to commit the optional anchor and tracker line is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T130622Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T130622Z.review-proof.md`; action-agent proof	Rejected because the artifact is untracked/self-referential, the remediation plan prefers the committed integration doc as Lane 0 evidence, and the action agent is unauthenticated.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T130622Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `20260609T130622Z.copilot-noedit-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T130622Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T130622Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T132104Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T132104Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T133449Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit	Full-swarm review is degraded for this cycle because only one substantive agent contributed and reviewer synthesis was missing from the DB audit.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T133449Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T133449Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T133449Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `42f08025e3ce449ba744d201060c4763d1ced96afba818a334024ad39f5cf1fb`	Host status `0`; audit `DEGRADED`; direct DB inspection found `analysis_findings=8` split `claude=1`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=6`, with execute/evolution tables empty.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L2`	local proof	The optional anchor is untracked, absent from `HEAD`, and not bound to this run id.	`20260609T133449Z.local-proof.md`; `20260609T133449Z.manthan-status.txt`; optional-anchor tracked/HEAD/run-id proof files	`git status` shows `??`; `git ls-files` exits `1`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:...` exits `128`; run-id grep exits `1`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L3`	local proof	Host packet/source drift remains between integration-doc control proof and optional-anchor packet proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T133449Z.md`; `20260609T133449Z.packet-source-proof.txt`	Runner, gates, and remediation plan target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`; packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L4`	local proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax pass, but smoke and selection executable gates fail.	`20260609T133449Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T133449Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T133449Z.scripts.txt`; script executable exit files	Compose syntax exits `0`; both executable checks exit `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L5`	local proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T133449Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T133449Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T133449Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence while write/admin routes exist.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L6`	local proof	NATS/HERALD/eventing claims are not P0 exit evidence until a live product-stack smoke proves the surfaces.	`20260609T133449Z.architecture-claims.txt`; `20260609T133449Z.local-proof.md`	Architecture grep shows designed NATS/HERALD claims and an integration-doc note that runtime still polls HTTP; no bridge/HERALD endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor and conformance package lock are untracked.	`20260609T133449Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture shows both untracked paths; no cleanup authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw single-voice recommendations to commit the optional anchor or sweep untracked files are rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T133449Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T133449Z.local-proof.md`	Rejected because swarm health is degraded, remediation-plan evidence is the committed integration doc, and no authorized product-action lane is available.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z	P0	Host cycle degraded; no accepted learning and no phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T133449Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T133449Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; local proof advisory only; no Manthan product edit; status delta `unchanged`.	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T133449Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T133449Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T133449Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T134803Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T134803Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T134803Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T134803Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=12`; execute/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes against an untracked artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD`.	`logs/20260609T134803Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T134803Z.review-proof.md`; optional-anchor tracking and HEAD checks	`test -f` and self-grep pass; tracked-state check exits `1`; HEAD check exits `128`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift persists between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T134803Z.md`; runner source; phase gates; remediation plan	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current control artifacts target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc and root compose syntax proof pass, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`20260609T134803Z.review-proof.md`; integration-doc grep; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q`; script executable checks	Integration-doc grep and compose config pass; both script executable checks exit `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L5`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T134803Z.review-proof.md`; Copilot binary and token environment checks	Copilot binary exists; `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` are unset; no Manthan product action executed.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L6`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only and no mutation, evaluation, promotion, or evolution rows.	`20260609T134803Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `e622a60a8372a9f44c46603736fa264b611f1a0f2e83ab6cc1e740ffd6b8f1bd`	Python read-only SQLite inspection found `analysis_findings=12`, `findings=0`, `mutations=0`, `evaluations=0`, `promotions=0`, `evolution_runs=0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor and conformance package-lock are untracked.	`20260609T134803Z.review-proof.md`; Manthan `git status --short`	Status shows both untracked paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	The immediate recommendation to commit the optional anchor is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T134803Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; optional-anchor tracking proof; Copilot auth proof	Rejected because the remediation plan prefers the committed integration doc, the file is untracked/self-referential, and product cleanup requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T134803Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T134803Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T134803Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T134803Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T135846Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T135846Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T135846Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T135846Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=18` split `claude=10`, `gemini=7`, `deepseek=1`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes against a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T135846Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`	`git ls-files` now exits `0` because the file is staged, but `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`, and tracker grep returns no match.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L3`	wrapper pre-status and reviewer proof	The anchor changed from untracked at cycle preflight to staged during the nominal review flow.	`logs/20260609T135846Z.pre.manthan.status`; `20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T135846Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Pre-status shows `?? docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; post proof shows `A docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L4`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift persists between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T135846Z.md`; remediation plan; phase gates; `20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`	Packet proof commands target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc and root compose syntax proof pass, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T135846Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Integration-doc grep exits `0`; `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L6`	deterministic proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T135846Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T135846Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T135846Z.routes.txt`	App-tier published ports appear without loopback `host_ip` evidence while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L7`	action-agent proof	The configured Copilot product-action lane is unavailable in this controller session.	`20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`	Copilot binary is present, but `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` are unset; no Manthan product edit or cleanup was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L8`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package-lock is untracked.	`20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T135846Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture shows `A docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` and `?? herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json`; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	The immediate recommendation to commit the optional anchor plus a tracker line is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T135846Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`; action-agent proof	Rejected for this cycle because the product-action agent is unauthenticated, the index changed during review, and no explicit human authorization was provided for Manthan product commits or tracker edits.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T135846Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T135846Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T135846Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T135846Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T141025Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T141025Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T142832Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T142832Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T142832Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T142832Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=18`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD`.	`logs/20260609T142832Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep pass; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; status shows `A docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T142832Z.md`; runner source; phase gates; remediation plan	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current control artifacts target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T142832Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L5`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup is blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` checks exit `1`; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L6`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package-lock is untracked.	`20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	The immediate recommendation to commit, drop, or otherwise use the optional anchor is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T142832Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected because the artifact is staged/self-validating, the remediation plan prefers the committed integration doc, and product cleanup requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T142832Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T142832Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T142832Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T142832Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T144034Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T144034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T144034Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T144034Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=28` split `claude=7`, `deepseek=13`, `gemini=8`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T144034Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep exit `0`; `git ls-files` exits `0`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T144034Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan; `20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T144034Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T144034Z.port-bindings.txt`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L5`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` are unset; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L6`	operator patch packet	The next authorized cleanup has an exact one-file target write set and proof command.	`20260609T144034Z.action-patch-packet.md`	Patch packet names `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` cleanup only, rejects committing the stub, and lists cleanup/integration/compose proof commands.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T144034Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw claims that the DB has zero rows, that the integration doc is in the wrong repo, or that the staged stub should simply be committed are rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T144034Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T144034Z.db-inspection.txt`; `20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`; remediation plan	DB inspection found 28 analysis rows; integration-doc proof exits `0` from the target repo; the staged 8-line stub is absent from HEAD and lacks tracker linkage.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T144034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T144034Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T144034Z.action-patch-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; exact cleanup patch packet emitted; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T144034Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T144034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T145227Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T145227Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T145227Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T145227Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=16` split `claude=1`, `deepseek=12`, `gemini=3`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD`.	`logs/20260609T145227Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T145227Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`	Status shows `A docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; no cleanup was authorized.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T145227Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T145227Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T145227Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T145227Z.port-bindings.txt`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier ports publish without loopback prefixes.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L5`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T145227Z.action-agent-auth.txt`	Copilot binary exists; `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` are unset; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L6`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T145227Z.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	Raw claims that the DB has zero rows, that the gates file is invented in all contexts, or that the staged stub should simply be committed are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T145227Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T145227Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`	DB inspection found 16 analysis rows; the gates file exists in the Conduir control repo; the staged anchor remains absent from Manthan `HEAD` and cleanup requires the configured action lane or explicit authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T145227Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T145227Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T145227Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T145227Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T150520Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T150520Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T150520Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T150520Z.db-inspection.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=23` split `claude=9`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=3`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L2`	Python DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T150520Z.db-inspection.txt`	`analysis_findings=23`; `findings`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T150520Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T150520Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T150520Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep exit `0`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L4`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T150520Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan; `20260609T150520Z.review-proof.md`	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; current gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T150520Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T150520Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T150520Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T150520Z.port-bindings.txt`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T150520Z.action-agent-auth.txt`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; token env vars are unset; stored `gh` credentials are invalid; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T150520Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T150520Z.post.manthan-status.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB and commit/count-anchor recommendations are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T150520Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T150520Z.db-inspection.txt`; remediation plan; action-agent proof	DB inspection found 23 analysis rows; staged anchor cleanup or commit requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T150520Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T150520Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T150520Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T150520Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T151642Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T151642Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T153419Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T153419Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T153419Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T153419Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=20` split `claude=8`, `deepseek=8`, `gemini=4`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L2`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD`.	`logs/20260609T153419Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T153419Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.review-proof.md`	`git status` shows the anchor staged; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L3`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains between optional-anchor packet proof and integration-doc control proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T153419Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan; `20260609T153419Z.integration-proof.txt`	Packet targets `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; gates/remediation target `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T153419Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.file-gates.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.port-bindings.txt`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L5`	deterministic compose proof and reviewer synthesis	The root compose `api` service loses inherited gateway/budget environment and the `nats` dependency because it re-declares `environment` and `depends_on` under the YAML merge anchor.	`logs/20260609T153419Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T153419Z.api-merge-source.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.api-compose-expanded.txt`	Expanded compose shows `api` depends only on `postgres` and `substrate`, and lacks the inherited gateway/budget env plus `nats` dependency.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T153419Z.action-agent.txt`; action queue	`copilot` binary exists; token variables are unset; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L7`	action queue lifecycle	The verified compose `api` merge defect is actionable only as a future candidate, not in this Lane 0 cycle.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `20260609T153419Z.review-proof.md`	`MAQ-019` records scope, write set, proof command, and blocker; no product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L8`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T153419Z.local.manthan.status`; `20260609T153419Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB and commit-the-anchor recommendations are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T153419Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T153419Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T153419Z.review-proof.md`; remediation plan	DB inspection found 20 analysis rows; staged anchor cleanup or commit requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T153419Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T153419Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T153419Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T153419Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T154805Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T154805Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T160021Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T160021Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T160021Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T160021Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T160021Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=23` split `claude=9`, `deepseek=12`, `gemini=2`; execute/evaluation/promotion/evolution tables remain empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T160021Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `29e6f2aa5c0a60b4b19581a66b3f3033e6b2d9482df6100d05502cf12288c006`	`findings`, `cycles`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, `evolution_runs`, and `objectives` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T160021Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T160021Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T160021Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep exit `0`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran, smoke/selection executables are absent, and app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`20260609T160021Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T160021Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T160021Z.root-smoke-executable.out`; `20260609T160021Z.selection-ab-executable.out`; `20260609T160021Z.port-bindings.txt`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; app-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip` evidence.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L5`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T160021Z.action-agent.txt`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; token variables are unset; `gh auth status` exits `1`; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L6`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T160021Z.local.manthan.status`; `20260609T160021Z.package-lock-proof.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	The claim that `.env` is committed and the recommendation to commit the staged anchor plus package lock are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T160021Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T160021Z.env-tracking-proof.txt`; `20260609T160021Z.package-lock-proof.txt`; remediation plan; action-agent proof	`.env` has no tracked output; package lock is untracked; staged anchor cleanup or commit requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z-L8`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T160021Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof is incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T160021Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T160021Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T160021Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T160021Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T161320Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T161320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T161320Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T161320Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=23` split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=4`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T161320Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `d9007aa6970a67ad625503d7811aa611e431eebbd40863eac3d18f8e09630620`	`findings`, `cycles`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, `objectives`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T161320Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T161320Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.review-proof.md`	`git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`20260609T161320Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.root-smoke-executable.out`; `20260609T161320Z.selection-ab-executable.out`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks fail; no service startup or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L5`	deterministic boundary proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T161320Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.compose-port-summary.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.routes.txt`	Postgres/nats use loopback `host_ip`; substrate/runtime/api/maestro-bridge/viewer app ports publish without `host_ip`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T161320Z.action-agent.txt`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; token variables are unset; `gh auth status` exits `1`; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T161320Z.local.manthan.status`; `20260609T161320Z.package-lock-proof.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	The `.env` committed-secret claim, the unbuilt infra image gate, and recommendations to commit the staged anchor plus package lock are rejected or demoted for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T161320Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T161320Z.env-tracking-proof.txt`; `20260609T161320Z.package-lock-proof.txt`; remediation plan	`.env` has no tracked output and is ignored; package lock is untracked hygiene only; committing the anchor widens the current write set and requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z-L9`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T161320Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof is incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T161320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T161320Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T161320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T161320Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T161320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T162826Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T162826Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T162826Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T162826Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=23` split `claude=10`, `deepseek=10`, `gemini=3`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T162826Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `f8ab741d50682b3462f1d6c5132f1b1713d63051c5e2751b2139eaf8fd17a688`	`findings`, `cycles`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, `objectives`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T162826Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T162826Z.optional-anchor-head.out`; `20260609T162826Z.optional-anchor-tracker-grep.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.review-proof.md`	`git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`20260609T162826Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.root-smoke-executable.out`; `20260609T162826Z.selection-ab-executable.out`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; no service startup or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L5`	deterministic boundary proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T162826Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T162826Z.status-claims.txt`	Postgres/nats use loopback `host_ip`; substrate/runtime/api/maestro-bridge/viewer app ports publish without `host_ip`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T162826Z.action-agent.txt`; action queue	Copilot CLI no-edit probe exits `1` with "No authentication information found"; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T162826Z.local.manthan.status`; `20260609T162826Z.package-lock-proof.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	The recommendation to commit the staged anchor plus tracker line is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T162826Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T162826Z.review-proof.md`; action-agent proof	Rejected because the write set and proof do not match the current cleanup lane, the remediation plan prefers committed integration-doc evidence, and Copilot action is unauthenticated.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z-L9`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T162826Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof is incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T162826Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T162826Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T162826Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T162826Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T164322Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T164322Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T164322Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; `analysis_findings=21` split `claude=8`, `deepseek=10`, `gemini=3`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; DB SHA `f43327e023beac2da12e24f1f33576fe7f2dbd41ebdb5a52d498dfcec1c882bc`	`findings`, `cycles`, `mutations`, `evaluations`, `promotions`, and `evolution_runs` are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T164322Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`	`test -f` and self-grep exit `0`; `git cat-file -e HEAD:docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L4`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains because the reviewed packet targets optional-anchor proof while current gates/remediation target committed integration-doc proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T164322Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan; `20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`	Packet proof names `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; gates/remediation name `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`	Integration-doc grep and compose config exit `0`; both executable checks exit `1`; no service startup or endpoint probe ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; action queue	Copilot binary exists; `COPILOT_GITHUB_TOKEN`, `GH_TOKEN`, and `GITHUB_TOKEN` are unset; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; wrapper pre-status file	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	The recommendation to commit the staged optional anchor plus extra gate wording is rejected for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T164322Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; action-agent proof	Rejected because the write set and proof do not match the current cleanup lane, the remediation plan prefers committed integration-doc evidence, and Copilot action is unauthenticated.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z-L9`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof is incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T164322Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T164322Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T164322Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T164322Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T165716Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T165716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T165716Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T165716Z.review-proof.md`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present; substantive findings came from `gemini` and `claude`; `deepseek/error` discarded.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T165716Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `6ccc1bb06f743d01dacff25fbe1e572cade38b35439ce57990d462eba45bc8b0`	`analysis_findings=10`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution tables are empty.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The optional-anchor proof remains false progress because it passes on a staged artifact absent from current Manthan `HEAD` and absent from the target tracker.	`logs/20260609T165716Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T165716Z.optional-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T165716Z.tracker-anchor-proof.txt`	`test -f` and self-grep exit `0`; `git cat-file` exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; `wc -l` reports 8 lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass under v1 `docker-compose`, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`20260609T165716Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T165716Z.compose-config.txt`; `20260609T165716Z.scripts.txt`	Integration-doc grep and v1 compose config exit `0`; v2 compose syntax exits `125`; both executable checks exit `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L5`	deterministic boundary proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T165716Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T165716Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T165716Z.routes.txt`	App-tier ports publish without `host_ip`; route/status proof captured.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L6`	action-agent proof	The scoped target cleanup remains blocked because the configured Copilot product-action lane is not authenticated.	`20260609T165716Z.action-agent.txt`; action queue	`copilot` and `gh` exist; token variables are unset; stored `gh` credentials are invalid; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L7`	target status proof	Manthan clean-tree proof remains dirty because the optional anchor is staged and the conformance package lock is untracked.	`20260609T165716Z.local.manthan.status`; `20260609T165716Z.package-lock-proof.txt`	Status capture shows both paths; no cleanup was authorized.	review-only	local-cycle-only	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	The recommendation to commit the staged optional anchor plus tracker update is not actionable in this cycle.	`logs/20260609T165716Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan; `20260609T165716Z.review-proof.md`; action-agent proof	Not executed because product action requires authenticated Copilot or explicit human authorization.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z-L9`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T165716Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof is incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T165716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T165716Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T165716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T165716Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T165716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T171000Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review is degraded because only Gemini produced usable findings and reviewer synthesis was not detected by the DB audit.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T171000Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T171000Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T171000Z.db-counts.txt`	audit `DEGRADED`; `analysis_findings=6`; `unparsed=2`; no execute/evolution rows	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L2`	local DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis rows only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`20260609T171000Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `e42656f25a03e46b3fdd6dd0ee38d069963cbfd80075c67afb15a7e531c9936d`	`findings=0`, `cycles=0`, `mutations=0`, `evaluations=0`, `promotions=0`, `objectives=0`, `evolution_runs=0`	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L3`	local proof	The optional anchor remains staged-only false-progress evidence.	`20260609T171000Z.manthan-status.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.optional-anchor-head.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.tracker-anchor-proof.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.optional-anchor-wc.txt`	status shows staged anchor; HEAD check exits `128`; tracker grep exits `1`; file is 8 lines	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L4`	local proof	Integration-doc proof and standalone root compose syntax pass, but this is static proof only.	`20260609T171000Z.integration-proof.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.compose.expanded.yml`	integration grep and compose config exit `0`; no endpoint smoke ran	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L5`	local proof	P0 smoke and selection executable gates are absent at target HEAD.	`20260609T171000Z.root-smoke-executable.out`; `20260609T171000Z.selection-ab-executable.out`; `20260609T171000Z.local-proof.md`	both `test -x` checks exit `1`; no `/signal/feed`, `/elites`, lineage, MCP, or bridge smoke ran	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L6`	local route and port proof	The outward boundary remains unresolved because app-tier ports publish without loopback `host_ip` while internal write/admin routes exist.	`20260609T171000Z.port-bindings.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.status-claims.txt`	app-tier ports publish without `host_ip`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L7`	local status proof	Manthan product status and Conduir loop status remain distinct and must not be collapsed.	`20260609T171000Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	target tracker says Phase 5 is done by internal-research definition; Conduir P0 still requires boundary, smoke, selection, and live swarm evidence	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L8`	local architecture proof	NATS/HERALD references are design/status evidence, not live P0 exit proof in this cycle.	`20260609T171000Z.status-claims.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.local-proof.md`	status proof includes NATS/HERALD references and routes, but no stack startup or bridge/HERALD endpoint smoke ran	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L9`	action-agent proof	The configured Copilot product-action lane is blocked in this controller session.	`20260609T171000Z.action-agent-env.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.copilot-path.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.gh-path.txt`; `20260609T171000Z.gh-auth-status.txt`	Copilot and `gh` exist; token variables are unset; stored GitHub CLI credentials are invalid	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z-L10`	reviewer filtering	Recommendations to commit or rely on the staged optional anchor are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`logs/20260609T171000Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T171000Z.local-proof.md`; remediation plan	rejected because full-swarm health is degraded, the artifact is absent from HEAD, and product action is not authorized	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z	P0	Host cycle degraded; local proof is advisory only and no phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T171000Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T171000Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; no Manthan product edit; status delta `conduir_changed`	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T171000Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T171000Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T171000Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T172451Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it reviewed Manthan `8b75d1b` and produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T172451Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T172451Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`	Audit `OK`; host output reports 26 findings from three agents and reviewer synthesis; DB SHA `ed056e5405aef5e1a87cceb2616661d6349b3e0dbdc8e7ec9a673a40fc9f23f5`; final target HEAD is `2408120`, so product action needs fresh review.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; cycle DB	`analysis_findings=26` split `claude=7`, `deepseek=10`, `gemini=9`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L3`	HEAD freshness recheck	The staged/absent-anchor cleanup finding was valid during initial proof but is stale for future action because the anchor is now committed at Manthan `HEAD`.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; final `git log -1`; final `git status`	Initial proof saw staged anchor at `8b75d1b`; final freshness check saw clean `2408120` with `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` in HEAD and no tracker linkage.	review-only	none	SUPERSEDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L4`	controller proof	Host packet/source drift remains because the reviewed packet targets `8b75d1b` optional-anchor proof while current target HEAD is `2408120` and gates/remediation target committed integration-doc proof.	`cycle-packet-20260609T172451Z.md`; phase gates; remediation plan; `20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`	Packet proof names `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` at `8b75d1b`; final target HEAD is `2408120`; gates/remediation name `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-INTEGRATION.md` and root `docker-compose.yml`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L5`	deterministic proof	Integration-doc proof and root compose syntax proof pass, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T172451Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Integration-doc grep and legacy compose config exit `0`; Docker CLI plugin form exits `125`; both script executable checks exit `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L6`	deterministic boundary proof	Read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T172451Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T172451Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T172451Z.status-claims.txt`	App-tier ports publish without `host_ip`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L7`	action-agent and cleanup-policy proof	The staged-anchor deletion cleanup packet is superseded by current HEAD freshness.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; `20260609T144034Z.action-patch-packet.md`; action queue	Copilot CLI and `gh` are present and `gh auth status` exits `0`, but final `HEAD` already contains the anchor; deletion/quarantine must be re-reviewed, not executed from the stale packet.	review-only	none	SUPERSEDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L8`	target status proof	Initial Manthan dirty-tree proof was superseded by final clean target status.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; wrapper pre-status; final `git status --short --untracked-files=all`	Initial status showed staged/untracked paths; final status is clean at `2408120`.	review-only	none	SUPERSEDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	Raw claims that the DB is empty/degraded or that the committed 8-line anchor is sufficient P0 evidence are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`logs/20260609T172451Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; remediation plan; action patch packet	DB inspection found 26 analysis rows and audit `OK`; the committed anchor lacks tracker linkage and was not reviewed at current `HEAD`; target action is blocked pending fresh proof.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z-L10`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, did not review current `HEAD`, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but target HEAD changed to `2408120` after the reviewed packet; action status is `BLOCKED_PROOF`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but target HEAD changed after review, so product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T172451Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T172451Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; reviewed HEAD `8b75d1b`; final HEAD `2408120`; no operator Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T172451Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T172451Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T174852Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for current Manthan `HEAD` `2408120`, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T174852Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `logs/20260609T174852Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T174852Z.review-proof.md`	Audit `OK`; host output reports 24 findings from three agents and reviewer synthesis; no product edit or phase advancement occurred.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`20260609T174852Z.db-counts.txt`; cycle DB	`analysis_findings=24` split `claude=8`, `deepseek=13`, `gemini=3`; loop execution/evaluation/promotion tables are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The committed optional anchor is not acceptable P0 exit evidence.	`logs/20260609T174852Z.swarm.out`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `20260609T174852Z.review-proof.md`	Fresh review at `2408120` found the 8-line anchor is a stub with no gates, no exit-evidence criteria, and no tracker linkage.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L4`	reviewer consensus and deterministic proof	The cycle proof set is decoupled from the P0 exit gate.	`cycle-packet-20260609T174852Z.md`; `20260609T174852Z.scripts.txt`; `20260609T174852Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Static compose config passes and `scripts/` contains only `bootstrap.sh`; no root smoke or selection executable exists, and no endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L5`	deterministic route and compose proof	The read-only outward boundary remains unresolved for root app-tier services.	`20260609T174852Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `20260609T174852Z.routes.txt`; `20260609T174852Z.status-claims.txt`	Compose expansion shows app-tier published ports without loopback `host_ip`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L6`	reviewer consensus and compose proof	A future root smoke must preflight the external host LLM gateway dependency instead of treating static compose syntax as live readiness.	`logs/20260609T174852Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T174852Z.compose.expanded.yml`	Review identified `host.docker.internal:48003`; compose expansion includes `MANTHAN_LLM_GATEWAY_URL`; no live smoke ran this cycle.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	Raw claims that the DB has zero analysis rows, that the stub anchor is sufficient, or that P0 advanced are rejected or scoped down.	`logs/20260609T174852Z.swarm.out`; `20260609T174852Z.db-counts.txt`; `20260609T174852Z.review-proof.md`	DB inspection found 24 analysis rows; the anchor was not accepted; tracker and phase state keep P0 active.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z-L8`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle did not execute a Manthan product edit, did not run endpoint smoke, and did not satisfy all P0 exit gates.	`20260609T174852Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but gate proof remains incomplete and action status is `BLOCKED_PROOF`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T174852Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T174852Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T174852Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T174852Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T181213Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T181213Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T181213Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.db-counts.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=18`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	Gemini did not provide substantive consensus in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T181213Z.swarm.out`	DB rows split `claude=7`, `deepseek=10`, `gemini=1`; Gemini row is error-only, while DeepSeek and Claude plus reviewer synthesis satisfy health.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The committed optional anchor remains false-progress evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T181213Z.swarm.out`	Anchor grep passes, but the file is only 8 lines and contains no P0 exit criteria, write-set rule, or tracker linkage.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Static compose validation does not prove the product-stack smoke gate.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.review-proof.md`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; no image build, service startup, endpoint smoke, MCP probe, bridge probe, or selection A/B check ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L5`	deterministic proof	P0/P1 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.scripts.txt`; phase gates	`find scripts -maxdepth 1 -type f -print` reports only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L6`	HEAD freshness and commit proof	The prior anchor commit leaked beyond its intended named write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.head-commit-files.txt`	`git show --name-status -1 HEAD` shows both `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` and `herald-protocol/tests/conformance/mvp-workflow/package-lock.json` added in commit `2408120`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L7`	compose boundary proof	The root app-tier outward boundary remains unresolved and must stay queued for Lane 1.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.compose-ports.txt`	App-tier published ports appear without loopback `host_ip` evidence in the grep artifact.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L8`	action-agent proof and operator packet	Anchor enrichment has an exact one-file write set, but product action is blocked in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.review-proof.md`	`copilot` and `gh` exist, but `gh auth status` reports invalid stored credentials; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	Claims that config validation proves live smoke, that Gemini added substantive consensus, or that product action was authorized are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T181213Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected because local proof shows static-only validation, an error-only Gemini row, invalid action-agent auth, and no phase-exit gate completion.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T181213Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.action-patch-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T181213Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T181213Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T182655Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T182655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T182655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.db-counts.txt`	Audit `OK`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; `analysis_findings=20`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	Gemini did not provide substantive consensus in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T182655Z.swarm.out`	DB rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=1`; Gemini row is error-only.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The committed optional anchor remains false-progress evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T182655Z.swarm.out`	Anchor grep passes with only four matching lines; the file lacks P0 exit criteria, write-set rule, learning audit linkage, or tracker linkage.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Static compose validation does not prove the product-stack smoke gate.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.review-proof.md`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; no live endpoint smoke ran.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L5`	deterministic proof	P0/P1 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.scripts.txt`; phase gates	`scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; both executable checks exit `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L6`	compose boundary proof	The root app-tier outward boundary remains unresolved and must stay queued for Lane 1.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.routes.txt`	App-tier published ports appear without loopback `host_ip` evidence; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L7`	reviewer consensus and compose proof	Compose service healthchecks still use `/healthz`, so root compose health does not prove service readiness.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T182655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.compose-ports.txt`	Reviewer synthesis flags `/healthz` vs `/readyz`; compose grep records `/healthz` healthcheck lines.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L8`	action-agent proof	Anchor enrichment has an exact one-file write set, but product action is blocked in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T181213Z.action-patch-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.copilot-noedit-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.review-proof.md`	Copilot no-edit probe exits `1` with no authentication information; no Manthan product edit ran.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z-L9`	reviewer filtering	Claims that config validation proves live smoke, that Gemini added substantive consensus, or that product action was authorized are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T182655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.review-proof.md`	Rejected because proof shows static-only validation, an error-only Gemini row, unauthenticated Copilot, and no phase-exit gate completion.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T182655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T182655Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T182655Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T182655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T184320Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review is degraded because only Claude produced usable findings and the DB audit did not detect healthy reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T184320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T184320Z.swarm.out`	Audit `DEGRADED`; host output says `contributing=1/3`; DeepSeek and Gemini rows are error/unparsed.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L2`	local DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis rows only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.db-counts.txt`	`analysis_findings=10`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution tables are all `0`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L3`	local anchor proof	The committed optional anchor exists at Manthan `HEAD` `2408120`, but it remains a thin metadata stub.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.anchor-lines.txt`	Anchor grep passes, but `wc -l` reports 8 lines and no exit criteria, write-set rule, tracker linkage, or learning audit linkage is proven.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L4`	local compose/script proof	Static root compose validation passes, but the P0 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.local-proof.md`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; both executable checks exit `1`; no endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L5`	local route and compose proof	The outward boundary and readiness posture remain unresolved for root app-tier services.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.status-claims.txt`	App-tier published ports appear without loopback `host_ip`; compose healthchecks use `/healthz`; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L6`	HEAD freshness and write-set proof	The current Manthan head still carries prior write-set hygiene risk from commit `2408120`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.head-commit-files.txt`	`git show --name-status -1 HEAD` shows both the anchor and a conformance package-lock added in the same commit.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L7`	local finalizer	P0 remains active because this cycle was degraded and did not satisfy the P0 exit gate.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.local-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	No Manthan product edit, no live endpoint smoke, no healthy full-swarm review, and no phase advancement occurred.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Recommendations from this degraded review to harden or advance the anchor are rejected as action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T184320Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.local-proof.md`; remediation plan	Rejected because usable review output came from one agent only; degraded review cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, or phase advancement.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z	P0	Host cycle degraded; local proof is advisory only and no phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T184320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T184320Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T184320Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T184320Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T184320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T185501Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T185501Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T191344Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T191344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T191344Z.swarm.out`	Audit `OK`; 26 findings from `deepseek`, `gemini`, and `claude`; reviewer synthesis present.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L2`	DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `550ce3d72777d88c2e2b703dafbdaec7b56b676873ab5c4519856a555a856474`	`analysis_findings=26` split `claude=8`, `deepseek=12`, `gemini=6`; execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The Lane 0 proof remains false progress because it validates an already-committed anchor at Manthan HEAD `2408120`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T191344Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.anchor.txt`	Anchor grep passes, but the file is 8 lines and the proof passes before any product action.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L4`	deterministic proof	Static compose validation passes, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection executable gates are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.scripts.txt`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; both script executable checks exit `1`; `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L5`	compose boundary and readiness proof	The root app-tier outward boundary and readiness posture remain unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.routes.txt`	App-tier published ports lack `host_ip`; compose healthchecks use `/healthz`; route proof includes `/readyz` handlers and write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L6`	reviewer filtering	Raw zero-DB/output, wrong-status-path, all-ports-exposed, and close-P0-now claims are rejected or scoped down against live evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.review-proof.md`	DB has 26 analysis rows; empty Manthan status is clean-tree evidence; Postgres/NATS are loopback-bound; P0 gates remain incomplete.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z-L7`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because no product edit, endpoint smoke, or complete P0 gate proof occurred.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but product action and phase advancement are `BLOCKED_PROOF`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T191344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T191344Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T191344Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T191344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T193029Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T193029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T194755Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T194755Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T194755Z.swarm.out`	audit `OK`; host status `0`; reviewer synthesis present in host output; DB SHA `cbd482f8c095ac93d526f279891518817ae01199809d269bb3e9b4c757f1c412`	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`; cycle DB	`analysis_findings=23`; agent rows `claude=9`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=3`; execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The selected Lane 0 proof is false progress because it passes before any product action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T194755Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`	reviewer consensus C1; anchor grep and compose config pass against already-existing files	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L4`	reviewer consensus and phase-gate proof	The P0 DB-audit requirement is not represented by a concrete command in the selected proof set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T194755Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`	reviewer consensus C1; local DB-audit assertion passed for this cycle, but the selected packet proof did not include it	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L5`	deterministic anchor and tracker proof	The committed optional anchor is not P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`; Manthan `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; Manthan `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md`	anchor is 8 lines and keyword grep passes; tracker grep has no anchor/Conduir-loop output	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L6`	deterministic compose and script proof	Static compose validation passes, but no live endpoint smoke ran and smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; `scripts/` contains only `bootstrap.sh`; both executable checks exit `1`	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L7`	HEAD freshness and write-set proof	The current Manthan head still carries prior write-set hygiene risk from commit `2408120`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`; `git show --name-status --oneline -1 HEAD`	commit added both the optional anchor and an unrelated conformance package-lock file	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z-L8`	reviewer filtering	Raw claims that the DB was empty or that control-repo DB/gate files were live Manthan evidence are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T194755Z.swarm.out`; DB inspection in `20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`	DB has 23 analysis rows; control-repo artifacts are valid controller evidence, not target-repo evidence	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T194755Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T194755Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T194755Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T194755Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T194755Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `124`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T201108Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T201108Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T203154Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was healthy for this cycle, but it produced review coverage only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T203154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T203154Z.swarm.out`	Audit `OK`; host status `0`; reviewer synthesis present; DB SHA `1bca0e7088bdc3ab9d6da155904197858c98df6d938a30e9af7f00e9d6c880c5`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L2`	direct DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis findings only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`	`analysis_findings=21`; execute/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution rows are all `0`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L3`	reviewer consensus and HEAD proof	The selected Lane 0 anchor proof is false progress because it validates an already-committed 8-line metadata stub.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T203154Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.tracker-anchor-proof.txt`	Anchor grep passes, `wc -l` reports 8 lines, and target tracker grep exits `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L4`	deterministic compose and integration proof	Integration-doc evidence and static compose syntax pass, but no live root-stack smoke ran and smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.scripts.txt`	Integration-doc proof and compose config pass; both smoke/selection executable checks exit `1`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L5`	compose boundary and route proof	Root app-tier outward boundary remains unresolved and should be reviewed as Lane 1, not actioned from this Lane 0 packet.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.routes.txt`	App-tier published ports lack `host_ip`; NATS/Postgres are loopback-bound; route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L6`	HEAD freshness and write-set proof	The current Manthan head still carries prior write-set hygiene risk from commit `2408120`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.head-commit-files.txt`	Commit `2408120` added both the optional anchor and an unrelated conformance package-lock file.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L7`	reviewer filtering and direct proof	Raw DB-empty and immediate-boundary-action claims are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T203154Z.swarm.out`; remediation plan Lane 1 contract	DB has 21 analysis rows; the boundary issue is real but not authorization for a product edit in this Lane 0 packet.	rejected	none	REJECTED
`manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z-L8`	controller finalizer	P0 remains active because no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, script gate, or boundary-posture proof completed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.review-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	Full-swarm health was `OK`, but product action and phase advancement are `BLOCKED_PROOF`.	guarded	accepted	PROMOTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T203154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T203154Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T203154Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T203154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T204802Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T204802Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - 20260609T205651Z

Learning ID	Source	Claim	Evidence	Validation	Safety	Promotion	Status
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L1`	wrapper DB audit and host output	Full-swarm review was degraded because only one requested agent produced substantive findings.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T205651Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T205651Z.swarm.out`	Audit `DEGRADED`; host output reports one substantive contributor (`gemini`) and unparsed/error-only `claude` and `deepseek`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L2`	local DB inspection	This cycle produced analysis rows only, not execution, evaluation, promotion, objective, or evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `4defa3aee500d73005602b9041c2c99cdf0850cbc67d479c969ab8b470bbcf8f`	`analysis_findings=13`; rows split `claude=1`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=11`; findings/cycles/mutations/evaluations/promotions/objectives/evolution rows are all `0`.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L3`	local compose and script proof	Static root compose validation passes, but P0 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.local-proof.md`	`docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` exits `0`; `scripts/` contains only `scripts/bootstrap.sh`; both executable checks exit `1`; no endpoint smoke ran.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L4`	local route and compose proof	The root app-tier outward boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.routes.txt`	App-tier published ports lack loopback `host_ip`, while NATS/Postgres show `local-service`; routes include write/admin surfaces.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L5`	local anchor and integration proof	The optional anchor exists but remains non-exit evidence in this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.anchor-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.integration-proof.txt`	Anchor line count is `8`; integration-doc proof passes; degraded review cannot authorize anchor promotion.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L6`	local finalizer	P0 remains active because the cycle was degraded and did not satisfy P0 exit gates.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.local-proof.md`; tracker entry; phase state	No Manthan product edit, no Copilot product action, no live endpoint smoke, no healthy full-swarm review, and no phase advancement occurred.	review-only	phase-candidate	RECORDED
`manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z-L7`	reviewer filtering	Recommendations from the degraded review are rejected as action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T205651Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T205651Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; local proof	Rejected because usable review output came from one substantive agent only; degraded review cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, or phase advancement.	rejected	none	REJECTED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z	P0	Host cycle degraded; local proof is advisory only and no phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T205651Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T205651Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	review-only	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T205651Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T205651Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T205651Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T210716Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T210716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T212502Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T212502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z - P0 - 2026-06-09T21:33:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review findings only: wrapper DB audit `OK`, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T213346Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T213346Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The Lane 0 anchor/static proof is rejected as P0 exit evidence and cannot authorize product edits.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T213346Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T213346Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Compose environment-merge defect for `api`/`maestro-bridge` needs deterministic expanded-compose replay before action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T213346Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z-L5	none	REJECTED	The critical framing of untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` was rejected/downgraded by the reviewer; it is not a product-action blocker from this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T213346Z.swarm.out`
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T213346Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T213346Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T215100Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T215100Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T221254Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T221254Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T223715Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T223715Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T223715Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z - P0 - 2026-06-09T22:55:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review findings only: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 30 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T225538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T225538Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `c6eb7f26a09e5713471a11b91928e88619ee43cf31a9ee9edacdfb342b914d36`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress because it passes against an already committed 8-line anchor.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T225538Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose and integration-doc proof pass, but live root smoke did not run and smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current: `api` and `maestro-bridge` miss inherited budget, dormancy, and LLM-gateway env defaults in expanded compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.compose-key-lines.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier outward boundary remains unresolved because app service published ports lack loopback `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` creates P0-vs-OS-O0 naming drift evidence but is not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.anchor-direction-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Claims that the current DB is empty/degraded or that this Lane 0 packet authorized immediate product action are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T225538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T225538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T225538Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T225538Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T225538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z - P0 - 2026-06-09T23:23:20Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review findings only: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 22 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T232320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T232320Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The Lane 0 proof remains false progress because it validates an existing anchor and static compose syntax, not live product behavior.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260609T232320Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` draft conflicts with the committed anchor's `Conduir loop P0` wording and proposes OS-O0 naming.	Manthan `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; Manthan `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; host reviewer C2/C9
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan tracker linkage is absent for anchor/product-stack/P0 loop terms.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.tracker-linkage-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current, but was not executed because this healthy review re-scoped the next safe action back to Lane 0 governance.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.compose-key-lines.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and separate from the Lane 0 governance packet.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, or trusted live-stack proof from this cycle is rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T232320Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T232320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T232320Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; only target dirty item is untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T232320Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T232320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z - P0 - 2026-06-09T23:42:15Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review findings only: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 32 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T234215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T234215Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress because it validates an existing 8-line anchor and static compose syntax only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.anchor-lines.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The reviewer-proposed direction/anchor/tracker product write set is broader than the current remediation-plan Lane 0 expected write set.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current and now covers one YAML merge root cause: missing env defaults on `api`/`maestro-bridge` and missing `api` `nats` dependency.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The committed anchor remains unlinked from `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.tracker-linkage-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.script-gates.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and separate from this Lane 0 governance packet.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, and `docker-compose up` smoke from this Lane 0 packet are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260609T234215Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T234215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260609T234215Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; only target dirty item is untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-09	manthan-phase-20260609T234215Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T234215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260609T235711Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260609T235711Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T001121Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T001121Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T002819Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T002819Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T003906Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T003906Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T00:49:52Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 13 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T004952Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T004952Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `1f3cbcc2a2e8b12f70496235b5e3128576b199000e6e24961888a55852c91447`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed anchor's `Conduir loop P0` wording, but the draft is not committed authority and requires a dedicated adoption/scope decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.direction-anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.direction-ls-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The committed anchor remains non-exit evidence because it is an 8-line self-referential anchor with zero tracker linkage for anchor/P0/OS-O0 terms.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.anchor-direction-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.tracker-linkage-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passes, but live root smoke and selection A/B gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because no callable Copilot action lane exists in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.review-proof.md`; tool discovery result
manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Treating the untracked direction draft as immediately adopted authority, or gitignoring it, is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T004952Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.direction-anchor-proof.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T004952Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T004952Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T004952Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T004952Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T010226Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T010226Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T011502Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T011502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T01:26:54Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 29 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T012654Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T012654Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.db-counts.txt`; DB SHA `664383ecf3de7e373e99ece54d66fdacc5c70a1bbce4725381bcc40f650b3e29`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof is false progress because it passes against existing files and static YAML only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T012654Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with committed anchor wording and needs a dedicated `MAQ-023` adoption/defer packet before it can influence target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current: `api.depends_on` omits `nats`, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` lack base budget/gateway `MANTHAN_*` keys in expanded service environments.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, and the raw DB-empty claim are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.db-counts.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T012654Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T012654Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T012654Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T012654Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T01:40:34Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 23 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T014034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T014034Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`; DB SHA `9a2c15666e5d5ec9697600055351b6728c4e7f1158511cf0c5177f74f5149b48`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose objective is already complete and is false progress for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T014034Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-023` remains live governance drift but not committed target authority: untracked direction draft uses `OS-O0`, committed anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, and tracker linkage count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.tracker-linkage-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-023` was explicitly deferred as product authority for this cycle, enabling the next cycle to return to `MAQ-001` if the Copilot lane is callable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.maq-023-deferral-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-review-20260610t014034z---p0`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current: `api.depends_on` omits `nats`, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` lack base budget/gateway `MANTHAN_*` keys in expanded service environments.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, DB-missing claims, and untracked-file criticality are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.db-file-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.action-agent-tool-discovery.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; controller-only `MAQ-023` deferral executed, while product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T014034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T014034Z.maq-023-deferral-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `EXECUTED` for controller finalization, `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT` for Manthan product files; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T014034Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T014034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T01:55:13Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 23 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T015513Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T015513Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`; DB SHA `7deda1e87aaf99a00ce6ab399a8b87dd4eb3bb457f343762fb629ea598ab3adf`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose objective is already complete and is false progress for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T015513Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`MAQ-022` remains current: `api.depends_on` omits `nats`, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` lack base budget/gateway `MANTHAN_*` keys in expanded service environments.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md#maq-022`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft is not target authority; its `OS-O0` naming is deliberate, but it overclaims loopback bindings that live compose does not implement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T015513Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.manthan.status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because no callable Copilot action lane exists in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.action-agent-tool-discovery.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, DB-empty/output-empty claims, untracked-file criticality, and missing-script-as-surprise-defect claims are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T015513Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.script-gates.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T015513Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T015513Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T015513Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T015513Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T015513Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T020719Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T020719Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T022318Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T022318Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T023717Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T023717Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T023717Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T024945Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T024945Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T03:02:22Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 10 rows, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T030222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T030222Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose objective is false progress because it revalidates an already-passing eight-line anchor and static YAML.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T030222Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft remains scope/adoption drift and cannot authorize product edits until committed/adopted or explicitly excluded.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passes, but live root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.script-gates.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 remains active because no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, executable gate proof, or phase advancement occurred.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, and replacing root `docker-compose.yml` with `infra/compose` as the product-stack target are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T030222Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T030222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T030222Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T030222Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T030222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T03:13:26Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 24 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T031326Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T031326Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose objective is false progress because it revalidates an already-passing eight-line anchor and static YAML.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T031326Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passes, but live root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.script-gates.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary and `MAQ-022` env/dependency guardrails remain unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.compose-service-verdicts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft is not target authority; `OS-O0` naming is not itself a live conflict, but the loopback claim and staging risk remain scoped drift.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.direction-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T031326Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Copilot CLI is installed, but product action was not authorized and GitHub auth was not valid in the final probe.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.copilot-version.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.gh-auth-status.exit.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, and combined smoke-plus-selection execution are rejected or scoped down for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T031326Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T031326Z.review-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T031326Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T031326Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T032644Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T032644Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T034001Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T034001Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T03:54:07Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 10 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T035407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T035407Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` is live working-tree evidence but remains untracked draft, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	If the direction draft is adopted, the committed anchor conflicts with it because the draft uses `OS-O0` and the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T035407Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T035407Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	The anchor commit was not single-purpose because it also added a test workflow package lockfile.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.head-show.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the Copilot action-agent contract is not satisfied: Copilot CLI exists, but GitHub auth fails with invalid tokens.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.copilot-help.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, treating the direction draft as already adopted authority, and claiming boundary proof from static compose are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T035407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T035407Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T035407Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T035407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T04:09:57Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 9 rows, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, one unparsed DeepSeek row, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T040957Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T040957Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress because it revalidates already-existing files and static YAML.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T040957Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Lane 0 target-selection semantics remain ambiguous between the anchor's root product-stack proof target and `CLAUDE.md`'s `infra/compose/` internal default.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T040957Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L6	none	REJECTED	The claim that the proof would fail because only legacy `docker-compose` v1 exists was rejected: hyphenated `docker-compose` is v2.39.4 and the proof passes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T040957Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Copilot/GitHub auth is not the active blocker in this cycle, but product action still did not run because proof and scope are blocked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.copilot-help.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, clearing or adopting the untracked draft, and claiming boundary proof from static compose are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T040957Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by proof/scope, not by current `gh auth status`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T040957Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T040957Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T040957Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T040957Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T040957Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T04:23:07Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 23 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T042307Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T042307Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L3	none	REJECTED	Wrong-working-directory critical findings about missing anchor and missing compose files are rejected because both proofs pass from Manthan root.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T042307Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	If the direction draft is adopted, the committed anchor conflicts with it; the combined adoption/anchor/tracker write set was not authorized this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T042307Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T042307Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the Copilot CLI exposes no callable product-edit command in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.copilot-help.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, DB-empty claims, and claiming boundary proof from static compose are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T042307Z.swarm.out`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by scope and action-agent availability.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T042307Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T042307Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T042307Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T042307Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T042307Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T042307Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T04:36:00Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 24 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T043600Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T043600Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	If the direction draft is adopted, the committed anchor conflicts with it because the draft uses `OS-O0` while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`; the adoption/relabel write set was not authorized this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T043600Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T043600Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	`CLAUDE.md:60` gate-path drift is real but low-risk and already cataloged as known drift by the direction draft.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T043600Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub auth fails and `gh copilot` exposes no callable product-edit lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.copilot-help.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, phase advancement, treating the untracked direction draft as adopted authority, and claiming smoke/boundary proof from static compose are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T043600Z.swarm.out`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by scope and action-agent availability.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T043600Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T043600Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T043600Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T043600Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T043600Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T043600Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T04:49:11Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 25 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T044911Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T044911Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L3	none	REJECTED	The analyst claim that this cycle DB had zero `analysis_findings` was rejected by direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T044911Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T044911Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence; if adopted, it conflicts with the committed anchor because it uses `OS-O0` while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	`CLAUDE.md:60` gate-path drift and old API-path tracker drift are real but low-risk cleanup items.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.doc-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub auth fails and `gh copilot` exposes no callable product-edit lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.copilot-help.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, phase advancement, treating the untracked direction draft as adopted authority, and claiming smoke/boundary proof from static compose are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by scope and action-agent availability.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T044911Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T044911Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T044911Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T044911Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T044911Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T050154Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T050154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T051700Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T051700Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T05:31:19Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 17 rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T053119Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T053119Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T053119Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.compose-service-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is not available in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority; its loopback-binding claim conflicts with current compose if adopted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	`CLAUDE.md:60` gate-path drift and old API-path tracker drift are real but low-risk cleanup items.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.doc-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L9	none	REJECTED	DB-empty, relative-path, and OS-O0-naming-as-drift claims are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T053119Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, phase advancement, and combined boundary-plus-smoke execution are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot authentication.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T053119Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T053119Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T053119Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T053119Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T05:44:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 17 rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T054455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T054455Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T054455Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.compose-service-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because Copilot is not authenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority; its loopback-binding claim conflicts with current compose if adopted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.direction-ls-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	The reviewer-suggested boundary-plus-direction action is wider than one remediation lane; the bounded product packet remains `MAQ-001` with exact write set `docker-compose.yml`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T054455Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Low-risk `CLAUDE.md` gate-path drift and old API path tracker drift remain current.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.doc-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Gemini's `config -q` boundary-action claim, immediate product action, phase advancement, and combined boundary-plus-direction execution are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T054455Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot authentication and combined-scope rejection.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T054455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T054455Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT` and `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T054455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T054455Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T054455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T06:00:10Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 31 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T060010Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T060010Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T060010Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The prior anchor commit was not a clean one-file write set because it also added a package lock.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.manthan-head-show.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority; if adopted, it conflicts with the committed anchor because it uses `OS-O0` while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.direction-ls-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.compose-service-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is not available in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Phase advancement is explicitly blocked in controller state until P0 gates pass; `allowed_next_phase` was cleared to avoid implying authorization for P1.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z-L10	none	REJECTED	DB-empty, missing-anchor-from-control-repo-as-phase-proof, immediate product action, phase advancement, and treating the untracked direction draft as adopted authority are rejected or scoped down.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T060010Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked, and controller state cleared `allowed_next_phase`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T060010Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T060010Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T060010Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T060010Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T061434Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T061434Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T06:31:14Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 13 rows, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T063114Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T063114Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T063114Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The target-side anchor lacks explicit P0 exit gates, pass/fail criteria, and a tracker link.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.anchor-gate-link.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`infra/compose` terminology is convention-drifted between the anchor, `CLAUDE.md`, and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.doc-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.direction-ls-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.compose-service-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is not available in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, phase advancement, static-compose-as-smoke, and combined anchor/boundary/smoke/selection execution are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T063114Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by proof, scope, and Copilot authentication.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T063114Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T063114Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T063114Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T063114Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T06:47:16Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded to one substantive agent and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, phase advancement, or consensus claims.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T064716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T064716Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T064716Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.tracked-docs.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.scripts-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L7	local-cycle-only	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this controller session because the latest persisted GitHub/Copilot probes fail authentication.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer recommendations to commit the direction draft, rewrite the anchor to `OS-O0`, execute product edits, or advance phase are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T064716Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T064716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T064716Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T064716Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T064716Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T064716Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T06:59:47Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 18 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T065947Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T065947Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T065947Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The target-side anchor lacks explicit P0 exit gates, pass/fail criteria, and a tracker link.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.anchor-gate-link.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` remains untracked draft evidence, not committed target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.direction-ls-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.compose-service-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Low-risk `CLAUDE.md` gate-path drift and old API path tracker drift remain current.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.doc-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub auth passes but the configured Copilot action lane is quota-blocked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, static-compose-as-smoke, and combined Lane 0/boundary/smoke/selection execution are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T065947Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by proof, scope, and Copilot quota.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T065947Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T065947Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T065947Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T065947Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T07:13:42Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 11 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T071342Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T071342Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.db-counts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.db-findings-by-agent.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft's app-tier loopback-boundary claim is false against current root compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.compose-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`maestro-bridge` remains an outward path exposed on all host interfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.compose-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Static `docker-compose config -q` is only a precheck and cannot satisfy P0 smoke or boundary proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T071342Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The committed anchor and untracked direction draft are authority-inverted and phase-name inconsistent if the draft is adopted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.direction-ls-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.script-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is not available in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The target-selection ambiguity claim is downgraded because the anchor already names root `docker-compose.yml` as proof target and `infra/compose` as supporting evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T071342Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.anchor.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate product action, phase advancement, static-compose-as-smoke, and treating the untracked direction draft as adopted authority are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by unauthenticated action agent.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T071342Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T071342Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T071342Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T071342Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T07:28:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded to one usable voice and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T072823Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T072823Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Current Manthan HEAD remains `2408120` with untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; only the short anchor is tracked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.manthan-head.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.manthan-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.tracked-docs.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier ports remain host-exposed without loopback binding while route proof includes write/admin surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.scripts-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Passing static compose config remains only structural validation, not live root-stack smoke or endpoint proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The untracked direction draft's loopback-boundary claim is false against current root compose, and its OS-O0 naming remains an adoption-only conflict.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.tracked-docs.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer recommendations to rewrite/adopt direction wording, execute product edits, or advance phase are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T072823Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T072823Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T072823Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T072823Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T072823Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T072823Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T072823Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T074131Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T074131Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T074131Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T07:51:57Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded with no substantive agents and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T075157Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T075157Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains only three unparsed analysis rows and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.db-sha256.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Current Manthan HEAD remains `2408120` with untracked `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; only the short loop anchor is tracked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.manthan-head.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.tracked-docs.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier ports remain host-exposed without loopback binding while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Passing static compose config remains only structural validation, not live root-stack smoke or endpoint proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The untracked direction draft's loopback-boundary claim is false against current root compose, and its `OS-O0` naming remains an adoption-only conflict.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.tracked-docs.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer recommendations to rewrite/adopt direction wording, execute product edits, or advance phase are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T075157Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T075157Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T075157Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T075157Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T075157Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T075157Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T075157Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T08:06:10Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 21 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T080610Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T080610Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `bdd88494cb873e4686fa1a2051177902bbed3aae0bc83e75af04400b0eac3cbe`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.anchor-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.boundary-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary risk is route-significant because app-tier proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.script-gates.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.action-agent.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The untracked direction draft's loopback-boundary claim is false against current root compose, but adoption remains a separate scope decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.boundary-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, queue validation, endpoint smoke, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T080610Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T080610Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T080610Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T080610Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T082228Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T082228Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T082228Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T08:32:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 25 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T083246Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T083246Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `5dec576b81b5e58fcc628fc5407d6ac7f112ea957a3ff4f128d6412030bbfca6`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T083246Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The target tracker lacks current Conduir-loop `P0` / `OS-O0` / exit-evidence linkage.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Passing static compose config remains structural validation, not live root-stack smoke or boundary proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.cmd-results.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.cmd-results.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in the immediate proof and replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.cmd-results.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.gh-auth-recheck.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The agent claim that this cycle had zero-byte output, no status file, and empty DB is rejected against host-visible artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T083246Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T083246Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T083246Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T083246Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T083246Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T083246Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T084555Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T084555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T08:57:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 25 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T085738Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T085738Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `cf7e898e179bbd941d8ebbb1521bb8b3446a679c6febd67c363a1e76192ed806`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T085738Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The target tracker lacks current Conduir-loop `P0` / `OS-O0` / exit-evidence linkage.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.target-tracker-phase.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed anchor if adopted, but remains separate non-authoritative `MAQ-023` drift for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.tracked-docs.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and no CBOR vector files exist at current HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.script-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.action-agent.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, direction-draft adoption, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; exact `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T085738Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T085738Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T085738Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T085738Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T09:11:37Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 28 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T091137Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T091137Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `5055394376787bb6146533d2474087305b40f917a756573003211c9ff5711dc6`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T091137Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed `Conduir loop P0` anchor if adopted, so `MAQ-023` remains a separate adoption-or-deferral decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.cmd-results.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.maq-023-decision-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; static compose config is not live endpoint proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.cmd-results.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.action-agent.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.maq-023-decision-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The claim that the untracked direction draft itself invalidates read-only proof is rejected; the verified issue is its content if later adopted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T091137Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.maq-023-decision-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; exact `MAQ-023` decision packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T091137Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T091137Z.maq-023-decision-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T091137Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T091137Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T09:24:09Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 13 rows, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T092409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T092409Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `2ed1aeeeffb308340d91cbde6db123d729642cf17f28769c30e1c00cc30c8709`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T092409Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed `Conduir loop P0` anchor if adopted, so `MAQ-023` remains a separate adoption-or-deferral decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; static compose config is not live endpoint proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.action-agent.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Passing anchor existence, anchor grep, and static compose proof is rejected as real P0 progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T092409Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, combined smoke-plus-selection execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; exact `MAQ-002` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T092409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T092409Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T092409Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T092409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T09:38:16Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 22 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T093816Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T093816Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d66ca5de2100856a4b82df910389a0afca5a6830df7a7293997cacbc7d5a76f5`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T093816Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.cmd-results.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this cycle because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.action-agent.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.action-agent-env.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Combined smoke-plus-selection product execution is rejected because it spans more than one remediation lane.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Agent claims that this cycle had empty output or an empty DB are rejected against host-visible controller artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T093816Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T093816Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.db-inspection.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T093816Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T093816Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T093816Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T093816Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T09:51:41Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 32 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T095141Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T095141Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `345bf910a2017027c82a4506c175379a20e434e30c57cb31cd2885f642d5235e`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.cmd-results.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The untracked direction draft conflicts with the committed anchor if adopted, but remains an uncommitted draft and not adopted target authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.tracked-docs.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, target tracker linkage is absent, and no live endpoint proof ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.target-tracker-phase.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this cycle because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The agent claim that this cycle had `analysis_findings=0` is rejected against direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T095141Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Treating the untracked direction draft as already adopted authority or as authorization for immediate anchor rewrite/product action is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T095141Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T095141Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `2408120`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T095141Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T095141Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T100548Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T100548Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `manthan_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T10:18:08Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded to one substantive agent and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, queue validation, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T101808Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T101808Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains five analysis rows, no structured progress rows, and only low/unparsed findings split `claude=1`, `deepseek=1`, `gemini=3`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `a1f3cf055c418e5286a7901413423aa26e9bbdb788bae03ea332225b0e45410e`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan HEAD is clean at `a3e1e89`; the now-tracked direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted/controller-only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.manthan-head.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.direction-anchor.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.write-routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, target tracker linkage grep fails, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.target-tracker-linkage.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, consensus wording, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T101808Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Degraded shared-log recommendations to edit target product files, harden audit policy, or fix direction-doc text are advisory only and require later healthy review or explicit approval.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T101808Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T101808Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T101808Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T101808Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T101808Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T101808Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T101808Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T10:32:09Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 21 rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T103209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T103209Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `74af76011e62460e0b82dd2454675ccbbed018cdf4e105436d348b3716566c82`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T103209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.compose-config-q.status`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; target tracker linkage fails; `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.target-tracker-linkage.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.cbor-files.count`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this cycle because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.action-agent-env.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Combined smoke-plus-selection product execution is rejected because it spans more than one remediation lane and was not the exact selected Lane 0 write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T103209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The critical claim that the cycle DB had no analysis findings is rejected against direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T103209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracked direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted, and known low-risk doc path drift remains.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.tracked-docs.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.doc-drift.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T103209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T103209Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T103209Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T103209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T10:47:19Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, queue validation, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T104719Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 10 analysis rows, no structured progress rows, and rows split `deepseek=1`, `gemini=1`, `claude=8`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `40b15a992fa499c0a105ac22719400e16c410b1b1c0dde43cd48654ff6e4dada`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan HEAD is clean at `a3e1e89`; the tracked direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming while the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.manthan.head.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.manthan.status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.direction-anchor.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable; target tracker linkage is absent; `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.phase-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, consensus wording, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer suggestions to rewrite the anchor or perform direction-doc cleanup are advisory only and cannot be promoted to product action in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T104719Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.direction-anchor.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T104719Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`/`BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T104719Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T104719Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T104719Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T105945Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T105945Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T11:13:15Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 21 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T111315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T111315Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `0b6bab28a6c357b0c8202f124de36b50d15bbd8af996c21434585354c4724d19`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracked direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted and uses `OS-O0`, while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0` and target tracker linkage is absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.target-tracker-phase-linkage.status`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, target tracker linkage fails, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.cbor-files.count`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this cycle because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Combining anchor/tracker linkage with direction-doc cleanup, boundary binding, smoke-script creation, or selection-script creation is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T111315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T111315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T111315Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T111315Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T111315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T11:25:34Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 34 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T112534Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T112534Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `0e3ca48b5e01e709af1e3fc168e2af186d1f3d3a7753dc6693663080a0cc5c2b`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracked direction doc uses `OS-O0`, while the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.manthan-head.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L5	none	REJECTED	The prior claim that missing external-loop terms in `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` is itself a product defect is rejected by reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T112534Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.target-tracker-phase-linkage.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.maq-024-scope-correction-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.cbor-files.count`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked in this cycle because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.maq-024-scope-correction-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Combining anchor naming cleanup with tracker status edits, direction-doc cleanup, boundary binding, smoke-script creation, or selection-script creation is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T112534Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.maq-024-scope-correction-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` was narrowed to anchor naming/proof hygiene and the old tracker-linkage packet was scope-blocked, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T112534Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T112534Z.maq-024-scope-correction-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`/`BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T112534Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T112534Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T112534Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T11:39:39Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 27 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T113939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T113939Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d504fcc7070cb9060cf551cb00580c8024afbd3769d617b0b18a274d65b20a0f`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.compose-source-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.cbor-files.count`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracked direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted and uses `OS-O0`, while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.manthan-head.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The claim that GitHub auth now passes is rejected, and the placeholder claim that wrapper health is pending is superseded by the finalized DB audit.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T113939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed `MAQ-001` boundary packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T113939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T113939Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T113939Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T113939Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T113939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T11:53:33Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review degraded and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T115333Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T115333Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains eight analysis rows, no structured progress rows, and rows split `gemini=6`, `claude=1`, `deepseek=1`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `ba3d9aa0ace2fb115b0efa30816c240d08f5f8fce1ff6b8ef2daef9e1c6eb02b`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan HEAD is clean at `a3e1e89`; root compose config validates, but static compose proof is not P0 endpoint-smoke progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent or non-executable, and `.cbor` vectors are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracked direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted and uses `OS-O0`, while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, consensus wording, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T115333Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Treating Gemini-only low findings or `docker-compose config -q` as swarm consensus or product progress is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T115333Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded the cycle; local proof stayed advisory and product action/phase advancement remained blocked.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T115333Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T115333Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T115333Z-learning-audit.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T115333Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T115333Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T115333Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T12:05:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 15 rows, substantive `claude` and `gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T120555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T120555Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T120555Z.swarm.db`; DB SHA `ff8743c6fa5b58c0e87faf546e5d0de3f2f2892e855010725d9662fdaf40264c`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T120555Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Current source still proves the compose-target clarification gap: the anchor names root `docker-compose.yml`, while `CLAUDE.md` and the target tracker keep `infra/compose/` as official/default internal compose evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan files
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Copilot authenticated for no-op use, but the actual `MAQ-024` product-doc edit was denied by its permission gate and made no changes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product files remained unchanged and P0 did not advance.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`; post-action status/diff proof
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Treating anchor existence, anchor grep, or `docker-compose config -q` as product-stack readiness or phase-exit evidence is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T120555Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Substituting Codex manual edits for the blocked Copilot product-doc edit is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but `MAQ-024` product action was blocked by the Copilot permission gate; no Manthan product file changed and no phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T120555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T120555Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T120555Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T120555Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T120555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T12:23:17Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 20 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T122317Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T122317Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `471c221cc2a895e3ca145067fdbeaafdbf66037f69890ac164694f9c519ca2bc`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Reviewer synthesis rejected the root-compose-vs-infra-compose conflict framing; they are separate compose tracks, not competing app-stack authorities.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T122317Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T122317Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` file count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Agent claims that the current cycle DB had zero findings or that `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` is uncommitted are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T122317Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.manthan-head.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action or manual Codex substitution for Copilot is rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z-L10	none	REJECTED	P0 phase advancement is rejected because endpoint smoke, product patch validation, queue validation, root smoke, and selection A/B gates did not pass.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T122317Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T122317Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T122317Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T122317Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T122317Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T12:36:19Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 21 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T123619Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T123619Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `2329d1ece952b3a2057ddc24c83b9fec717be1805dd659a012a812dc2ad679b8`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T123619Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant, including the runtime admin write route while the runtime port is outward-bound.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.auth-boundary.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.root-smoke-exec.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.selection-ab-exec.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.cbor-files.count`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The stale direction status label and OS-O0/P0 naming drift remain real but outside the selected write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The agent claim that the current cycle DB has zero analysis findings is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The reviewer claim that `gh auth status` and `copilot -p` pass is rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.gh-auth-status.code`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.copilot-noop-probe.code`
manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, combined multi-lane edits, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed exact `MAQ-001` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T123619Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T123619Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T123619Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T123619Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T123619Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T12:48:29Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 23 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T124829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T124829Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains analysis rows only and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `c024f6d76b01d44d7e8cd431bc344016ff58b184c078b2f61cf44e2f5ee92820`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T124829Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Current HEAD proves a Lane 0 naming-discipline conflict: the anchor uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires target-facing `OS-O0` naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.status-claims.txt`; current Manthan files
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.status-claims.txt`; current Manthan HEAD proof
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Target-repo-only claims that full-swarm health or DB audit were confirmed failing are rejected; controller artifacts prove swarm health OK, while action-agent failure is separately proven by immediate probes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T124829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane edits, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; blocked `MAQ-024` anchor naming/proof packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T124829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T124829Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T124829Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T124829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T13:00:44Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 17 rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T130044Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T130044Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 analysis rows, one promotion circuit breaker row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `62405c4275492dd7544607e7a8eeb187cfd38ac6d1fdc60fc1b1498e4398d460`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T130044Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Current HEAD proves a Lane 0 naming conflict: the anchor uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires target-facing `OS-O0` naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.status-claims.txt`; current Manthan files
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.manthan-head.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback posture remains unresolved, root smoke and selection A/B scripts are absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because persisted `gh auth status` fails with invalid tokens and `copilot -p` fails with no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Agent claims that the current cycle DB has zero analysis findings are rejected by direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T130044Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Agent claims that `gh auth status` and no-op `copilot -p` pass are rejected by persisted current-cycle proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane edits, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; blocked `MAQ-024` anchor naming/proof packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T130044Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T130044Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T130044Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T130044Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T130044Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T131445Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T131445Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T13:30:52Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 22 rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T133052Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T133052Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 22 analysis rows and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `74a727a0124f7cbabfc72f476498772b8a2ca24cf610b0a926e0365b9c9743dc`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T133052Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Current HEAD proves a Lane 0 naming conflict: the anchor uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires target-facing `OS-O0` naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.status-claims.txt`; current Manthan files
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.manthan.head.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.gh-auth-summary.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The current-cycle zero-byte swarm artifact claim and Gemini controller-path access findings are rejected by controller artifact proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T133052Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T133052Z.swarm.status`
manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane edits, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; blocked `MAQ-024` anchor naming/proof packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T133052Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T133052Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T133052Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T133052Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T13:46:41Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 24 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from DB/output artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T134641Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T134641Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 analysis rows and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `80098d56aaa959466d21a413cf54867c789c801d1ff238e59b0d6f36e5333ab1`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T134641Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` is present in current HEAD, so the agent claim that it is tracked but not in current HEAD is stale/false.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.anchor-head-presence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T134641Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.status-claims.txt`; current Manthan file
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.script-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.copilot-noop.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The claim that active OS-O0 plus missing deliverable scripts is self-contradictory is rejected; the direction doc explicitly marks those scripts as deliverables.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T134641Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane edits, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; blocked `MAQ-023` direction-doc status packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T134641Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T134641Z.maq-023-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T134641Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T134641Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T14:07:03Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T140703Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T140703Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `0e81005ae1a425cb90add8ee7352140c3c146fb052c0847e0458dfa713a68301`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T140703Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor is 8 lines and lacks run id, date, and `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` linkage, so it cannot distinguish this P0 cycle from prior cycles.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The literal hyphenated `docker-compose` proof works; `docker compose` v2 absence is not a blocker for this cycle's proof command.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T140703Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.compose-config-q.status`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 remains open: root smoke and selection A/B executable gates are absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, and app-tier boundary proof remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.cbor-count.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	A future `MAQ-024` anchor hygiene patch is scoped to `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`, but this cycle did not authorize or execute it.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Gemini existence/config confirmations are not independent progress evidence; the reviewer merged them into the false-progress finding.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T140703Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane edits, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; blocked `MAQ-024` anchor hygiene packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by no-op proof, action-agent authentication, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T140703Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T140703Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T140703Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T140703Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T140703Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T14:26:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 21 rows, one error row, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T142646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T142646Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 21 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `62818c4210e198db9b49ad374bf820e2fe62c7d66b5a4f5ebb7b3f97757a2470`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T142646Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.script-gates.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L7	local-cycle-only	RECORDED	Current `gh auth status` passes and `copilot` exists, so broad prior `gh auth failed` queue text is stale for this run; Copilot product-write capability was not probed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.action-agent-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Following remediation order, the next safe product lane is `MAQ-001` boundary binding with write set `docker-compose.yml`, before trusted up-based smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that the cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected by direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, multi-lane execution, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-001` boundary handoff packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by missing reviewed product write set and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T142646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T142646Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; `gh auth status` passed but product action was not authorized; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T142646Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T142646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T14:44:03Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 18 rows, one error row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T144403Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T144403Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 18 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `af233914e9a5843dc116858a9f23e5ace3fac1e4d46d5f617d48ff8620a6900e`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T144403Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.script-gate-ls.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction/anchor drift remains current: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming and still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Following remediation order and boundary safety, `MAQ-001` remains the next exact guarded product packet before trusted up-based root smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that the cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected by direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, multi-lane execution, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed `MAQ-001` boundary handoff packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T144403Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T144403Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T144403Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T144403Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T144403Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T150148Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T150148Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T15:18:43Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 17 rows, two error/unparsed rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T151843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T151843Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `836f7c4be9f1569222b681a7d6934f97d72f275f1f6fab78630208ccdf47ecc4`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T151843Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The anchor lacks run id/date/tracker linkage, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted despite being committed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T151843Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.copilot-noop-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Following remediation order and boundary safety, `MAQ-001` remains the next exact guarded product packet before trusted up-based root smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The broad claim that `Conduir loop P0` in the anchor conflicts with the direction doc is rejected as overstated.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T151843Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Codex substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, multi-lane execution, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; refreshed `MAQ-001` boundary handoff packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T151843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T151843Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T151843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T151843Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T151843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T15:33:21Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 27 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected from DB/output artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T153321Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T153321Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 27 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `b392d1e7242d9a9b7c930a38385f1ba324503acb9b0fd9a0bd41611d819ff194`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T153321Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Target tracker linkage is absent at current Manthan HEAD, but a tracker product edit is scope-blocked until a later healthy cycle accepts it as an allowed write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.tracker-linkage.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.maq-024-tracker-linkage-scope-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` still self-labels as `DRAFT for review (uncommitted)` despite being committed at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.direction-grep.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured GitHub/Copilot action lane is unauthenticated in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.gh-auth-status.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.copilot-noop.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L9	none	REJECTED	DeepSeek claims that the anchor file is missing and `test -f` fails are rejected as controller-repo path errors.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T153321Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.anchor-test.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual operator substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; tracker-linkage scope packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by false-progress proof, scope mismatch, action-agent authentication, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T153321Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T153321Z.maq-024-tracker-linkage-scope-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; scope status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T153321Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T153321Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T15:46:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 24 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from DB/output artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T154638Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T154638Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `6b079240fc528a14e7845128ebdf46a4a3d7d8cb949b59104185f382ce1f38a2`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T154638Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Target tracker linkage is absent at current Manthan HEAD, but a tracker product edit is scope-blocked until a later healthy cycle accepts, narrows, or rejects it as an allowed write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.tracker-linkage.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.maq-024-tracker-linkage-scope-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction/anchor drift remains current: the direction doc self-labels as uncommitted while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.direction-anchor-grep.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.gh-auth-status.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.copilot-auth-probe.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that the current-cycle DB has zero analysis findings is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T154638Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual operator substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; tracker-linkage scope packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by false-progress proof, scope mismatch, action-agent authentication, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T154638Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T154638Z.maq-024-tracker-linkage-scope-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; scope status `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T154638Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T154638Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T16:02:28Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: one substantive agent, two error/unparsed rows, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T160228Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T160228Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `7240c9fa4aa1a896c1ff8db8aed31a79c0ddbd38e4a256d5fde2f2a779ab702e`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.compose-config-q.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Direction/tracker/anchor hygiene remains unresolved: direction self-labels as uncommitted, tracker linkage grep has zero rows, and the anchor declares no bounded write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.direction-anchor-grep.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.tracker-linkage.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.gh-auth-status.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.copilot-noop.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Standalone `docker-compose` works while Docker plugin spelling fails in this environment.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.compose-config-q.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.docker-compose-v2-config-q.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The degraded-host recommendation to repoint P0 product-stack proof to `infra/compose` is not accepted because current control docs select root `docker-compose.yml`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T160228Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260610T160228Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded; local proof recorded advisory findings only, with no product action or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T160228Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T160228Z.db-inspection.txt`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF` and `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T160228Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T160228Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T160228Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T16:15:48Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: DB audit `OK`, 25 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T161548Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T161548Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 25 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `d2bfc3c8f7b08868d68002d84da74275ea8df16a4a0e29f0d4272ee0088e762f`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T161548Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction/anchor drift remains current: the direction doc self-labels as uncommitted while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Target tracker linkage is absent at current Manthan HEAD, but a tracker product edit remains scope-blocked until a later healthy cycle accepts, narrows, or rejects it as an allowed write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.compose-source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.scripts-check.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.gh-auth.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.copilot-noop.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw or stale claim that this cycle had zero analysis findings is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T161548Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T161548Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T161548Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T161548Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T161548Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T16:30:12Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: DB audit `OK`, 18 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T163012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T163012Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 18 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `8e63f54b8637713d75288814003b6ccb8001474677c6bfd3bc5ede6d1f9b6a2f`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T163012Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction/anchor hygiene remains current: the direction doc requires `OS-O0` and still self-labels as uncommitted while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.gh-auth.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.copilot-noop.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`host.docker.internal` mapping is incomplete for substrate and maestro-bridge, but it remains a later concrete follow-up rather than this Lane 0 action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.host-internal.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw tracker-missing claim is rejected as a product-status defect because the direction doc says external-loop artifacts do not override Manthan tracker authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T163012Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.tracker-linkage.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Zero-analysis-finding claims, target-repo-only controller-artifact absence claims, immediate product action, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` anchor action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T163012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T163012Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T163012Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T163012Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T16:45:24Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: wrapper audit reports `DEGRADED`, host output reports one usable agent voice, and DB-detected reviewer synthesis is missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T164524Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T164524Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains seven analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `803b8e6a4e38f21c5051009b6a2124e70dc5610b0ef74d4559fcd52289b571e0`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.compose-config-q.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, `.cbor` count is `0`, and MCP/bridge surfaces are not exercised by a root smoke script.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.cbor-count.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.mcp-evidence.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Direction/tracker/anchor hygiene remains unresolved: direction self-labels as uncommitted, the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, and tracker-linkage grep has zero matches.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.tracker-linkage.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Standalone `docker-compose` works while Docker plugin spelling fails in this environment.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.compose-config-q.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.docker-compose-v2-config-q.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The degraded reviewer refutation of app-tier loopback risk is rejected as authoritative because current source compose proof shows app-tier published ports without `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T164524Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.compose-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, consensus wording, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit degraded; local proof recorded advisory findings only, with no product action or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T164524Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T164524Z.db-inspection.txt`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF` and `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T164524Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T164524Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T164524Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T170237Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T170237Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T17:18:54Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 15 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T171854Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T171854Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 15 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `b4c17a8e50682ba5172f15f266de833e689081d8b89e21ad29eb3f2105295a5b`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T171854Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved and route-significant.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction/anchor hygiene remains current: direction self-labels as uncommitted while the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Following remediation order and boundary safety, `MAQ-001` remains the next exact guarded product packet before trusted up-based root smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The reviewer correction that `gh auth status` passes is rejected by current shell proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T171854Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.gh-auth-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-001` boundary action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T171854Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T171854Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T171854Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T171854Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T17:32:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 22 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected from DB/output artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T173238Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T173238Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 22 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `aac5f1c0148d1eb3e5d023a454e0d08ff82835da78975f6f3a3f6eff53db758a`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T173238Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, while the tracked direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming and treats the external loop as controller evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in source/expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is the exact Lane 0 anchor rewrite packet for a later action-authorized cycle, with write set `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that this cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T173238Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` anchor action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T173238Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T173238Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T173238Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T173238Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T17:45:45Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 23 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T174545Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T174545Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `aad31d6997a01879686fb5dd8fd16de7165d6735dea94d35f17626d5a5a485ce`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T174545Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, while the tracked direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming and treats the external loop as controller evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured `copilot` action agent failed a bounded auth probe, even though `gh auth status` succeeded.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is the exact Lane 0 anchor rewrite packet for a later action-authorized cycle, with write set `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that this cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T174545Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.db-inspection.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` anchor action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T174545Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T174545Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T174545Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T174545Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T17:57:39Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper DB audit `OK`, 12 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T175739Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T175739Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 12 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `01e1d2f62400630df2d3013f34b896ecee963a83c9b101d5da1ba51ff1fdc087`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T175739Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`docker-compose config -q` and `infra/compose` config validation are static checks only and must not be recorded as product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, while the tracked direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming and treats the external loop as controller evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI authentication is invalid and the configured action agent `copilot` failed a bounded no-op auth probe.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact Lane 0 anchor/proof-hygiene rewrite packet for a later action-authorized cycle, with write set `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Gemini's high-severity `infra/compose` consistency concern is demoted to low/non-gating because `infra/compose` is supporting evidence, and its static config validates in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T175739Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` proof-hygiene packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T175739Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T175739Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T175739Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T175739Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T181050Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T181050Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T181050Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T182306Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T182306Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T183717Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T183717Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T185318Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T185318Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T19:06:03Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 14 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T190603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T190603Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 14 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `db89bf0e06ad18e382e7f9521b6998d65385a0c7c97dfcc3b081dfc87eeabb08`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T190603Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The target anchor still uses `Conduir loop P0` and lacks measurable exit conditions.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`docker-compose config -q` passed but remains static validation only, not root-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.compose-config-q.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` now has an exact one-file anchor exit-gate/proof-hygiene packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Gemini's cross-repo compose dependency and unsafe env-substitution findings are rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T190603Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.compose-config-q.err`
manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T190603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T190603Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T190603Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T190603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T19:19:20Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 25 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T191920Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T191920Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 25 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.db-inspection.txt`; DB SHA `f8a25b47f1f62913989b989965d1b61ec6acd67b26268a5e7af001f6dddf45a8`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T191920Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 gate proof was hardened with `OS-O0` positive and `Conduir loop P0` negative checks, and the updated JSON validates.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` count is `0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.cbor-count.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L9	accepted	PROMOTED	The committed direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted, but that remains separate `MAQ-023` scope.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T191920Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L10	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0/proof-hygiene packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z-L11	none	REJECTED	DB-empty, anchor-aligned/proceed, immediate product action, manual Copilot substitution, multi-lane execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement claims are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.db-inspection.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; controller P0 anchor proof was hardened, but `MAQ-024` product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T191920Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T191920Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; P0 gate JSON validates; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T191920Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T191920Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T193228Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T193228Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T19:43:25Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T194325Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T194325Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d38a24c75d863279ba20f3a17cff8065f70417b9b468c5176a8d30adfb6c0127`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T194325Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that this cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T194325Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Same-pass anchor plus tracker plus direction-doc editing, manual Copilot substitution, service-mesh boot, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T194325Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T194325Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T194325Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T194325Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T19:56:07Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T195607Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T195607Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 analysis rows, one promotion-circuit row, and no execution/evaluation/promotion/objective/evolution progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `6d77809ab1a895f91bbfb87d80b759ed6d41f659abf91f8fa9eed45f7ba4c163`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T195607Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, specific target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.tracker-linkage-specific.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Gemini's proceed/all-met claims are rejected by reviewer synthesis and current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T195607Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass anchor plus tracker plus direction-doc editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, multi-lane execution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T195607Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T195607Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T195607Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T195607Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T195607Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T200818Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T200818Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T20:22:02Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 27 rows, 0 error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T202202Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T202202Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 27 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `e4b212a18fcd7d383734b90dea1bacdfa27f40b1fc03bd8cc9be7835c415a449`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T202202Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that this cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T202202Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T202202Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T202202Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T202202Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T202202Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T202202Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T20:37:53Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 12 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T203753Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T203753Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 12 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `90b93020dcff614ae3e6f8059f2793e597597253ffca2635050900c5403b4f9c`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T203753Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.root-smoke-check.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.selection-ab-check.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.target-tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L9	none	SUPERSEDED	The in-flight claim that the current DB audit artifact is missing is superseded by the final wrapper audit artifact.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T203753Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T203753Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T203753Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T203753Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T203753Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T203753Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T203753Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T205023Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T205023Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T205023Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T21:02:21Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 14 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T210221Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T210221Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 14 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `b294858e3ad61fddac7f1785916ebe001963afa1df774b093eba7bfc9ecab802`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T210221Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty; direction doc status remains stale.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.root-smoke-check.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.selection-ab-check.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.target-tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The framing that absent smoke/selection scripts are already missed requirements is rejected; current direction text names them as OS-O0 deliverables, not existing executable gates.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T210221Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T210221Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T210221Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T210221Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T210221Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T21:18:12Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L1	local-cycle-only	RECORDED	Host swarm review was degraded despite host status `0`: wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, one error row, missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis, and host output reported a single usable agent voice.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T211812Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T211812Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L2	local-cycle-only	RECORDED	The cycle DB contains 8 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `69cb51c999ac9106d89a86d5ddf9626d5eedbbc5bd2ebe2f979965a5fdaa0315`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 exit spot-checks fail at current Manthan HEAD: anchor `OS-O0`, lingering `Conduir loop P0`, smoke executable, selection executable, and DB-audit health.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.p0-gate-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static compose validation passes, but app-tier boundary posture remains unresolved while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.compose-config-q.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates are absent, target tracker linkage and `.cbor` scans are empty, and GitHub/Copilot authentication fails.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.script-gates.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.target-tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L6	none	REJECTED	The single-source reviewer suggestion to advance the phase is rejected because full-swarm health is degraded and P0 gates fail.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T211812Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.p0-gate-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z-L7	local-cycle-only	RECORDED	No Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement is authorized from this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.manthan-status.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z	P0	Host swarm degraded; deterministic local proof ran as advisory only; no product action or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T211812Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T211812Z.local-proof.md`	full-swarm DB audit `DEGRADED`; local proof captured; action status `BLOCKED_PROOF` and `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; promoted count `0`.	guarded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T211812Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T211812Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T211812Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T21:31:18Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T213118Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T213118Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `b70b98a04ddedf10392416c2d5add7cba850495f68af0277b9f6e4e875846075`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T213118Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.anchor-direction-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.p0-gate-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent; target tracker linkage contains only incidental `infra/compose` hits, and `.cbor` scan is empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.p0-gate-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.target-tracker-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw claim that this cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T213118Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T213118Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T213118Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T213118Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T213118Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T214448Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T214448Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T21:59:06Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 25 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T215906Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T215906Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 25 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `a910a23db5c8b1c621d84dcd70eb17fda8b1eaa0be4605472487f129e8d54c98`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T215906Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`infra/compose` secondary exposure remains a separate future lane and should not be bundled with root app-tier boundary or Lane 0 anchor work.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.port-evidence.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, `.cbor` scan is empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty and GitHub-auth-passes claims are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T215906Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T215906Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T215906Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T215906Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T215906Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T22:12:06Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 18 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T221206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T221206Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 18 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `5929d0408336f632af5a1a40de4e4ba3122f9dbee8670184961361165ce40343`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T221206Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`infra/compose` secondary exposure remains a separate future lane and should not be bundled with root app-tier boundary or Lane 0 anchor work.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.port-evidence.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, `.cbor` scan is empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty and GitHub-auth-passes claims are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T221206Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T221206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T221206Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T221206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `conduir_changed,engine_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T221206Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T221206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T22:29:30Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T222930Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T222930Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `12b5adfbc026c391581f73027db24a1eed2d3507d61a0b150b095be27d3f00df`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T222930Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, `.cbor` scan is empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw empty-swarm-output and zero-review-substance claims are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T222930Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T222930Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T222930Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T222930Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T222930Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T22:43:34Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 16 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T224334Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T224334Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 16 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `e49eabe74764f9df6a4e7b343ca47715b7a3e2b6e5dbe6ff4411a21575a62942`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T224334Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, `.cbor` scan is empty, and the direction doc still self-labels as uncommitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty and GitHub-auth-passes claims are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T224334Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T224334Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T224334Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T224334Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T224334Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T23:00:29Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T230029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T230029Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `f61d1c89f35d34a2a090d9c439a7214ea82ac22cd44fb8b9689a75c2501edf33`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains the reviewer-ranked first blocker before any trusted live smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T230029Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor OS-O0 hygiene remains current: the anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T230029Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent, and `.cbor` scan is empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-001` remains the exact `docker-compose.yml` loopback-boundary packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty and DB-gate-violated claims are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T230029Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, service-mesh boot, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-001` boundary action packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T230029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T230029Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T230029Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T230029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T23:16:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 12 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T231623Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T231623Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 12 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `4290df2b6c5ccb912e2397fe60ec7c7259d886ae2b007b0cf0bffbfb9dadfa5d`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Anchor existence and static root compose validation pass, but static validation is not live smoke evidence and cannot advance P0 by itself.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 exit spot-checks fail at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`: anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and smoke/selection executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits remain blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the narrow one-file anchor `OS-O0` plus traceability packet, but it was not executed this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The reviewer recommendation to advance the phase is rejected because configured P0 gates still fail and no endpoint smoke, queue validation, or product action occurred.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T231623Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Deepseek's unparsed/wrong-repo output and raw critical DB-gate framing are rejected or downgraded where current controller artifacts disprove them.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T231623Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-024` anchor traceability packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T231623Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T231623Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T231623Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T231623Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T23:29:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 20 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T232923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T232923Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 20 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `c50eac628fd8f840b410172bff70fd38b85d0b3c9d53bad3131cb7e53df6e3a5`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains the reviewer-ranked first blocker before any trusted live smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T232923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Phase identity remains unresolved for controller gates: the anchor still says `Conduir loop P0`, lacks `OS-O0`, and the reviewer flags adoption ambiguity in the direction document.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not live product-stack smoke evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection A/B executable gates remain absent under current controller gates, and `.cbor` scan is empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-001` is refreshed as the exact `docker-compose.yml` loopback-boundary packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty, zero-output, and missing-status claims are rejected by current artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T232923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T232923Z.swarm.status`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, service-mesh boot, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Treating absent `OS-O0` scripts or `.cbor` vectors as standalone active-product failures is rejected until phase identity/adoption is resolved; they remain controller-gate blockers.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T232923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-001` boundary packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T232923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T232923Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T232923Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T232923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T234416Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T234416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z - P0 - 2026-06-10T23:59:13Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 25 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T235913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T235913Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB exists in the controller workspace and contains 25 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `1e4ed8df532430c20f800967ca7d25e0fb399b624051377983f3eaea7aa1cd89`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T235913Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved in expanded compose, while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 exit spot-checks fail at Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`: anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, smoke/selection executables are absent, and `.cbor` scan is empty.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.scripts.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan HEAD stayed clean and no Manthan product file was edited.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.manthan-head.txt`; `git -C manthan status --short`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-001` remains the exact `docker-compose.yml` loopback-boundary packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke script creation remains a separate Lane 2 action and must not be combined with the `MAQ-001` boundary edit in the same cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T235913Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty, DB-absent, and `config valid means smoke stable` claims are rejected by controller DB inspection and deterministic proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260610T235913Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual substitution for Copilot, same-pass boundary plus smoke edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, service-mesh boot, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.copilot-noop.txt`
2026-06-10	manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; `MAQ-001` boundary packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T235913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260610T235913Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260610T235913Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260610T235913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T00:14:28Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 27 rows, no error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer evidence from host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T001428Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T001428Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 27 analysis rows and no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `3c3d0d759e8871c4cbdd74dae211b8710abb5f5e64fa0a1d94c891135d7da71b`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static-compose objective remains false progress for P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T001428Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 still fails anchor, smoke, and selection executable checks at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.copilot-noop.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.auth-vars.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	The reviewer-ranked two-script plus doc-refresh recommendation is a multi-lane bundle and cannot authorize product action in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T001428Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.maq-002-scope-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-002` root smoke script remains a phase candidate for a later one-lane action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.maq-002-scope-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw DB-empty, DB-absent, infra-compose standalone exposure, and Phase 5 tracker findings are rejected or out of scope for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T001428Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Immediate Manthan product action, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, endpoint smoke, queue validation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.copilot-noop.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed review-only completion; `MAQ-002` scope packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication, multi-lane scope, unresolved boundary, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T001428Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T001428Z.maq-002-scope-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T001428Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T001428Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T00:29:29Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but reviewer synthesis was missing because the reviewer body was a Claude session-limit message; the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T002929Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T002929Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 16 analysis rows split `deepseek=11`, `gemini=4`, and `claude=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `aa56a585c597345009bf13c7a2e4abf5c6bf32fdd4ff0ba0000dd0683fb0bc52`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root compose validation passes, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, and selection executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.cbor-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains a phase-candidate Lane 0 anchor cleanup only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute the product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient full-swarm consensus because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T002929Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T002929Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Agent claims that the current cycle DB has 27 `analysis_findings` and that target-anchor absence in the controller repo is actionable are stale or wrong-scope.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T002929Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.copilot-noop.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory findings only; no Manthan product action or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T002929Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T002929Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T002929Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T002929Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T00:42:25Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but reviewer synthesis was missing because the reviewer body was a Claude session-limit message; the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T004225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T004225Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 15 analysis rows split `deepseek=10`, `gemini=4`, and `claude=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `9d2bbaf9fdb6fc363b4e63e5b6f1e50cb8223a48ba0cc6dd9349021a37633ff4`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation passes, but P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, and selection executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains a phase-candidate Lane 0 anchor cleanup only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute the product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient full-swarm consensus because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T004225Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T004225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The DeepSeek claim that this cycle had empty/missing host artifacts is stale after current status, output, DB audit, and DB inspection artifacts exist.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T004225Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T004225Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.copilot-noop.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory findings only; no Manthan product action or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T004225Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T004225Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit artifact exists but is insufficient for action because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T004225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T004225Z.swarm.out`	wrapper DB audit `OK`; operator health `DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T004225Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T004225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T00:54:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but reviewer synthesis was missing because the reviewer body was a Claude session-limit message; the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T005455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T005455Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 analysis rows split `deepseek=13`, `gemini=3`, and `claude=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `339a49143133cce3672e2102abdeb6170801c7c88da7f6170183f9ce7b8a5af3`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation passes, but P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, and selection executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.copilot-noop.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains a phase-candidate Lane 0 anchor cleanup only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute the product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient full-swarm consensus because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T005455Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T005455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The DeepSeek claim that this cycle had no evidence files is stale after current local proof, compose, route, status, auth, and DB inspection artifacts exist.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.copilot-noop.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory findings only; no Manthan product action or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T005455Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T005455Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit artifact exists but is insufficient for action because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T005455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T005455Z.swarm.out`	wrapper DB audit `OK`; operator health `DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T005455Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T005455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T010620Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T010620Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T011725Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T011725Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T011725Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T012934Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T012934Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T012934Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T014046Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T014046Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T01:52:01Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but substantive reviewer synthesis was missing because the reviewer row and REVIEW body were a Claude session-limit message; the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T015201Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T015201Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 15 analysis rows split `deepseek=10`, `gemini=4`, and `claude=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `4e859032af81823a3084325c426a19ef91558261e7012455799133f84962da74`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, and literal `infra/compose`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.cbor-scan.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains a phase-candidate Lane 0 anchor cleanup only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient full-swarm consensus because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T015201Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T015201Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Swarm-only healthcheck/image-name suggestions are not promoted because this degraded cycle did not replay them as the selected one-lane proof target.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T015201Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T015201Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T015201Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit artifact exists but is insufficient for action because substantive reviewer synthesis is missing.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T015201Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T015201Z.swarm.out`	wrapper DB audit `OK`; operator health `DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T015201Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T015201Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T02:08:09Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: DB audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T020809Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T020809Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six analysis rows split `claude=1 unparsed`, `deepseek=1 unparsed`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `04cbbd515c20eee581c2a03d645d88e63b701a6a3c941b72cbb23d23767b633a`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, and literal `infra/compose`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.cbor-scan.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Env/compose drift is advisory: `MAESTRO_BRIDGE_HOST_PORT` appears in compose with a default while `.env.example` omits it, but this was not the selected action lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains phase-candidate only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Gemini-only proof-command and infra-compatibility suggestions are not promoted as swarm findings from this degraded single-voice review.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T020809Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z	P0	Host review degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T020809Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T020809Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T020809Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T020809Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T020809Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T02:19:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but substantive reviewer synthesis was missing, so the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED` for action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T021923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T021923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 20 analysis rows split `deepseek=16`, `gemini=3`, and `claude=1 unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `39b713ff24d3735429217181abe8385549ddaddaa99ff6aa489de9911e39cc0a`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, and literal `infra/compose`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.cbor-scan.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Env/compose drift is advisory: `MAESTRO_BRIDGE_HOST_PORT` appears in compose with a default while `.env.example` omits it, but this was not the selected action lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains phase-candidate only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient action authorization because the reviewer synthesis is not substantive.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T021923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T021923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.db-inspection.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T021923Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T021923Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; wrapper audit `OK` but reviewer synthesis missing; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T021923Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T021923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T02:30:56Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but substantive reviewer synthesis was missing, so the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED` for action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T023056Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T023056Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 18 analysis rows split `deepseek=15`, `gemini=2`, and `claude=1 unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d76c4d4150fb88b3db313988de388b89b8a67796a1ed07dc35a865467ed80228`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, and literal `infra/compose`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present and `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.cbor-scan.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Env/compose drift is advisory: `MAESTRO_BRIDGE_HOST_PORT` appears in compose with a default while `.env.example` omits it, but this was not the selected action lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.env-port.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains phase-candidate only; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Wrapper audit `OK` is rejected as sufficient action authorization because the reviewer synthesis is not substantive.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T023056Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T023056Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.db-inspection.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T023056Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T023056Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; wrapper audit `OK` but reviewer synthesis missing; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T023056Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T023056Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T024215Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T024215Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T024215Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T025233Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T025233Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T030518Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T030518Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T030518Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T03:15:15Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: DB audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T031515Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T031515Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six analysis rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, `gemini/high=1`, `gemini/medium=2`, and `gemini/low=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `40bb52a1f51aeedf1cd22969807170071fb922a6258a885ec00085fa5c09bd3a`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, literal `infra/compose`, direction-doc self-status, and host DB health.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L5	accepted-local-proof	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD, and env/compose drift is advisory only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.cbor-scan.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024`, `MAQ-023`, and `MAQ-001` remain separate future lanes; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Gemini-only claims that the anchor/static proof satisfies P0 are not promoted as swarm findings from this degraded single-voice review.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T031515Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z	P0	Host review degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T031515Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T031515Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T031515Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T031515Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T031515Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T03:25:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host wrapper audit reported `OK`, but substantive reviewer synthesis was missing because the REVIEW body was a Claude session-limit message; the operator downgraded this cycle to `DEGRADED`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T032538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T032538Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 analysis rows split across `deepseek`, `gemini`, and `claude/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows and a non-tripped promotion circuit.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `6d6cfe28e8e9c69089b19230efaefc1ee5a4011049134f41db73bb48fc4675aa`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, literal `infra/compose`, and direction-doc self-status.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L5	accepted-local-proof	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD, and env/compose drift is advisory only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024`, `MAQ-023`, and `MAQ-001` remain separate future lanes; this degraded-for-action cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z-L8	none	REJECTED	DeepSeek claims that the anchor file does not exist and that current host artifacts are missing or empty are stale after current HEAD and host artifact proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T032538Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.db-inspection.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z	P0	Host review downgraded to degraded for action authorization; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T032538Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T032538Z.db-inspection.json`	wrapper health `OK`; operator swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T032538Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T032538Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T03:44:58Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: DB audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T034458Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six analysis rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, `gemini/critical=1`, `gemini/high=1`, `gemini/medium=1`, and `gemini/low=1`, with no product/progress rows except one promotion-circuit row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `a6e61b21d56ca84f46140df2a1164191c134d533a28d34be632f62f4476f30b9`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static root and infra compose validation pass, but current P0 spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, stale `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, selection executable, literal `infra/compose`, and direction-doc self-status.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved, while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L5	accepted-local-proof	PROMOTED	Status-drift proof remains present, `.cbor` scan is empty at current Manthan HEAD, and env/compose drift is advisory only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.cbor-files.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.env-compose-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.proof-counts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024`, `MAQ-023`, and `MAQ-001` remain separate future lanes; this degraded cycle cannot refresh or execute a product packet.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual Copilot substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Gemini-only suggestions from this degraded single-voice review are not promoted as swarm consensus or product-action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T034458Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.db-inspection.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z	P0	Host review degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, queue validation, endpoint smoke, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T034458Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted-local-proof	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no product-action learning promoted.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T034458Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T034458Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T034458Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T034458Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T035954Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T035954Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T041323Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T041323Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T04:24:45Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T042445Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T042445Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `701c8a71756b260169185c19c4c7c02d7e3fcb43b606e67875c598ee9010b7d3`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The current Lane 0 anchor still uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the committed direction doc requires `OS-O0` and forbids `Phase 0/P0` external-stage naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T042445Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not live product-stack smoke; root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, and the app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.gh-auth-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Gemini claims that the anchor aligns with current phase config or that static compose proves readiness are rejected as false-progress framing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T042445Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T042445Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T042445Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T042445Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T042445Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T04:37:59Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T043759Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T043759Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 analysis rows and no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `5cab127b632aab669f41494b005aca5ab1e57f9b7f502ca5b16ecc33c788655d`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The current Lane 0 anchor still uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the committed direction doc requires `OS-O0` and forbids `Phase 0/P0` external-stage naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T043759Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not live product-stack smoke; root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, and the app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.gh-auth-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The host pre-cycle Manthan status artifact is empty, but operator replay against current Manthan HEAD was clean before any action decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T043759Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Claims that current host artifacts are empty or missing, that the anchor is absent, or that standalone `docker-compose` is v1 are rejected or downgraded after current artifact proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T043759Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication, empty host pre-Manthan-status capture, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T043759Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T043759Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T043759Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T043759Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T04:52:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T045246Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T045246Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 analysis rows split across `claude`, `deepseek`, and `gemini`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `43ced38352018b011a1ac0adc2dc22af1ead118d746e97a2a0d1719cedc07e96`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The current Lane 0 anchor still uses `Conduir loop P0`, while the committed direction doc requires `OS-O0` and forbids `Phase 0/P0` external-stage naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T045246Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.anchor-direction.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not live product-stack smoke; root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, and the app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.gh-auth-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The host pre-cycle Manthan status artifact is empty, but host output is non-empty and operator replay against current Manthan HEAD was clean before any action decision.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T045246Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T045246Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.operator.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Claims that current host artifacts are empty or missing, that the DB has zero analysis rows, or that standalone `docker-compose` is v1 are rejected or downgraded after current artifact proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T045246Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication, empty host pre-Manthan-status capture, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T045246Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T045246Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T045246Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T045246Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T05:09:18Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 11 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T050918Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T050918Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 11 analysis rows split across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `3ad1cf4892d5fe85958d660fecbbbab421317ff96d0851ebe0e4d199862be2ae`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The old Lane 0 anchor/target-selection objective is already satisfied at current Manthan HEAD, so re-authoring it would be false progress; the live anchor hygiene gap remains `Conduir loop P0` versus `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T050918Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.anchor.git-log.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed but is not live product-stack smoke; root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, and the app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.scripts.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.gh-auth-status.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan status was clean before action decision and stayed unchanged; empty `git status --short` output is clean-status evidence, not by itself a missing-status gap.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T050918Z.pre.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.operator.manthan.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.manthan.head`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle; `MAQ-025` tracker linkage remains separate.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Gemini claims that the review lacked verifiable health proof or DB health are rejected as stale after current wrapper audit, host output, and DB inspection artifacts.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T050918Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T050918Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; old anchor/static proof was rejected as false progress; `MAQ-024` packet refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T050918Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T050918Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T050918Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T050918Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T05:23:41Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 14 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T052341Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T052341Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 14 analysis rows split across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `caaaffb024ebeedef47869fedf06f4d4fda19f9e1739ec53792e05a8a03bbf26`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor uses `Conduir loop P0` / `Lane 0`, while the current direction doc requires `OS-O0` naming and says external-loop artifacts are not Manthan's status of record.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T052341Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root compose has 39 interpolated lines and ignored root/infra `.env` files, so `docker-compose config -q` depends on local ignored state and cannot be exit evidence by itself.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`; `git check-ignore -v .env infra/compose/.env`; `grep -c '\${' docker-compose.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The eight-line anchor has no exit-gate or exit-evidence section, and the Manthan tracker has no anchor, `Lane 0`, or `Conduir loop P0` linkage.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, and route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because `copilot -p` returned `402 quota_exceeded`, even though GitHub CLI auth currently passes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle; tracker linkage, boundary, smoke, and selection remain separate lanes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Claims that root compose has zero interpolation or no ignored-env dependency are rejected after current proof found 39 interpolated lines and ignored `.env` files.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T052341Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Gemini's positive anchor-alignment claim is rejected as false-progress framing under current `OS-O0` direction.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T052341Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and phase advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot quota exhaustion, static-proof insufficiency, ignored-env reproducibility risk, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T052341Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T052341Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T052341Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T052341Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T052341Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T05:45:25Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T054525Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T054525Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows and no product/progress rows; the zero-analysis-row claim is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `c731935d08c28904592fd7168fd8d91a7f424fde7dd1b384f62395f9dd8b3840`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Standalone `docker-compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` passes, while plugin-form `docker compose -f docker-compose.yml config -q` fails on this host.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.compose-standalone-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.compose-plugin-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation is not live root smoke; root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Direction-doc status is stale, but missing smoke/selection scripts are tracked OS-O0 work rather than broken references.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T054525Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because `copilot -p` fails with no authentication information even though GitHub CLI auth passes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.gh-auth.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-002` is emitted as the exact `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The agent claim that this cycle's DB has zero analysis findings is rejected by direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T054525Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and phase advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; static proof was rejected as false progress; `MAQ-002` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot action-agent unavailability and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T054525Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T054525Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T054525Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T054525Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T06:05:41Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 10 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T060541Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T060541Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 10 analysis rows split across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `cc0fbc82649126d03743ecb298de7b69fcea9675bcdda2cf6663e5219a01b772`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress: the anchor is already committed, file-existence and grep proofs pass by construction, and no product/progress rows exist.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T060541Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.review-proof.md`; `git -C manthan log --oneline --name-only -1 2408120`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`CLAUDE.md` still names `infra/compose/` as the official internal default while the anchor names root `docker-compose.yml` as proof target; this is target-rationale drift, not same-cycle authorization to switch targets.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T060541Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.review-proof.md`; `CLAUDE.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 gate spot checks fail for anchor `OS-O0`, negative `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke executable, and selection executable; app-tier boundary remains unresolved.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent auth proof failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	No Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement is authorized by this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Gemini's positive claim that the anchor is synchronized and enables safe advancement is rejected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T060541Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Rewriting the anchor, switching target convention, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T060541Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.review-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; selected anchor/static proof was rejected as false progress; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by failed P0 gates and action-agent authentication.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T060541Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T060541Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T060541Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T060541Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T060541Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T06:19:50Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 21 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T061950Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T061950Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 21 analysis rows and no product/progress rows; stale zero-row DB claims from agent output are rejected by direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d9d728d676fa511495b7437d416a1a96c566d263073a2733f828f7cae2dccb28`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress for P0 exit evidence because it only proves file existence, grep matches, clean status, and static compose config.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T061950Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.review-proof.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent, app-tier boundary remains unresolved, and route proof has 53 API/route lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.compose-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because Copilot could not execute shell auth checks in this non-interactive runtime, even though operator `gh auth status` passed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` anchor hygiene and `MAQ-002` root smoke remain separate future lanes; neither was product-executed or validated in this cycle.	`delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Gemini's positive claims that the anchor/static proof is sufficient for safe finalization are rejected by current P0 proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T061950Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; selected anchor/static proof was rejected as false progress; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot action-agent runtime permission failure and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T061950Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T061950Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T061950Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T061950Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T06:31:39Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 11 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T063139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T063139Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 11 analysis rows split across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `f08bd0f4258261577c67b9f5ddef9a6db870f9ccbbb23aecbd896b848da4825c`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	OS-O0 deliverables are unbuilt: root smoke and selection executable gates fail at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not live root product-stack smoke and does not exercise five build services or host-gateway connectivity.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.compose-runtime-lines.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor uses `Conduir loop P0` while the direction doc requires `OS-O0`; a blocked `MAQ-024` one-file action packet was emitted.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The tracker does not yet record root `docker-compose.yml` as product-stack smoke target; keep this as a separate future tracker-linkage lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.tracker-target-lines.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Gemini's host-gateway top-risk framing is rejected for this cycle as current-action authorization because the selected proof never starts the stack.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T063139Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.compose-runtime-lines.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; OS-O0 remained unbuilt and static proof was rejected as false progress; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot/GitHub auth and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T063139Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T063139Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T063139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T07:01:38Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 26 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T070138Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T070138Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 26 analysis rows split across all three agents, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `f568eaec71896394a1d3eba255d11cd7af427e2ddfb75bbd63b837f305fdbfe3`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress and cannot satisfy P0 exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T070138Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	OS-O0 root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	In this cycle, standalone and plugin-form compose static validation both exit `0`; plugin version is `v2.39.4`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.compose-standalone-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.compose-plugin-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.docker-compose-version.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-002` is refreshed as the exact one-file `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Positive claims that compose validity and a clean tree allow safe movement are rejected as false comfort.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T070138Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; static anchor proof was rejected as false progress; `MAQ-002` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T070138Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T070138Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T06:44:16Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T064416Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 analysis rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `98bcafbc919524ec6f9eb8022e685e1e4147e2daf4ce255953f4d9b758dab2a4`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier loopback/default-safe boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation passed, but it is not OS-O0 live root smoke; root smoke and selection executable checks fail.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The target anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` while the direction doc requires `OS-O0` external-stage naming.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.status-claims.txt`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured Copilot action lane could not execute usable shell checks or produce a patch in this runtime.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-001` is emitted as the exact one-file boundary action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The agent claim that this cycle's DB has zero analysis findings is rejected by direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T064416Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; reviewer ranked boundary binding as top verified action; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by Copilot action-agent runtime permissions and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T064416Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T063139Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T063139Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; chronological tail marker for the current cycle after a pre-existing duplicate prior-cycle row.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T064416Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T064416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion; chronological tail marker after pre-existing duplicate prior-cycle rows.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T070138Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; `MAQ-002` packet emitted; no product edit; no phase advancement	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T070138Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T070138Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T07:16:17Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: wrapper audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T071617Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T071617Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six analysis rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, `gemini/high=1`, and `gemini/low=3`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `6c4012e1e545aa9de7db85fa93e4ddcb848df2a312c3e5b409be35b2ff247522`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static anchor/compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence; the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	OS-O0 root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan internal Phase 5 status must remain separated from Conduir control-loop P0 gate status.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Positive static-precondition claims from the single substantive degraded review are rejected as product-action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T071617Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T071617Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T071617Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T071617Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T071617Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T071617Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T07:26:41Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 23 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T072641Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T072641Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 `analysis_findings` rows split across all three agents, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `5cf312683113d3abfafa97940530dd290e14850cda8640c9f1d404f443caa752`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress; the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still says `Conduir loop P0`, and static compose validation is not live product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	OS-O0 root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Target tracker linkage remains a separate future lane because `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` lacks current OS-O0/anchor linkage.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Positive claims that the current anchor/static proof is sufficient are rejected as false-progress framing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T072641Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L10	none	REJECTED	DeepSeek's raw claim that this cycle DB has zero analysis findings is rejected by direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T072641Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T072641Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T072641Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T072641Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T072641Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T072641Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T07:41:00Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 17 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T074100Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T074100Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 `analysis_findings` rows split across `deepseek`, `gemini`, and `claude/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `a5bc01080b79e868c77c6e87fd21c1df34eca0873f9a3102043f505b18540593`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress for P0 exit evidence because static compose validation is not live product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T074100Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The anchor exists but fails stricter P0 naming checks: it lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	`CLAUDE.md:60` has current gate-path drift: stale `herald-protocol/manthan-platform/gates/...` path versus live `manthan-platform/gates/` files.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.claude-gate-path.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.gate-files.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-002` is refreshed as the exact one-file `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Positive claims that static compose validity and a clean tree satisfy P0 are rejected as false-progress framing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T074100Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z-L11	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; static anchor proof was rejected as false progress; `MAQ-002` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T074100Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T074100Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T074100Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T074100Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T07:54:20Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 12 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T075420Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T075420Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 12 `analysis_findings` rows split across `claude`, `gemini`, and `deepseek/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `566458d81389519cd033fe112be4956489d56891dbbfebb2a72f9bbf2b129d97`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress for P0 exit evidence because the anchor already exists and static compose validation is not live product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T075420Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The anchor lacks measurable exit-gate criteria and tracker linkage, making `MAQ-024` the next scoped Lane 0 packet after action authorization is restored.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T075420Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	The stricter P0 gates remain open: anchor `OS-O0` positive check fails, negative `Conduir loop P0` check fails, and root smoke/selection executable checks fail.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof includes write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Positive claims that static compose validity and a clean tree satisfy P0 are rejected as false-progress framing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T075420Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; static anchor proof was rejected as false progress; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T075420Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T075420Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T075420Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T075420Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T08:07:05Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: wrapper audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T080705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T080705Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six `analysis_findings` rows with severity counts `low=2`, `medium=2`, and `unparsed=2`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `5d294071918875950c2e1b29656cffe74014d3cba175abb8c5f80721e3bb4d24`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static anchor/compose proof remains false progress for P0 exit evidence; the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still says `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	OS-O0 root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.compose-source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan internal Phase 5 status, the OS-O0 direction draft, and Conduir control-loop P0 gates must remain separate until later healthy review reconciles authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Positive single-agent claims that the anchor is aligned, the DB audit satisfies the safety rule, or static compose supports safe movement are rejected as product-action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T080705Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T080705Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T080705Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no product learning promoted.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T080705Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T080705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T080705Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T080705Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T080705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T082143Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T082143Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T083745Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T083745Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T083745Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T08:51:12Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 15 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T085112Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T085112Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 15 `analysis_findings` rows split across `deepseek`, `gemini`, and `claude/unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `446178ca07aaac1446bbcd0e8f3bd9c2b85c036b015ba4b04a7fa511458649b3`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress for P0 exit evidence because the anchor already exists and static compose validation is not live product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T085112Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The anchor still says `Conduir loop P0`, lacks `OS-O0`, and root smoke/selection executable gates remain absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L8	none	REJECTED	DeepSeek's raw claim that this cycle DB has zero analysis findings is rejected by direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T085112Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Gemini's positive claim that the anchor and project configuration are aligned is rejected by reviewer synthesis and current P0 spot checks.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T085112Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, boundary binding, root-smoke creation, selection-script creation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T085112Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T085112Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T085112Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T085112Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T09:05:35Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 26 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T090535Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T090535Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 26 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=13`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `413f9bd0cfaffd67deca76f2dc905c29ca4d69ffb115df52a0ede7d305be72ea`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is safe to run but non-advancing because static compose validation is not live product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T090535Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is still current: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` has a current one-file patch packet but remains blocked until authenticated action-agent execution or explicit human-approved substitution.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L9	none	REJECTED	DeepSeek's raw claim that this cycle had zero swarm output, missing status, or zero DB findings is rejected by host files and direct DB replay.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T090535Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T090535Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` attempted through the required Copilot lane but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T090535Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T090535Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T090535Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T090535Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T092021Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T092021Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T09:34:07Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 13 rows, one error row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T093407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T093407Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 `analysis_findings` rows split across `claude`, `deepseek/unparsed`, and `gemini`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `453f6e50e390c2e3861e912693f6dc82d9989545b199bc4a304800a7981c8a55`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress because the candidate proofs were already green or self-referential and the packet named no product write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T093407Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T093407Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Root and `infra/compose` static compose validation pass, but this is config parsing only, not build/start/probe product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 spot checks still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke/selection executable scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.anchor-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub/Copilot action-agent authentication failed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	A future action-authorized cycle must name an exact write set and use a non-circular proof command.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T093407Z.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T093407Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Gemini's raw claim that the anchor document itself must contain DB-audit evidence is rejected as misdirected; controller DB audit evidence exists.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T093407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T093407Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; the selected anchor/static proof and missing write set blocked product action; no Manthan product edit, endpoint smoke, queue validation, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T093407Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T093407Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_SCOPE` and `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T093407Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T093407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T09:46:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T094646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T094646Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split across all three agents, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `26e2334c4f7d20170d623289123c0cd053ec6026b2ee8082ade41ba05503d7e2`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress for phase advancement because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T094646Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`, exit evidence, proof-command, write-set, run, and tracker linkage.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable gates remain incomplete: root and infra static compose checks pass, but root smoke and selection scripts are absent and app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not usable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is emitted as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Positive claims that the anchor action is still pending or that static compose validation can move P0 are rejected as stale or insufficient.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T094646Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T094646Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T094646Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T094646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T094646Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T094646Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T09:59:28Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 29 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T095928Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T095928Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 29 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=17`, and `gemini=3`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `03471e3c0fdef56237959d635b11eacabee8f2be2533c5771ee03d5aa7d1b56e`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress for phase advancement because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T095928Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable gates remain incomplete: root and infra static compose checks pass, but root smoke and selection scripts are absent and app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not usable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is emitted as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had empty swarm output or zero DB findings are rejected by settled host files and direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T095928Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T095928Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T095928Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T095928Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T095928Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T095928Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T095928Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T10:14:09Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T101409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T101409Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=12`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `8ef8d4746cb77bf7a86ee17988bf5c083ff6bdceb039028802dc394a135cfb75`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress for phase advancement because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or DB product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T101409Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The current anchor still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable gates remain incomplete: root and infra static compose checks pass, but root smoke and selection scripts are absent and app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.infra-compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is not usable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is emitted as the exact one-file `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L8	none	REJECTED	The raw promotion-circuit-breaker trip claim is rejected; direct DB inspection shows the initialized default singleton row with zero failures and no halted window.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The raw critical port finding is rejected as same-cycle scope/severity because boundary posture remains a separate `MAQ-001` lane, not part of `MAQ-024`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T101409Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.port-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T101409Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T101409Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T101409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T10:28:13Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T102813Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T102813Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=12`, and `gemini=3`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `51caee7cca5466b1529413987ae5d309fd7be25583e0210281f25c638c797b71`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected anchor/static proof is false progress for phase advancement because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or DB product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T102813Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, and the target tracker lacks loop-state wording.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.scripts-list.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.compose-source-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` is committed at current Manthan HEAD but still self-labels as draft/uncommitted; this is low-risk status drift, not phase-exit evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor semantics packet for a later action-authorized cycle, but it is blocked in this cycle by action-agent availability.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that compose proof had not run or that healthy swarm DB audit evidence was absent are rejected as stale for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T102813Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T102813Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z	P0	Host review was healthy for review coverage; `MAQ-024` packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T102813Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T102813Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T101409Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T101409Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T102813Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T102813Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T10:42:13Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded: wrapper audit reports six rows, two error/unparsed rows, one substantive agent (`gemini`), and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T104213Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T104213Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains six `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, and four `gemini` severity rows, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `b0d8095addf03c2e47b183147d7e8e5e87ff56070a2bc396baf4ea7b6524e049`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static compose validation remains non-smoke evidence and cannot prove live root product-stack readiness.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The anchor remains non-advancing P0 evidence because it still says `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`.	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root smoke and selection executable gates remain absent at current Manthan HEAD.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Root app-tier boundary remains unresolved while route proof has 53 route/API lines including write/admin-capable surfaces.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Manthan internal Phase 5 status claims and Conduir control-loop P0 gates must remain separate until later healthy review reconciles authority.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, manual substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Positive single-agent claims that static compose validity or anchor existence can move P0 are rejected as product-action authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T104213Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T104213Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T104213Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T104213Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T104213Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T104213Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T10:53:11Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 19 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T105311Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T105311Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 19 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek critical=5 high=4 medium=3 low=2`, and `gemini high=1 medium=2 low=1`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d145a8868f4e8cd284e0fe255f3b3fcff63c0496d794e668e8ac75667c9fa35d`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is false progress for phase advancement because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or product DB progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T105311Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable and boundary gates remain incomplete: anchor naming fails, root smoke and selection scripts are absent, and app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Expanded compose omits budget/dormancy guardrail env vars from `api` and `maestro-bridge`, while `runtime` and `substrate` include them.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and no-op `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	A later action-authorized cycle should select exactly one reviewed product write set rather than re-run the Lane 0 static anchor proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had empty swarm output, no status file, or zero DB findings are rejected by settled host files and direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T105311Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T105311Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; selected static anchor proof was rejected as non-advancing; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by missing write-set authorization, action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T105311Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T105311Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T105311Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T105311Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T11:08:29Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T110829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T110829Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split across all three agents, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `03a1aedfa0748b1fb75216603b5911c5724ce51d0e83dabef7b9db3f339b413a`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or product DB progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T110829Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Expanded compose omits budget/dormancy guardrail env vars from `api` and `maestro-bridge`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.compose-api-bridge.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable and boundary gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and root smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because the configured Copilot action lane is unavailable in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-022` is emitted as the exact one-file `docker-compose.yml` guardrail environment restoration packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.maq-022-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the DB was empty or that static compose validation plus anchor existence make P0 safe to advance are rejected by direct proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T110829Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-022` guardrail packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T110829Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T110829Z.maq-022-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T110829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T110829Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T110829Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T11:22:09Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 17 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T112209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T112209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek=11`, and `gemini=5`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `c72406229c1e27dcee7fc62514e4acfcaeb7c8aa3d50e36c5dbfb1cf0aa4e589`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or product DB progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T112209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable checks still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 boundary and guardrail gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit guardrail env in expanded compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.compose-api-bridge.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and no-op `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 hygiene packet for a later action-authorized cycle, but it is blocked in this cycle by action-agent availability.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that DB audit was absent, or that static compose validation plus anchor existence can move P0, are rejected by settled host files and direct proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T112209Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-024` anchor OS-O0 packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T112209Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T112209Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T112209Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T112209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T11:36:03Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 12 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T113603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T113603Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 12 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `gemini=3`, and `deepseek=1 unparsed`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `eae8910abda715f0fddea1d57edc32ae90e65f0499c4a3ad371a1c46d2af081b`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress because it proves anchor prose and static config only, not live root product-stack smoke or product DB progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T113603Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable checks still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke/selection scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.scripts-list.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.anchor-direction-tracker.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 boundary and guardrail gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and expanded compose only shows budget/dormancy guardrail env on `runtime` and `substrate`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.port-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and no-op `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The Phase 5 `DONE` versus pending-AWS claim is a low-priority Manthan tracker label-drift cleanup, not a contradiction that authorizes P0 advancement or product action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T113603Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; selected static anchor proof was rejected as non-advancing; product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T113603Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T113603Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T113603Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T113603Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T11:46:20Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 16 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T114620Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T114620Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 16 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek=11`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `b976000f2d406048c5827310c9e28801c9c5a72da067405a97042959a023589a`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.review-proof.md`; `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static compose validation remains pre-smoke evidence only; root smoke and selection executable scripts are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and expanded compose shows guardrail env only on `runtime` and `substrate`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and no-op `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.gh-auth-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 hygiene packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had empty swarm output or zero DB findings are rejected by settled host files and DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T114620Z.swarm.status`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T114620Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-024` anchor OS-O0 packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T114620Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T114620Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T114620Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T114620Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T114620Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T120214Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T120214Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T12:15:46Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T121546Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T121546Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split across all three agents, with no product/progress rows and no halted promotion circuit breaker.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `7c75a6c68d2557b07ae4a5a67185fe316e217b6673b259e61eeaeda8f63a0f84`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor and compose proof remain false progress for phase advancement because they do not build, boot, healthcheck, probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T121546Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit budget/dormancy env in expanded compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Current HEAD verifies low-risk doc drift in `CLAUDE.md`, `MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md`, and `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`, but it is outside this cycle's Lane 0 write set.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.doc-drift-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.path-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth and no-op `copilot -p` both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is emitted as the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the DB had zero analysis rows, the anchor referenced `dir/some_subdir/`, Compose was v1/EOL, or the promotion circuit breaker was halted are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T121546Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.docker-compose-version.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, manual Copilot substitution, same-pass multi-lane editing, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-024` anchor OS-O0 packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T121546Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T121546Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T121546Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T121546Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T12:31:24Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 23 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T123124Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T123124Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 23 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=11`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `046133185ff2d93191231d260ec5c8187fb99915f92a0cabe9985c7e980d8bb9`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor and compose proof remain false progress for phase advancement because they do not build, boot, healthcheck, probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T123124Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail gates remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and budget/dormancy env is absent from `api` and `maestro-bridge` expanded service definitions.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	The configured Copilot action lane could not perform the one-file Manthan product edit: `gh auth status` captured invalid tokens and the action attempt reported patch/direct/in-place writes denied with `Changes +0 -0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet, but this cycle cannot mark it product-executed.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-024` was assigned to Copilot, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked when the action agent could not write the one-file anchor patch.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T123124Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T123124Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T123124Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; no product edit; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T123124Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T123124Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T124705Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T124705Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T124705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T12:59:36Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host review was degraded for action authorization: status `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, seven rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T125936Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T125936Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains seven `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, and `gemini critical=1 high=1 medium=2 low=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `50be6f03ea5135b4a25975384d3bb212eeb334572ed550c5747d91e3f4ea8d51`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, architecture scan has 596 lines, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` lack budget/dormancy env in expanded compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are blocked because local proof in a degraded cycle is advisory only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Raw degraded-cycle claims that CWD-relative `context: .` is critical or that Conduir repos are missing are rejected by current proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T125936Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T125936Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T125936Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T125936Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T125936Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T125936Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T125936Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T13:10:45Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 28 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T131045Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T131045Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 28 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=16`, and `gemini=4`, with no product/progress rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `7652afedbfeb78f06d42651e218b5c81d04d8284078c310c35168772cbd50932`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T131045Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`api` and `maestro-bridge` lack budget/dormancy/gateway `MANTHAN_*` env keys in expanded compose while `runtime` and `substrate` retain them.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T131045Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth and no-op `copilot -p` both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-022` is emitted as the exact `docker-compose.yml` guardrail restoration packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.maq-022-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had zero DB findings or empty swarm output are rejected by settled host files and direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T131045Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z	P0	Host review was healthy for coverage; `MAQ-022` guardrail packet emitted, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T131045Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T131045Z.maq-022-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T131045Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T131045Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T13:27:21Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded for action authorization: status `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, seven rows, two error/unparsed rows, only `gemini` substantive, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T132721Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T132721Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains seven `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, `gemini/low=3`, and `gemini/medium=2`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `9fd092c6d7a3bc4beeb6dd9389194931481521cbaa45dcba2a4443847d7a04a7`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit budget/dormancy/gateway env in expanded compose.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.boundary-guardrail.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Status and architecture claims remain unproven by live product-stack smoke: status proof has 42 lines, architecture scan has 483 lines, and no endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.architecture-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Product edits, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-agent invocation, DB progress mutation, and P0 advancement are blocked because local proof in a degraded cycle is advisory only.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T132721Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Positive single-agent claims that anchor existence, clean status, or static compose validity can move P0 are rejected as product-action or phase-advancement authorization.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T132721Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T132721Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T132721Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no product learning promoted.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T132721Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T132721Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; Manthan status clean	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T132721Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T132721Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T132721Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T134000Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T134000Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T13:52:39Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 24 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T135239Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T135239Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 24 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=1 low=3 medium=5`, `deepseek critical=3 high=8 medium=1`, and `gemini high=2 medium=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `b2ff11e566825758945dc7f030c6efdbbcc565faebc43a435800af7fa998ea3f`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	The selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof remains false progress because it proves older anchor prose and compose syntax only, not live root-stack smoke, selection A/B, or product/progress evidence.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T135239Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.anchor-and-script-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` is committed at current HEAD and names active stage `OS-O0`, while the older anchor still contains `Conduir loop P0` and lacks `OS-O0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 executable checks still fail because root smoke and selection A/B scripts are absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.anchor-and-script-proof.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth reports invalid configured tokens and no-op `copilot -p` reports no authentication information.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is emitted as the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the cycle DB had zero findings, that audit artifacts were absent, or that the direction document was uncommitted are rejected by settled host files and current HEAD proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T135239Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z	P0	Host review was healthy and selected `MAQ-024`, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T135239Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T135239Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T135239Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T135239Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T14:05:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 14 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T140555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T140555Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 14 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=1 low=4 medium=4`, `deepseek unparsed=1`, and `gemini critical=1 low=3`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `0caac3717049049f0f55da23d5263dd39e3d9029301c10fa481594c0f16fd088`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L3	none	REJECTED	The reviewer subclaim that the cycle DB and action queue do not exist is rejected by runtime file proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T140555Z.swarm.db`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T140555Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	`MANTHAN_PLATFORM_TRACKER.md` has zero anchor or `Conduir loop P0` references; tracker linkage remains a separate future lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.target-tracker-anchor-grep.txt`; grep exit `1`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit `MANTHAN_*` guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.compose-ports.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.compose-guardrail-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L8	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because GitHub CLI auth and no-op `copilot -p` both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.copilot-auth-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L9	phase-candidate	RECORDED	A later cycle must select exactly one plan-matching remediation lane with an explicit write set and proof command; no product lane was authorized here.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-GAP-REMEDIATION-PLAN-2026-06-08.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z	P0	Host review was healthy, but the selected Lane 0 anchor/static proof is non-advancing and product action stayed blocked by missing action-agent authentication plus incomplete P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T140555Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T140555Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T140555Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T140555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T14:20:48Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 15 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T142048Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T142048Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 15 `analysis_findings` rows split `deepseek critical=2 high=3 medium=4 low=1`, `gemini critical=1 high=1 medium=1 low=1`, and `claude/unparsed=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T142048Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	The Lane 0 anchor still lacks `OS-O0` and still contains `Conduir loop P0` after the blocked action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Copilot no-op readiness did not prove product-write capability; the scoped `MAQ-024` patch, shell, Python, and git-apply write attempts were denied and reported `Changes +0 -0`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.copilot-action-result.md`; post-action Manthan status/diff proof
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 60 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L7	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 cannot advance because no Manthan product patch landed and required anchor, smoke, selection, boundary, guardrail, endpoint-smoke, queue-validation, and DB-progress proofs remain incomplete.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 lane, blocked on action-agent write capability.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Successful `gh auth status` and no-op `copilot -p` readiness are rejected as sufficient proof that Copilot can write Manthan product files.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.copilot-action-result.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was assigned to Copilot, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked when the action agent could not write the one-file anchor patch.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T142048Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.copilot-action-result.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by Copilot write denial.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T142048Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T142048Z.copilot-action-result.md`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T142048Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T142048Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T14:36:35Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host review is degraded for action authorization: wrapper audit reported `OK`, but the reviewer section in host output ended with a `claude` executable error instead of reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T143635Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T143635Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 25 `analysis_findings` rows across all three agents, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d023f876d2b61fe6af8be16c3192c5e47eb989d3d2d22a27d3f7ee0e85ee5294`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remain incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and app-tier guardrail env remains incomplete.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Status and architecture claims remain unproven by live product-stack smoke: status proof has 42 lines and no endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had zero DB findings, zero-byte `swarm.out`, or uncommitted `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` are rejected by settled host files and current-HEAD proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T143635Z.swarm.out`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this degraded cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z	P0	Host review was degraded by missing reviewer synthesis; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T143635Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T143635Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T143635Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T143635Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T14:46:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 22 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T144655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T144655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 22 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=12`, and `gemini=2`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `bcc237916139e3831005b9a71b38d03a0d4951731b5891c310bf42d5e3a3ef58`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T144655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.compose-boundary-guardrails.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is refreshed as the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the cycle DB is suspicious because it is not UTF-8 text are rejected; the DB is SQLite and was validated through structured sqlite access.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T144655Z.swarm.db`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L9	none	REJECTED	The missing smoke and selection scripts are rejected as a contradiction; they are expected pending OS-O0 work, though their absence still blocks P0 gates.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T144655Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T144655Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T144655Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T144655Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T144655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T15:01:25Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T150125Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T150125Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek=10`, and `gemini=2`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `30023433a26e0643954aa5968b81f9ae1863b56b39ef3269466c63268c7acd57`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T150125Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, app-tier guardrail env is incomplete, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.compose-boundary-guardrails.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Direction-doc header drift and `CLAUDE.md` gate-path drift are real but outside this cycle's one-file anchor action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T150125Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.anchor-grep.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Claims that a clean worktree or static compose pass authorizes advancement are rejected by reviewer synthesis and current P0 gate proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T150125Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T150125Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by action-agent authentication failure.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T150125Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T150125Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T150125Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T150125Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T151436Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T151436Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T15:31:54Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 22 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer consensus in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T153154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T153154Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 22 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=9`, and `gemini=5`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d20a13e858fbf6a9286c5a8fe33f598d6155165d91468e51792197edcda6ea91`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T153154Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.anchor-grep.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier port/guardrail evidence is not sufficient, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 61 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.compose-boundary-guardrails.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Direction-doc header drift and `CLAUDE.md` gate-path drift are real but outside this cycle's one-file anchor action.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T153154Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the cycle DB is empty or that controller-side audit evidence can be judged absent from inside the Manthan repo are rejected by controller artifacts and direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T153154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T153154Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by action-agent authentication failure.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T153154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T153154Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T153154Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T153154Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T154317Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T154317Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T16:01:01Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 27 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T160101Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T160101Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 27 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=8`, `deepseek=14`, and `gemini=5`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `ab3d599a0d855a5af5d813b21657e7cd0ac9fbd1a1b5d4b1ea403c602c7a05e8`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T160101Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.anchor-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit shared guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, and status proof has 42 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.guardrail-env.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the cycle DB has zero findings or that missing smoke/selection scripts are an unexpected contradiction are rejected by direct proof and `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T160101Z.swarm.out`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, unavailable Docker live-health proof, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T160101Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; Docker live-health proof blocked; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by action-agent authentication failure.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T160101Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T160101Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T160101Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T160101Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T16:18:28Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 22 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T161828Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 22 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=9`, `deepseek=10`, and `gemini=3`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `203d33631fa74cc79dfde04227e2a693c6dfc5db8731ae3d5b845627c64b2c94`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement; reviewer ranked root smoke script creation as the separate genuine forward proof lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T161828Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.anchor-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, and status proof has 42 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.guardrail-env.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` remains the exact one-file anchor OS-O0 packet, while `MAQ-002` root smoke script creation remains a separate future lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`; host output reviewer section
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that the cycle DB has zero findings or that controller artifacts are absent from the Manthan repo are rejected by direct proof.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T161828Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was refreshed, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, empty product/progress DB tables, unavailable Docker live-health proof, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; Docker live-health proof blocked; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by action-agent authentication failure.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T161828Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T161828Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T161828Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T16:33:15Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review is degraded for action authorization: wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, status `0`, 8 rows, 2 error/unparsed rows, substantive `gemini` only, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T163315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T163315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 8 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/unparsed=1`, `deepseek/unparsed=1`, and `gemini critical=1 high=3 medium=2`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `f5062731d9a271498be2ff9ac8e48bdbdfa3c06ad513fe60052bba36c1fd8e7e`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passes, but live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.anchor-os-o0.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.anchor-conduir-p0.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and integration target proof has 36 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.guardrail-env.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.status-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.integration-lane0.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Degraded-cycle findings are advisory only and cannot authorize product edits, Copilot action, consensus language, queue validation, or phase advancement.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Raw degraded-cycle suggestions that pivot to `MAQ-002`, edit anchor wording, bind boundary ports, or restore guardrails are rejected as action authorizations for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T163315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T163315Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T163315Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T163315Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T163315Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T163315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T16:51:01Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 17 rows, 2 error rows, substantive `deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T165101Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T165101Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 17 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude/error=1`, `deepseek critical=4 high=5 medium=2 low=1`, and `gemini critical=1 high=2 medium=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `d8a58178cd579574bc7e92d199622443c894739077df9fdcd032a08c7e055ac5`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Candidate anchor/static compose proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not inspect controller DB/audit evidence, can pass incomplete regex-OR evidence, and proves no live stack health.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T165101Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.anchor-linkage.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.script-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit shared guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and integration proof has 36 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.guardrail-env.txt`; proof scans
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-002` is the reviewed root product-stack smoke-script lane for a later action-authorized cycle, with exact future write set `scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw claims that this cycle had zero DB findings, a zero-byte `swarm.out`, or only metadata rows are rejected by direct DB inspection and host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.db-inspection.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T165101Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-002` was emitted as a blocked future action packet, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure, unavailable Docker live-health proof, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T165101Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T165101Z.maq-002-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; Docker live-health proof blocked; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T165101Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T165101Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T17:07:45Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 27 rows, zero error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T170745Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T170745Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 27 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=2 low=4 medium=2`, `deepseek critical=3 high=5 medium=3 low=2`, and `gemini critical=1 high=3 medium=1 low=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `c54a112ce51dbb5631d9b8bb9b805b04b6e9f5e6467755c252a59b1d245fcfe6`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T170745Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.compose-config-q.status`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, `api`/`maestro-bridge` omit shared guardrail env, route proof has 53 lines, and status proof has 44 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.boundary-guardrail.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero in this Codex execution context.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.docker-compose-ps.err`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-024` is the current reviewed one-file Lane 0 anchor OS-O0 packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Host-reviewer claims that `gh`, Docker live inspection, and `copilot -p` are usable in the current action shell are rejected for this Codex execution context.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T170745Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.docker-compose-ps.err`
manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z	P0	Host review was healthy and `MAQ-024` was emitted as a blocked future action packet, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by action-agent authentication failure in this Codex context, unavailable Docker live-health proof, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T170745Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.maq-024-action-packet.md`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; Docker live-health proof blocked; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion, but product action remained blocked by action-agent authentication failure in this Codex execution context.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T170745Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T170745Z.copilot-probe.txt`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`; product action `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T170745Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T170745Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T17:23:47Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: wrapper audit `OK`, status `0`, 13 rows, one error/unparsed row, substantive `claude`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T172347Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T172347Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 13 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=1 low=4 medium=4`, `deepseek unparsed=1`, and `gemini high=1 low=1 medium=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `cd3231671d09c9f9d3db22319a8164002c4c64a62bdeb412153e7807b7d78c59`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T172347Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L4	accepted	PROMOTED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent or non-executable.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.anchor-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L5	accepted	PROMOTED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports publish without app-tier `host_ip`, route proof has 53 lines, status proof has 42 lines, and no live endpoint smoke ran.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.compose-boundary.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because persisted GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The next product action should be a real boundary validation or root-smoke lane, but this cycle did not authorize an exact write set for either lane.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T172347Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L8	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live stack health and endpoint smoke were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.docker-ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L9	none	REJECTED	A transient console no-op action-agent success is rejected as product-action authorization because persisted cycle proof failed authentication.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z-L10	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z	P0	Host review was healthy and controller proof was recorded, but product action and phase advancement stayed blocked by missing exact product-lane authorization, action-agent authentication failure, unavailable Docker live-health proof, empty product/progress DB tables, and unmet P0 gates.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T172347Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T172347Z.db-inspection.json`	full-swarm DB audit `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT` and `BLOCKED_SCOPE`; Docker live-health proof blocked; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T172347Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T172347Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T17:39:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host review is degraded for action authorization: status file is `0`, but wrapper audit reports `DEGRADED`, and host output says only Claude produced usable findings while DeepSeek and Gemini emitted error/unparsed rows.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T173923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T173923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 9 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude=7`, `deepseek=1 error`, and `gemini=1 error`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `6046a195f0e35f30c85df19224525092b43e78c181403681ab9246ebc0121dc3`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passed, but it remains insufficient phase-exit evidence because it does not boot or probe the product stack and `docker-compose ps` failed with Docker socket `operation not permitted`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor and script gates still fail: the anchor lacks `OS-O0`, still contains `Conduir loop P0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B executables are absent or non-executable.	`docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary and guardrail evidence remain incomplete: app-tier ports `47000`, `47001`, `47002`, `47003`, and `27000` publish without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines including write/admin surfaces; status proof has 42 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Live endpoint smoke and product-stack health were not proven because Docker daemon access is denied in this controller session.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer suggestions to create both scripts or rewrite the anchor are rejected as product-action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T173923Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T173923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T173923Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T173923Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T173923Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T173923Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T173923Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T175131Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T175131Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T180459Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T180459Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T180459Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T18:18:55Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded for action authorization: status file `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, 14 rows, three error rows, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T181855Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T181855Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 14 `analysis_findings` rows split `deepseek critical=3 high=4 medium=3 low=2`, `gemini error=1`, and `claude unparsed=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `2489752cd736b0c690b6425327e03cbe134d7fe6fffe920d1b7844ea28389229`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passed, but live product-stack health and endpoint smoke are blocked because `docker-compose ps` cannot access the Docker socket.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, the direction doc names `OS-O0`, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.p0-spot-checks.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.anchor-status.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports `47002`, `47003`, `47001`, `47000`, and `27000` publish without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines including write/admin routes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.boundary-guardrail.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The target tracker has generic/historical Phase 0 or swarm mentions but no current OS-O0/P0 loop exit-evidence row.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.target-tracker-proof.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Raw claim that the cycle DB has zero `analysis_findings` is rejected by direct DB inspection.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.db-inspection.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, action-packet refresh, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T181855Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T181855Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no product learning promoted.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T181855Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T181855Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T181855Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T181855Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T181855Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T183225Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T183225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T18:46:36Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded for action authorization: status file `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, 9 rows, one error row, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T184636Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T184636Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 9 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=2 low=3 medium=2`, `deepseek unparsed=1`, and `gemini error=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero except `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `704a0e5047fdbd93d481e40b9d8c984883bda501750f18629b88015e58b5f569`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passed, but live product-stack health and endpoint smoke are blocked because `docker-compose ps` cannot access the Docker socket.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, the direction doc names `OS-O0`, the direction doc self-labels uncommitted while tracked, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.anchor-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.script-ls.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports `47002`, `47003`, `47001`, `47000`, and `27000` publish without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines including write/admin routes.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.route-write-admin.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Target tracker and architecture claims remain insufficient as exit evidence: targeted tracker grep found no current OS-O0/P0 loop exit-evidence row, and architecture claim proof was not live-smoked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.target-tracker-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.architecture-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer suggestions to create scripts, rewrite the anchor, or bind boundary ports are rejected as product-action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T184636Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T184636Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, action-packet refresh, DB progress mutation, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, action-packet refresh, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T184636Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T184636Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T184636Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T184636Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T184636Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T18:59:58Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded for action authorization: status file `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, 10 rows, one error row, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T185958Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T185958Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 10 `analysis_findings` rows split `claude high=2 medium=3 low=3`, `deepseek unparsed=1`, and `gemini error=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero except `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `c765bed3441a0a1ab05f1e2f82df070caa32693fca75aec91552687dc7447fc1`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passed, but live product-stack health and endpoint smoke are blocked because `docker-compose ps` cannot access the Docker socket.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.compose.ps.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, the direction doc names `OS-O0`, the direction doc self-labels draft/uncommitted while tracked, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.anchor-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.script-ls.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports `47002`, `47003`, `47001`, `47000`, and `27000` publish without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines including 15 write/admin-related lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.route-write-admin.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Target tracker and architecture claims remain insufficient as exit evidence: targeted tracker grep found no current OS-O0/P0 loop exit-evidence row, and architecture claim proof was not live-smoked.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.target-tracker-proof.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.architecture-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer suggestions to create scripts, rewrite the anchor, update tracker linkage, or bind boundary ports are rejected as product-action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T185958Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T185958Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, action-packet refresh, DB progress mutation, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, action-packet refresh, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T185958Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T185958Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T185958Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T185958Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T185958Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T19:13:15Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was healthy for review coverage: status file `0`, wrapper audit `OK`, 21 rows, zero audit-counted error rows, substantive `claude`/`deepseek`/`gemini`, and reviewer synthesis detected in host output.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T191315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T191315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.review-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains 21 `analysis_findings` rows split `deepseek critical=2 high=5 medium=5 low=1`, `claude high=2 medium=3 low=2`, and `gemini error=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `e7d936a4aa490dc89629cade6d1aaca05f902f48bdcbf842d2b392cda66e83a2`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L3	accepted	PROMOTED	Static anchor/config proof remains false progress for phase advancement because it does not build, boot, healthcheck, live-probe, prove selection behavior, close boundary posture, or record product progress.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T191315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.compose.expanded.yml`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, the direction doc names `OS-O0`, the direction doc self-labels draft/uncommitted while tracked, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.anchor-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.script-ls.txt`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports `47002`, `47003`, `47001`, `47000`, and `27000` publish without app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines and status proof has 42 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.boundary-bindings.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L6	accepted	PROMOTED	Manthan product edits are blocked because captured GitHub/Copilot action-agent probes both exited nonzero.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.copilot-probe.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L7	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`MAQ-001` is the current blocked one-file boundary action packet for a later action-authorized cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, same-pass multi-lane edits, manual action-agent substitution, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.review-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z-L9	none	REJECTED	Raw or overstated claims that the cycle DB is empty, that the missing smoke script filename is `scripts/manthan-smoke.sh`, or that documented OS-O0 script absence is unexpected are rejected by direct proof and reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T191315Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.db-inspection.json`; `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z	P0	Host review was healthy; static Lane 0 proof was rejected as false progress; blocked `MAQ-001` boundary action packet emitted; no Manthan product action, endpoint smoke, queue validation, DB progress mutation, manual substitution, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T191315Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.review-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T191315Z.maq-001-action-packet.md`	swarm health `OK`; action status `BLOCKED_ACTION_AGENT`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	accepted	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T191315Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T191315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T19:26:34Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L1	accepted	PROMOTED	Host swarm review was degraded for action authorization: status file `0`, wrapper audit `DEGRADED`, three analysis rows, two error rows, and missing DB-detected reviewer synthesis.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T192634Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T192634Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L2	accepted	PROMOTED	The cycle DB contains only degraded analysis rows split `deepseek/unparsed=1`, `claude/unparsed=1`, and `gemini/error=1`, with tracked product/progress tables at zero except `promotion_circuit_breaker=1`.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.db-inspection.json`; DB SHA `92df5e498c89f823b4ff479d67e0bc1667372a8340d6486d666209db0555db65`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static root compose validation passed, but live product-stack health and endpoint smoke are blocked because `docker-compose ps` cannot access the Docker socket.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	P0 anchor/script gates still fail: the anchor says `Conduir loop P0`, the direction doc names `OS-O0` and self-labels draft/uncommitted while tracked, and root smoke plus selection A/B scripts are missing.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Boundary evidence remains incomplete: app-tier ports `47002`, `47003`, `47001`, `47000`, and `27000` publish without adjacent app-tier `host_ip`; route proof has 53 lines.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.port-evidence.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.routes.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.status-claims.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Architecture and status claims remain insufficient as exit evidence: architecture proof has 579 lines but no live product-stack smoke in this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.architecture-claims.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L7	none	REJECTED	Degraded reviewer suggestions to create scripts, rewrite the anchor, update target selection, or bind boundary ports are rejected as product-action authorization for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T192634Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T192634Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z-L8	none	REJECTED	Manthan product execution, endpoint smoke, action-agent invocation, queue validation, action-packet refresh, DB progress mutation, consensus language, and P0 advancement are rejected for this cycle.	`delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-STATE.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z	P0	Host review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory/controller findings only; no Manthan product action, action-agent invocation, endpoint smoke, queue validation, action-packet refresh, DB progress mutation, consensus claim, or phase advancement occurred.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T192634Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T192634Z.db-inspection.json`	swarm health `DEGRADED`; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no Manthan product edit; no endpoint smoke; no queue validation; no phase advancement.	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T192634Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T192634Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T192634Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T193926Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T193926Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T193926Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T194226Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T194226Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T194226Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T194623Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T194623Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T194623Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T194913Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T194913Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T194913Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T195235Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T195235Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T195235Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T195625Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T195625Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T195625Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T195837Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T195837Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T195837Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T200156Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T200156Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T200156Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T200442Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T200442Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T200442Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T200748Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T200748Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T200748Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T201107Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T201107Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T201107Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T201423Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T201423Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T201423Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T201713Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T201713Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T201713Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T202052Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T202052Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T202052Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T202839Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T202839Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T202839Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T203231Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T203231Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T203231Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T203540Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T203540Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T203540Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T203816Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T203816Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T203816Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T204644Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T204644Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T204644Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T204939Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T204939Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T204939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T205352Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T205352Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T205352Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T205751Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T205751Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T205751Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T210136Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T210136Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T210136Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T210941Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T210941Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T210941Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T211242Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T211242Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T211242Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T211534Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T211534Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T211534Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T211917Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T211917Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T211917Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T212242Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T212242Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T212242Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T212609Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T212609Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T212609Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T213000Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T213000Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T213000Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T213339Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T213339Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T213339Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T213722Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T213722Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T213722Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T214048Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T214048Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T214048Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T214400Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T214400Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T214400Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T214828Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T214828Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T214828Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T215407Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T215407Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T215407Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T215608Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T215608Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T215608Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T215902Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T215902Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T215902Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T220222Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T220222Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T220222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T220435Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T220435Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T220435Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T220832Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T220832Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T220832Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T22:15:25Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z-L1	none	RECORD	Swarm review did not satisfy healthy quorum: `swarm_health=DEGRADED`, one substantive agent, no reviewer synthesis.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T221525Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z-L2	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Anchor-phase naming and phase drift confirmed (`Conduir loop P0` vs `OS-O0`).	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.anchor.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.phase-drift.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Lane 0 proof target remains file-static (`docker-compose.yml`) without an executable boundary proof command in this run.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.anchor.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T221525Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Outward-boundary command evidence still lacks host-IP constrained app-tier bindings; route scan includes service endpoints.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.boundary-ports.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.routes.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Action-agent readiness and live-stack checks are blocked: invalid GitHub auth, invalid/copied `copilot -p` invocation, and Docker socket `operation not permitted`.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z	P0	Host swarm review was degraded; deterministic local proof recorded advisory findings only. No product action or phase advancement executed.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T221525Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-learning-artifact.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-cycle-manifest.md`	no phase advancement; current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; action-agent and Docker health checks blocked	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T221525Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T221525Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T221525Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T221525Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T222041Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222041Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T222747Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T222747Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T222747Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T22:36:56Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z-L1	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Host and local evidence confirm category drift: `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` remains `Conduir loop P0` while `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` uses `OS-O0` language.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T223656Z.anchor-check.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T223656Z.anchor-vs-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z-L2	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The active proof command pass (`docker-compose config -q`) is configuration-only and does not cover P0 exit requirements (runtime smoke, type-check/test, and validated DB-audit advancement criteria).	`conduir-evolution/delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-PHASE-GATES.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T223656Z.validation.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T223656Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	App-tier ports still publish without adjacent `local-service` loopback host binding, while infra ports remain loopback-bound.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T223656Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T223656Z.compose-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Full-swarm health summary is inconsistent (`health: OK`) while `reviewer_synthesis_detected` is false, so this run remains evidence-limited for phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T223656Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T223656Z.swarm.out`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z	P0	Host swarm review completed with 21 findings and mixed review metadata; deterministic local proof completed with compose checks; no product action, no gate closure.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T223656Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T223656Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T223656Z-learning-artifact.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T223656Z-cycle-manifest.md`	swarm health `DEGRADED` (synthesis flag false); current Manthan HEAD `a3e1e89`; no phase advancement	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T223656Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T223656Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T22:46:24Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z-L1	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Conduir loop naming in `docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md` conflicts with `docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` stage taxonomy.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T224624Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T224624Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z-L2	phase-candidate	RECORDED	The cycle’s lane objective targets a committed artifact, so the productive next step is correction-in-place, not regeneration.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T224624Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z-L3	none	REJECTED	`docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md` says `DRAFT for review` while committed, a stale self-descriptor requiring separate alignment handling, but this cycle remains review-only.	`conduir-evolution/docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	App-tier ports remain non-loopback-bound in expanded compose evidence; boundary readiness is incomplete before smoke proof.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T224624Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z-L5	none	RECORDED	Full-swarm health was OK with 3 substantive agents, but no action was executed because no safe, authenticated action path is available in this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T224624Z.swarm.status`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-learning-audit.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z	P0	Host review completed (health OK) with lane-0 semantic/document-correctness findings; no Manthan action executed; no phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T224624Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `0`; host status delta `unchanged`; active phase remained P0	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z	P0	Nested cycle completed with host outputs and DB audit.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T224624Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `0`; DB row_count `19`; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T224624Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T224624Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T23:01:23Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z-L1	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Anchor naming violates phase discipline (`Conduir loop P0`) relative to canonical OS-O0 stage language.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T225718Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `conduir-evolution/docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z-L2	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Lane-0 objective was mis-scoped (`root product-stack` + `docker-compose.yml`) versus OS-O0 required deliverables (`manthan-root-smoke.sh`, `manthan-selection-ab.sh`).	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T225718Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Static `docker-compose config -q` output was not considered proof for P0 gate advancement; no runtime smoke/path gating was executed.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T225718Z.proof.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T225718Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z-L4	accepted	RECORDED	Manthan HEAD was clean for this cycle (`git status --short` empty); cycle was review-only.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T225718Z.proof.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T225718Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z-L5	none	REJECTED	The raw `uncommitted/zero-DB` blocker framing from a single analyst was rejected by reviewer synthesis and did not block this cycle's execution.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T225718Z.swarm.out`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T225718Z-swarm-db-audit.json`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z	P0	Host review healthy (3 agents, reviewer synthesis true, 20 findings), objective mismatch and false-progress risk confirmed, no product action executed.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T225718Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T225718Z-learning-artifact.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T225718Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T225718Z.proof.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T225718Z.swarm.out`	exit status `0`; row_count `20`; `reviewer_synthesis_detected`: true; action status: no-phase-advancement	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T225718Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T225718Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z - P0 - 2026-06-11T23:04:30Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L1	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Host review remains `DEGRADED`; `swarm_health` is `DEGRADED` with missing reviewer synthesis, so this run cannot authorize product action or phase advancement.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T230430Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T230430Z.swarm.status`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L2	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Phase-name drift remains unresolved: the prior static anchor/Direction evidence is still reflected in cycle-local proof.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.anchor-direction-grep`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.anchor-vs-direction.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L3	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Objective and proof command set still do not reflect OS-O0 lane requirements (`manthan-root-smoke.sh`, `manthan-selection-ab.sh`).	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260611T230430Z.md`
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	`scripts/manthan-root-smoke.sh` and `scripts/manthan-selection-ab.sh` are still missing/non-executable.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.anchor-existence.txt`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.anchor-direction-grep.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L5	phase-candidate	RECORDED	App-tier ports remain published without explicit `local-service` host bindings in compose expansion evidence.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.boundary-ports.txt`
manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z-L6	phase-candidate	RECORDED	Action path is blocked by auth and runtime-check constraints (`gh auth status`, `copilot -p`, and `docker-compose ps` failures), so no executable proof lane can run this cycle.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z	P0	Host review degraded; deterministic local proof executed for advisory checks only; no product action or phase movement recorded; next target remains guarded review-only execution in P0.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T230430Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T230430Z-learning-artifact.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T230430Z-learning-audit.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260611T230430Z.local-proof.md`	exit status `swarm-health=DEGRADED` from host/DB audit; no phase advancement	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T230430Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T230430Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T230430Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T231206Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T231206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T231925Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T231925Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T231925Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T232403Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T232403Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T232403Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T233023Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T233023Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T233023Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T233458Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T233458Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T233458Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T234235Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T234235Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T234235Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T234300Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T234300Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T234300Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T234323Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T234323Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T234323Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T234344Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T234344Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T234344Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T234734Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T234734Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T234734Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-11	manthan-phase-20260611T235115Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T235115Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T235115Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260611T235638Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260611T235638Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260611T235638Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T000007Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T000007Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T000007Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T000510Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T000510Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T000510Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T001014Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T001014Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T001014Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T001241Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T001241Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T001241Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T001530Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T001530Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T001530Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T001856Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T001856Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T001856Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T002158Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T002158Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T002158Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `engine-status-changed`; status delta `unchanged,engine_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T002448Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T002448Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T002448Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T002825Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T002825Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T002825Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T003140Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T003140Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T003140Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T003455Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T003455Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T003455Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T004018Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T004018Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T004018Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T004505Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T004505Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T004505Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T004859Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T004859Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T004859Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T005241Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T005241Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T005241Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T005521Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T005521Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T005521Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T005824Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T005824Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T005824Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T010355Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T010355Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T010355Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T010655Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T010655Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T010655Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T010935Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T010935Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T010935Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T011259Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T011259Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T011259Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T011656Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T011656Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T011656Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T012050Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T012050Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T012050Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T012400Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T012400Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T012400Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T012746Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T012746Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T012746Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T013057Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T013057Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T013057Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T013442Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T013442Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T013442Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T013715Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T013715Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T013715Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T014040Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T014040Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T014040Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T014424Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T014424Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T014424Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T014643Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T014643Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T014643Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T015029Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T015029Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T015029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T015447Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T015447Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T015447Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T015821Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T015821Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T015821Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T020104Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T020104Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T020104Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T020502Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T020502Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T020502Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T020725Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T020725Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T020725Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T021029Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T021029Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T021029Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T021351Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T021351Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T021351Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T021733Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T021733Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T021733Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T022113Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T022113Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T022113Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T022441Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T022441Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T022441Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T022934Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T022934Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T022934Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T023315Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T023315Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T023315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T023742Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T023742Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T023742Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T024037Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T024037Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T024037Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T024318Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T024318Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T024318Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T024607Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T024607Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T024607Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T024955Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T024955Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T024955Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T025416Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T025416Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T025416Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T025640Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T025640Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T025640Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T025954Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T025954Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T025954Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T030234Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T030234Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T030234Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T030702Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T030702Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

Cycle Summary - manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z - P0 - 2026-06-12T03:16:37Z

Learning ID	Promotion	Status	Summary	Evidence
manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z-L1	phase-candidate	VERIFIED	Host-swarm review remains execution-degraded (`reviewer_synthesis_detected: false`) despite 3 agents and no DB errors.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T031637Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T031637Z.swarm.out`
manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z-L2	phase-candidate	VERIFIED	Control naming collision persists between `Conduir loop P0` and `OS-O0` authority language.	`manthan/docs/SWARM-EVOLUTION-LOOP-ANCHOR.md`; `manthan/docs/DIRECTION-24-MONTH.md`
manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z-L3	phase-candidate	VERIFIED	OS-O0 smoke and selection scripts are still missing/non-executable.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T031637Z.script-deliverables.txt`; `manthan/scripts`
manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z-L4	phase-candidate	RECORDED	App-tier ports remain without loopback host binding in compose; boundary posture not yet proven for read-only outward constraints.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T031637Z.compose.expanded.yml`
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z	P0	`DEGRADED`	4 phase-candidate	none	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T031637Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T031637Z-learning-artifact.json`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T031637Z.local-proof.md`	Degraded full-swarm review with advisory local proof only; no product edits, no action queue execution, no phase advance.
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T031637Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T031637Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T032242Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T032242Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032242Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T032552Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T032552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T033315Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033315Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T033843Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T033843Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T034544Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T034544Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T035150Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035150Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T035627Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T035627Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T035627Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T040216Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040216Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T040822Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T040822Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T041305Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T041305Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T042111Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T042111Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T042111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T042442Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T042442Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T042442Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T042828Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T042828Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T042828Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T043140Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T043140Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T043140Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T043657Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T043657Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T043657Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T043927Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T043927Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T043927Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T044418Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T044418Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T044418Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T044715Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T044715Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T044715Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T045024Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T045024Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T045024Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T045633Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T045633Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T045633Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T050025Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T050025Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T050025Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T050347Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T050347Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T050347Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T050705Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T050705Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T050705Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T051034Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T051034Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T051034Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T051331Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T051331Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T051331Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T051709Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T051709Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T051709Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T051939Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T051939Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T051939Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T052307Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T052307Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T052307Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T052723Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T052723Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T052723Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T052959Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T052959Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T052959Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T053247Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T053247Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T053247Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T053536Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T053536Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T053536Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T053920Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T053920Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T053920Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T054158Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T054158Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T054158Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T054531Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T054531Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T054531Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T054849Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T054849Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T054849Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T055148Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T055148Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T055148Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T055622Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T055622Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T055622Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T060109Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T060109Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T060109Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T060320Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T060320Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T060320Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T060636Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T060636Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T060636Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T060940Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T060940Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T060940Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T061236Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T061236Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T061236Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T061540Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T061540Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T061540Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T061935Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T061935Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T061935Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T062217Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T062217Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T062217Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T062523Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T062523Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T062523Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T062826Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T062826Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T062826Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T063231Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T063231Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T063231Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T063555Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T063555Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T063555Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T063922Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T063922Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T063922Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T064222Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T064222Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T064222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T064747Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T064747Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T064747Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T065133Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T065133Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T065133Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T065605Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T065605Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T065605Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T065912Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T065912Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T065912Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T070231Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T070231Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T070231Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T070633Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T070633Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T070633Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T070912Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T070912Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T070912Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T071841Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T071841Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T071841Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T072116Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T072116Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T072116Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged,conduir_changed`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T072434Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T072434Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T072434Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T072754Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T072754Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T072754Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T073113Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T073113Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T073113Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T073510Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T073510Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T073510Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T073853Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T073853Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T073853Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T074222Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T074222Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T074222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T074540Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T074540Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T074540Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T074835Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T074835Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T074835Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T075445Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T075445Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T075445Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T075752Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T075752Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T075752Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T080142Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T080142Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T080142Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T080524Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T080524Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T080524Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T080827Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T080827Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T080827Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T081111Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T081111Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T082706Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T082706Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

20260612T083148Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T083148Z`	`P0`	`OK`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T083148Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`, `L6`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083148Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083148Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083148Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083148Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T083148Z.compose.expanded.yml`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T083148Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/cycle-packet-20260612T083148Z.md`	Verified lane-0 naming/boundary blockers and action-auth blocker; full-swarm review is present and no phase-advance action executed.
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T083148Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083148Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T083648Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T083648Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T084351Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T084351Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T085206Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085206Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED

20260612T085947Z Cycle Summary

run id	phase	health	promoted	rejected	evidence	summary
`manthan-phase-20260612T085947Z`	`P0`	`DEGRADED`	phase-candidate: `manthan-phase-20260612T085947Z-L1`, `L2`, `L3`, `L4`, `L5`	none	`delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z-learning-audit.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z-cycle-manifest.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z-learning-artifact.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z-swarm-db-audit.json`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T085947Z.swarm.out`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z.local-proof.md`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T085947Z.host-binding.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T085947Z.gh-auth-status.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T085947Z.copilot-probe.txt`; `delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/20260612T085947Z.docker-ps.txt`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-EXECUTION-TRACKER.md`; `delivery/MANTHAN-SWARM-ACTION-QUEUE.md`	Host review failed healthy-gate checks (`DEGRADED`, one substantive agent, no reviewer synthesis). Local proof confirms action-agent auth/runtime blockers and Lane 1 boundary drift but no Manthan product change occurred; phase remains `P0` and no gate advancement was executed.
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T085947Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T085947Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T085947Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `swarm-db-DEGRADED`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T090504Z	P0	Wrapper DB audit allowed completion.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T090504Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	full-swarm DB audit OK; status delta `unchanged`	guarded	phase-candidate	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T091453Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T091453Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T091453Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T091946Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T091946Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T091946Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T092232Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T092232Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T092232Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T092750Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T092750Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T092750Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T093209Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T093209Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T093209Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T093531Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T093531Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T093531Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T094002Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T094002Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T094002Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T094326Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T094326Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T094326Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T095045Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T095045Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T095045Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T095405Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T095405Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T095405Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T095730Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T095730Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T095730Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T100039Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T100039Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T100039Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T100353Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T100353Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T100353Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T100903Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T100903Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T100903Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T101211Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T101211Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T101211Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T101711Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T101711Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T101711Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T102052Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T102052Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T102052Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T102443Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T102443Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T102443Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T102925Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T102925Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T102925Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T103255Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T103255Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T103255Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T103552Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T103552Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T103552Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T104018Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T104018Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T104018Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T104343Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T104343Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T104343Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T104613Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T104613Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T104613Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T104917Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T104917Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T104917Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T105149Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T105149Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T105149Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T105404Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T105404Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T105404Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T105651Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T105651Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T105651Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T105901Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T105901Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T105901Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T110222Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T110222Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T110222Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T110503Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T110503Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T110503Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T110800Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T110800Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T110800Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T111035Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T111035Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T111035Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T111330Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T111330Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T111330Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T111807Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T111807Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T111807Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T112118Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T112118Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T112118Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T112423Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T112423Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T112423Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T112747Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T112747Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T112747Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T113225Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T113225Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T113225Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T113558Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T113558Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T113558Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T113909Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T113909Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T113909Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T114146Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T114146Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T114146Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T114454Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T114454Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T114454Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T114802Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T114802Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T114802Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T115057Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T115057Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T115057Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T115424Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T115424Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T115424Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T115744Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T115744Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T115744Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T115933Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T115933Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T115933Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED
2026-06-12	manthan-phase-20260612T120205Z	P0	Nested cycle degraded; no promoted learning.	`conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-swarm-phase-loop/logs/20260612T120205Z.log`; `conduir-evolution/delivery/reviews/manthan-learning-audit/20260612T120205Z-swarm-db-audit.json`	exit status `1`; status delta `unchanged`	degraded	none	RECORDED